cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard

tag
matchu
Valued Member

DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard

So after deliberating on whether I should go ahead and take a hit with a hard pull, I finally went ahead and requested a CLI on my Citi RZMC. It's currently at $1100 and I'd like it to at least match my others at $2500. They denied me, pulling Transunion, with the letter showing my score as a 165(WHAT???!!!!) saying I had a lack of credit history (AoAA is 5.2 Years) and high balances (Uti at 7%) Now, I can see here my score is a 706 and am utterly confused. So I call customer service, who then transfers me to a "credit specialist." Of course the "credit specialist" was outsourced and kept giving canned repsonses and really had no idea what she was doing. She told me to take it up with Transunion. 

 

I'm furious and really debating closing the account. 

Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
stillirise
New Contributor

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard

I know...I have that one too. My limit there is even lower than yours. The same thing happened to me...they claimed they pulled Eq and a collection acct was reported. I have all of the memberships. I could see the hard pull but there was no collection acct on any of my reports.

 

 

I felt the same way. I wanted to close the acct.

 

Dont do it....just dont use it.

It will help with your average acct age.

 

Use them to help get your score up then get better cards elsewhere.  Smiley Happy


@matchu wrote:

So after deliberating on whether I should go ahead and take a hit with a hard pull, I finally went ahead and requested a CLI on my Citi RZMC. It's currently at $1100 and I'd like it to at least match my others at $2500. They denied me, pulling Transunion, with the letter showing my score as a 165(WHAT???!!!!) saying I had a lack of credit history (AoAA is 5.2 Years) and high balances (Uti at 7%) Now, I can see here my score is a 706 and am utterly confused. So I call customer service, who then transfers me to a "credit specialist." Of course the "credit specialist" was outsourced and kept giving canned repsonses and really had no idea what she was doing. She told me to take it up with Transunion. 

 

I'm furious and really debating closing the account. 





Starting Score: EQ 680 EX 731 TU 697
Current Score: EQ 742 EX 752 TU 743
Goal Score: 800


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge
Message 2 of 9
gdale6
Moderator Emeritus

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@stillirise wrote:

I know...I have that one too. My limit there is even lower than yours. The same thing happened to me...they claimed they pulled Eq and a collection acct was reported. I have all of the memberships. I could see the hard pull but there was no collection acct on any of my reports.

 

 

I felt the same way. I wanted to close the acct.

 

Dont do it....just dont use it.

It will help with your average acct age. Closing an account does not hit your AAoA immediately as it remains on file up to 10 yrs post close.

 

Use them to help get your score up then get better cards elsewhere.  Smiley Happy






 

Message 3 of 9
gdale6
Moderator Emeritus

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@matchu wrote:

So after deliberating on whether I should go ahead and take a hit with a hard pull, I finally went ahead and requested a CLI on my Citi RZMC. It's currently at $1100 and I'd like it to at least match my others at $2500. They denied me, pulling Transunion, with the letter showing my score as a 165(WHAT???!!!!) saying I had a lack of credit history (AoAA is 5.2 Years) and high balances (Uti at 7%) Now, I can see here my score is a 706 and am utterly confused. So I call customer service, who then transfers me to a "credit specialist." Of course the "credit specialist" was outsourced and kept giving canned repsonses and really had no idea what she was doing. She told me to take it up with Transunion. 

 

I'm furious and really debating closing the account. 


Request a  hard copy of your TU report via US mail using the Citi denial (its free). You will get a letter from Citi as well, make copies of the CR & letter and mail them with your own letter requesting an immediate recon of the CLI request. If this request is denied then you can choose whether or not to close the account, if it has not been open for 24 months I would suggest you SD it and close it after 24 months of history report. Good luck Smiley Happy

Message 4 of 9
Shogun
Moderator Emeritus

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard

We'll a 165 score wouldn't be a FICO score, it doesn't go that low.  Must be a proprietary score as I don't know any formulas used that goes that low.

Starting Score: 504
July 2013 score:
EQ FICO 819, TU08 778, EX "806 lender pull 07/26/2013
Goal Score: All Scores 760+, Newest goal 800+
Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge

Current scores after adding $81K in CLs and 2 new cars since July 2013
EQ:809 TU 777 EX 790 Now it's just garden time!

June 2017 update: All scores over 820, just pure gardening now.
Message 5 of 9
bk510
Valued Contributor

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@gdale6 wrote:

@stillirise wrote:

I know...I have that one too. My limit there is even lower than yours. The same thing happened to me...they claimed they pulled Eq and a collection acct was reported. I have all of the memberships. I could see the hard pull but there was no collection acct on any of my reports.

 

 

I felt the same way. I wanted to close the acct.

 

Dont do it....just dont use it.

It will help with your average acct age. Closing an account does not hit your AAoA immediately as it remains on file up to 10 yrs post close.

 

Use them to help get your score up then get better cards elsewhere.  Smiley Happy






 +1 yes indeed

 

 photo QS visa_zps7zokw2wl.jpg photo QS visa_zps7zokw2wl.jpg photo Venture One_zpsigvttrlz.jpg photo Sony Visa_zpsxoradr1b.jpg photo USC Reward_zpslcvjfxmq.jpg photo Penfed Promise_zpsdg1y2dw2.png photo NasaFcu_zpswac3zwcu.jpg photo America_zpsuwx8rzdm.jpg photo LA-Kings-card_zpslbkyeqsz.png photo Barclay_zpslqv3i4tl.jpg photo BBVA_zpsqrhh7omh.jpg
 photo nfcu debit card_zpsprkh98jw.png photo nfcu visa siggy_zps0gjgyxje.png/ photo nfcu goReward card_zpsixhh1qcp.jpg photo sdfcu platinum card_zpspilihdiv.png  photo penfed reward cash_zpsyckxjc7y.png photo alliant visa_zpsaf4udfx0.jpg photo Citi Secured_zpsypzxi0jm.png photo fnbo platinum_zpsxfub6esb.png photo marvel-credit-card_zpsfkvc3ux5.png photo golden 1 CU_zpslhgxynjv.pngBurned AECitiChase
Message 6 of 9
bk510
Valued Contributor

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@Shogun wrote:

We'll a 165 score wouldn't be a FICO score, it doesn't go that low.  Must be a proprietary score as I don't know any formulas used that goes that low.


agree, must be some sort of system glitch.

 

But still though, 165?????

 

thats crazy!!

 photo QS visa_zps7zokw2wl.jpg photo QS visa_zps7zokw2wl.jpg photo Venture One_zpsigvttrlz.jpg photo Sony Visa_zpsxoradr1b.jpg photo USC Reward_zpslcvjfxmq.jpg photo Penfed Promise_zpsdg1y2dw2.png photo NasaFcu_zpswac3zwcu.jpg photo America_zpsuwx8rzdm.jpg photo LA-Kings-card_zpslbkyeqsz.png photo Barclay_zpslqv3i4tl.jpg photo BBVA_zpsqrhh7omh.jpg
 photo nfcu debit card_zpsprkh98jw.png photo nfcu visa siggy_zps0gjgyxje.png/ photo nfcu goReward card_zpsixhh1qcp.jpg photo sdfcu platinum card_zpspilihdiv.png  photo penfed reward cash_zpsyckxjc7y.png photo alliant visa_zpsaf4udfx0.jpg photo Citi Secured_zpsypzxi0jm.png photo fnbo platinum_zpsxfub6esb.png photo marvel-credit-card_zpsfkvc3ux5.png photo golden 1 CU_zpslhgxynjv.pngBurned AECitiChase
Message 7 of 9
wHiTeSoL
Valued Contributor

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@bk510 wrote:

@Shogun wrote:

We'll a 165 score wouldn't be a FICO score, it doesn't go that low.  Must be a proprietary score as I don't know any formulas used that goes that low.


agree, must be some sort of system glitch.

 

But still though, 165?????

 

thats crazy!!


Would you feel better if I told you thier score range is 100-166?Smiley LOL

Message 8 of 9
matchu
Valued Member

Re: DONE with Citi Best Buy Mastercard


@wHiTeSoL wrote:

@bk510 wrote:

@Shogun wrote:

We'll a 165 score wouldn't be a FICO score, it doesn't go that low.  Must be a proprietary score as I don't know any formulas used that goes that low.


agree, must be some sort of system glitch.

 

But still though, 165?????

 

thats crazy!!


Would you feel better if I told you thier score range is 100-166?Smiley LOL


Smiley LOL

 

I've PIF for the past four months with them, hoping to get in good with Citi now that my scores are all in 700s. I'm just pissed I wasted an inquiry on this crap. They're my only card left with an AF. The problem with closing it is, when Citi took over, they reported as a new account, so I lost the years I had it open before that. 

 

 

Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.