cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

MB E-300 buy vs lease

tag
stancil70
Contributor

MB E-300 buy vs lease

I'm eyeing a 2018 MB E-300.  This will be my first true luxury car purchase -- currently in Passat, Jetta prior to that (both financed) and prior to that a BMW convertible but I paid cash for that.  

 

I've negotiated 14% off of sticker price and it's the end of the month so I know they really want me to come in to sign the deal.  My question is this -- buy vs lease?  

 

I've never leased before so I don't know what questions I should be asking.  What should I ask them about the lease details?  I do like the lease payments much better than the finance payments, though my credit is very good -- mid to high 700's with 100K annual income and 4% debt to income. 

 

BOA offers 2.84% for 72 months.  MB offered to match for financing, both with options of zero down, which I don't think is bad idea since there is a 14% off MSRP offer on the table.  

 

Any input/advice would be greatly appreciated.  

 

 

My Wallet: Chase Freedom Unlimited 2k; Chase Amazon Prime 30k; Chase IHG 500; Chase Disney 15k; Chase Mariott Bonvoy 23.7k; Barclays Carnival 11.1k; Barclay Rewards 1.9k; Cap 1 Savor 15k, Cap 1 Walmart 10k; Cap 1 QS 6.7k; Cap 1 Pottery Barn 18.2k; Discover It 12k; Citi Rewards 14.7k; Citi DC 14k; Citi Simplicity 16.8k; Citi Custom Cash 3k; Amex Goldno pre-set limit; Amex BCE 5.1k; Amex Hilton 40k; Amex Magnet 5.5k; Amex Macys 19.7k; Amex Delta 20k; BOA Cash Rewards 75k; BOA Travel Rewards 15.2k; Wells Fargo Active Cash 22k; Best Buy Visa 3.3; BP Visa 4k; Target MC 4k; Kohls 3k; Nordstrom 1k; Apple MC 15k; Penfed Power Cash 8.8k; Penfed Platinum 10k; Various Comenity MC/Visa 72.6k/ Various Synchrony MC/Visa 83.5k. Total Credit Lines: $597,150k, utilization less than 1%. FICO scores 775 - 800; Annual Income $250k
Message 1 of 7
6 REPLIES 6
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease

Buy vs Lease is a question only you can answer.  Do you drive alot?  If so, leasing isn't for you as you are giving an amount of miles you can drive per year.  Since you are new to leasing, I suggest you go to www.leaseguide.com for a quick crash course.  Also, the zero down is often just a catch phrase and will like pay some money out of pocket.  With leasing, you also have to factor in bank acquisition fees, dmv fees etc..  So weigh your options very carefully.

 

Have you thought about a lease take over?  That option is usually cheaper than starting a fresh lease.  What are the payments going to be if you were to buy or lease? 

Message 2 of 7
stancil70
Contributor

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease

STANCIL RATES.PNG

Thank you for your reply and for the very informative link.  I do have a 2nd car so I don't anticipate that mileage would be a problem, but I did have them quote me for 15k just to be safe.  The money factor here seems to be high (I get 5.04%) when I multiply the stated rate x 2400.  

My Wallet: Chase Freedom Unlimited 2k; Chase Amazon Prime 30k; Chase IHG 500; Chase Disney 15k; Chase Mariott Bonvoy 23.7k; Barclays Carnival 11.1k; Barclay Rewards 1.9k; Cap 1 Savor 15k, Cap 1 Walmart 10k; Cap 1 QS 6.7k; Cap 1 Pottery Barn 18.2k; Discover It 12k; Citi Rewards 14.7k; Citi DC 14k; Citi Simplicity 16.8k; Citi Custom Cash 3k; Amex Goldno pre-set limit; Amex BCE 5.1k; Amex Hilton 40k; Amex Magnet 5.5k; Amex Macys 19.7k; Amex Delta 20k; BOA Cash Rewards 75k; BOA Travel Rewards 15.2k; Wells Fargo Active Cash 22k; Best Buy Visa 3.3; BP Visa 4k; Target MC 4k; Kohls 3k; Nordstrom 1k; Apple MC 15k; Penfed Power Cash 8.8k; Penfed Platinum 10k; Various Comenity MC/Visa 72.6k/ Various Synchrony MC/Visa 83.5k. Total Credit Lines: $597,150k, utilization less than 1%. FICO scores 775 - 800; Annual Income $250k
Message 3 of 7
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease

Leasing versus buying is something that I've taken into account when purchasing my luxury vechiles. I spent a considerable amount on my latest car, and ended up leasing it. I didn't want to be on the hook for thousands of dollars of depreciation or damage if something happened to it that wasn't covered by an insurance policy, like the hard top being destroyed on my last vehicle.

 

 A lease made sense to my wallet, because if anything happens to the vehicle, it's not my problem. Considering that the E class just ended up on a list of fastest-depreciating vehicles I would have a hard time justifying purchasing instead of leasing without a lot of money down. 

Message 4 of 7
Kree
Established Contributor

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease


@DeeBee78wrote:

 

 A lease made sense to my wallet, because if anything happens to the vehicle, it's not my problem. 


I thought at turn-in people were responsible for any damage outside of normal wear/tear. 

Message 5 of 7
Schwartzinator
Frequent Contributor

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease


@Kreewrote:

@DeeBee78

I thought at turn-in people were responsible for any damage outside of normal wear/tear. 


I read that as the inevitable repairs that may start creeping up after the 3 year mark when the vehicle was turned in that they wouldn't need to worry about. 


Message 6 of 7
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: MB E-300 buy vs lease


@Schwartzinatorwrote:

@Kreewrote:

@DeeBee78

I thought at turn-in people were responsible for any damage outside of normal wear/tear. 


I read that as the inevitable repairs that may start creeping up after the 3 year mark when the vehicle was turned in that they wouldn't need to worry about. 


True, but I'm also talking about if the car is wrecked, like my last one was. Leases carry GAP coverage, so you won't get stuck with paying the difference between your car's value and how much you owe.

 

If you put $0 down on an E Class (like OP is talking about), and something happens to it that totals it out, you could be looking at a significant difference between the payoff and the value. 

Message 7 of 7
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.