Reply
Member
MCHammerFan
Posts: 14
Registered: ‎04-18-2012

Best cashback card for light spenders

I was reviewing cards and I'm trying to figure out what would be best as a cash back card for me. I was looking at the Chase Sapphire Preferred due to the no forex fee card but it was too travel oriented I already have a Capital One card but it only has a CL of $750 but it was almost my first CC and a BOA Plat Plus with a CL of $2000. The Amex blue cash cards seem tempting but I hear it is better for heavier spenders. Citi Dividends I hear is good but my family keeps telling me not to do business Citi. Right now I have two CC's that I basically PIF each time, but I'm not getting the best out of it. I'm probably going to just spend it on groceries/electronics/Paypal and it's going to be light spending ($200 per statement period and PIF max).
EQ: 707
TU: 743
Frequent Contributor
Brian_Trying_700
Posts: 446
Registered: ‎09-14-2011

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

Check Discover More quarterly they have different things that give 5% cash back.

Garden mode till 11/19/2013 Amex Zync 500 H-L I Discover More 1750 I Capital One Rewards 1750 I Barclay Apple 1500 I Macys 2000 I Orchard 400 I Walmart 2000 I Chase Freedom 1500 I Lowes 1K l Barclay NFL 1K l Wright Express gas 2500 l PayPal Debit MasterCard BusinessCard $ ?
Frequent Contributor
SamsungHDTV
Posts: 292
Registered: ‎10-25-2011

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders


MCHammerFan wrote:
I was reviewing cards and I'm trying to figure out what would be best as a cash back card for me. I was looking at the Chase Sapphire Preferred due to the no forex fee card but it was too travel oriented I already have a Capital One card but it only has a CL of $750 but it was almost my first CC and a BOA Plat Plus with a CL of $2000. The Amex blue cash cards seem tempting but I hear it is better for heavier spenders. Citi Dividends I hear is good but my family keeps telling me not to do business Citi. Right now I have two CC's that I basically PIF each time, but I'm not getting the best out of it. I'm probably going to just spend it on groceries/electronics/Paypal and it's going to be light spending ($200 per statement period and PIF max).


I wouldn't recommend the Chase Sapphire preferred for light spending. Solely because it has an $95 annual fee. Any card with annual fees usually needs a heavier spending to recoup the annual fee cost. Although with it's generous sign up bonus, the card is basically free for 5 years. Further more, its spending is 2% cash back on hotels and restaurants which is not in your list. It is a great card, but not for your purpose today.

 

I think the Amex blue cash card is a good bet. The one without an annual fee though. 3% cash back on supermarkets is what I like most and is on your list. Although I could not find if there was a cap to how much you earn or any fine print on the rewards program.

 

If you have a Chase checking account, I'd recommend the Chase Freedom. The cash back ratio is IMO the best for small purchases or everyday spending because of its rewards bonus if you have a Chase checking. I'll link you to the examples I've previously posted. Just ignore the part about Chase sapphire preferred.

 

http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/CSP-Freedom-Checking-Use-wisely/m-p/1355519

My contributions back to myfico forums:

The CSP-Freedom-Chase Checking Trifecta decoded:
http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/CSP-Freedom-Checking-Use-wisely/td-p/1355519
How to buy a car (First time car buyers)
http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Auto-Loans/How-to-buy-a-car-for-the-first-time-buyer/td-p/1923289
Established Contributor
Koop10010
Posts: 731
Registered: ‎02-15-2012

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

Chase Freedom and Amex Blue Cash Everyday are good cards.  Freedom is good with changing 5% categories, but they are capped at $1500 spend per 3 months.  Still, if you are going for $200 a month, that should be fine.  The Amex has permanent 3% on groceries with no cap or minimum spend, so it should definitely be considered.

FICOs (2/24/12): EX 752, EQ 740
Chase Sapphire Preferred, Freedom; American Express PR Gold, Blue Cash Everyday
Frequent Contributor
Mike360
Posts: 397
Registered: ‎03-19-2010

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

Chase Freedom for light spender. Discover More is just a bad choice IMO
~~In my wallet: Best Buy $7500, Dell Preferred $5500, Chase Freedom $3500, Barclays NFL Extra Points $3300, Sears $2800, CapOne Platinum $2000, Kohls $1500, Bill Me Later $1015, Target $200
Established Contributor
Koop10010
Posts: 731
Registered: ‎02-15-2012

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders


Mike360 wrote:
Chase Freedom for light spender. Discover More is just a bad choice IMO

I agree, I've never even considered Discover despite the numerous pre-approvals they've sent me.  The .25% on general spending for the first $3,000 per year is pathetic.  This makes the More a very niche card that is typically only good for the few 5% categories.  If you want a solid, general use cashback card there are better options.

FICOs (2/24/12): EX 752, EQ 740
Chase Sapphire Preferred, Freedom; American Express PR Gold, Blue Cash Everyday
Established Member
ShallRecoverIt
Posts: 16
Registered: ‎04-14-2012

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

[ Edited ]

Koop10010 wrote:

Mike360 wrote:
Chase Freedom for light spender. Discover More is just a bad choice IMO

I agree, I've never even considered Discover despite the numerous pre-approvals they've sent me.  The .25% on general spending for the first $3,000 per year is pathetic.  This makes the More a very niche card that is typically only good for the few 5% categories.  If you want a solid, general use cashback card there are better options.


I have a Discover More and couldn't agree more :smileywink:. I was almost surprised when I found out that I have to spend $3k just to get a measly 1% on all purchases! For a person with rather typical spending habits, (buying groceris, gas, paying bills, etc.) the card would really only be good for its 5% categories or maybe the 2% on automatically paid bills.

 

Otherwise, IMO, the Chase Freedom with 1% out of the gate and rotating 5% cateogires easily beats it. One of the Amex Blue cards would also be a good choice, if they are tailored to your particular spending habits.

Wallet:
Chase Freedom
Discover More

SD:
Walmart Discover
Cap1 Platinum
Contributor
Carbon44
Posts: 79
Registered: ‎02-15-2012

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

[ Edited ]

ShallRecoverIt wrote:

Koop10010 wrote:

Mike360 wrote:
Chase Freedom for light spender. Discover More is just a bad choice IMO

I agree, I've never even considered Discover despite the numerous pre-approvals they've sent me.  The .25% on general spending for the first $3,000 per year is pathetic.  This makes the More a very niche card that is typically only good for the few 5% categories.  If you want a solid, general use cashback card there are better options.


I have a Discover More and couldn't agree more :smileywink:. I was almost surprised when I found out that I have to spend $3k just to get a measly 1% on all purchases! For a person with rather typical spending habits, (buying groceris, gas, paying bills, etc.) the card would really only be good for its 5% categories or maybe the 2% on automatically paid bills.

 

Otherwise, IMO, the Chase Freedom with 1% out of the gate and rotating 5% cateogires easily beats it. One of the Amex Blue cards would also be a good choice, if they are tailored to your particular spending habits.


I would agree and disagree with some aspects. 

 

The Discover More card is great if: You purchase gas on your card because you earn 5% 6 months of the year at least in 2012. You earn 5% I believe 3 months of the year which is nice, and the October thru December (3 months) which is a big season for spending with Black Friday, Thanksgiving, and Christmas as well as whatever other Holidays you may celebrate you get 5% at Department Stores vs. Chase Freedom's 5% at only Khols and Bestbuy. Oh and I almost forgot for the Month of May Discover is giving 5% on Groceries so at least you get a month there. 

 

The Chase Freedom you got 5% on Amazon this year for January - March, but they had made that October - December to compete with Discovers 5% at department stores they would have blown Discover away. Chase also gives you 6 months of 2012 with 5% on Gas I beleive and at least 3 months of 5% on grocerys and another 3 months on Restaurants.  

 

As far as Utility Bills go Discover this year is giving 2% on Utility Bills while Chase gives 0. Heck if you use it for just say phone internet and tv and your bill is $120 thats just under $30 in cashback right there. Now pair that with other utilities or if it is more and you can make $50 easily. 

 

Last, but not least if you do a lot of online shopping the Shop Discover is better then what Chase offers in my opinion. I think on average Discover gives you more cashback on online purchases. I don't know if Chase does this I can't remember with my Freedom, but I know for sure Discover allows you to use your cashback towards Amazon purchases which is very nice and all ran for a month I beleive Free 1 or 2 day shipping when paying with your Discover earlier this year. 

 

*** Forgot to mention if you are just spending and not going to pay attention to the revolving categories then the Chase you get the 1% on all purchases where the Discover you get a measily 0.25% (Discover you need to fix this!) until you reach something like 2500 or $3000 spent. 

 

With Both Cards you get great customer service and if you make a little schedule for when to use your card on certain categories you can really bring

in more cashback. I will give the edge to the Discover More Card, but Chase is a VERY VERY good company. Hope this helps some people 

 

 

OH One LAST THING: if you can get the get $300 cashback when you spend $500 with the Chase Freedom then go for that and forget Discover because I think they only give you like $50-$150 where Chase gives you a huge incentive to sign up for the card

CSP, Discover IT, Amex BCE, Citi Dividend, and Amex Zync
Frequent Contributor
Chris123nTx
Posts: 439
Registered: ‎05-11-2007

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

I have a blue cash preferred and even though it has a yearly fee, just putting to grocery store stuff on there at 6% back more than pays for the fee for me. I dont spend alot either on credit cards or even cash, but that one makes the most sense for me. I do have a chase freedom as well and like it well enough that i use it pretty regularly. My citi cards dont get much use and i have a wells fargo that is pretty much useless as far as rewards go.
Frequent Contributor
Mike360
Posts: 397
Registered: ‎03-19-2010

Re: Best cashback card for light spenders

The reason I say chase freedom is because of the cash bank bonus for signing up. I've earned $367.54 so far and I've put about $4k on it since December. Yes discover more is good for certain things but the spent $3k to reach the 1% sucks.
~~In my wallet: Best Buy $7500, Dell Preferred $5500, Chase Freedom $3500, Barclays NFL Extra Points $3300, Sears $2800, CapOne Platinum $2000, Kohls $1500, Bill Me Later $1015, Target $200

myFICO is the consumer division of FICO. Since its introduction 20 years ago, the FICO® Score has become a global standard for measuring credit risk in the banking, mortgage, credit card, auto and retail industries. 90 of the top 100 largest U.S. financial institutions use the FICO Score to make consumer credit decisions.

>> About myFICO
FICO Score - The Score that matters
Click to Verify - This site chose VeriSign SSL for secure e-commerce and confidential communications.
www.myfico.com is a BBB Accredited Financial Service in San Rafael, CA
FOLLOW US Social Media Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+