My fingers twitch for the Arrival.
IMO one of the better travel cards based on rewards points earned on travel expenses...and...parking counts. I pay for employee parking. OH THE POINTS.
of course, PC normally loses any sign up bene's 
I just applied for the Arrival and got approved and didn't appyly for the Arrival+ due to the AF. 
I went the other way as I owned the Arrival+ and recently PC'ed to the Rewards card. IMO, most (if not every) cards will fit a certain niche of customers. With that said, the recent changes in the benefits of the Arrival+ did not match very well with my spending habits...throw in the AF of $89 (which I paid already) and it was an easy decision to walk away and PC.
Earlier, you mentioned that you do not travel much. The only way to get the ~2.1% redemption rate is to redeem against travel charges. That's really hard to do if you do not travel 
Making things even tougher, the minimum redemption amount is now $100 (up from $25). That part was the killer for me since I never had travel charges that met this amount (I have a CSP for scheduled travel purchases).
My advice is to really think about your spending habits and see if you come out ahead. Marketing says that the Arrival+ has "more prestige" but prestige means nothing if you if can't take advantage of the benefits to put money back in your pocket.
