Blessings, FightClub!
I understand you have a decision crisis, but you came here for help and that's what every one is trying to do for you -- that is, help you. It sounds to me like you've crossed all avenues, yet you keep coming up to the same cross road. What exactly do you want to do? Do you want to keep the cards and pay the high interest rates? Or, do you want to close the cards, pay the balances and move forward? It sounds to me like you want to rebuild, but you are discouraged at the time frame you THINK it will take to do so. Am I correct?
Not every one who has filed BK took the "cop-out" route, as you proclaim. Not all situations are the same. Unfortunately, I had to file Ch 13 BK when all of my resources were exhausted. A serious medical emergency (my child) forced me to take a long leave from work with no pay at all. That was my only means of income, but I had to stay home with my child who suffered a serious illness and had an extended stay in the hospital. He was cut off of his father's medical insurance without my knowledge so the hospitals where coming after me for payment of these bills. With medical expenses topping $200k, using CCs to buy medications, get food and gas, rent, utilities, etc., I simply could not do it any longer. So, filing BK was my last resort, not my "cop-out" decision. I have paid back my debt and don't feel embarrassed at all.
If none of these answers are what you like, perhaps you can get the advice you seek from an experienced attorney?
You may not see it now, but there is a light at the end of the tunnel.