Reply
Frequent Contributor
niecey89
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎05-01-2007

Discover card- earned income

Good Morning Forum,

 

One of my girlfriends called me this morning (too early for drama I must say) about she received a letter from Discover about claiming them on her taxes. The information was correct except for the SS# which they have as the tax ID number. So I informed her to give them a call and see what it is all about. I also suggested that she pull her reports. Well after she talked to a rep about the letter because she settled a debt with them but did not pay the late fees and interest. She has to claim it as earned income on her taxes. WT *bleep*? She said she had settled with them months ago over $4000 but today they said that the unpaid about was over $5000. So the actual debt was over $10,000. WOW

 

Has anyone ever heard of claiming debt on your taxes as earned income? 

 

*mods move if in wrong forum* Thanks

FICO Scores 7/15/2008: EQ 600, TU 546, EX 490
9/17/08 - TU 571,12/17/08 649,3/16/09 638, 6/14 642
ScoreWatch 12/17/08 EQ 646, 1/2/ 09 664, 2/2/09 684,2/12/09 673, 2/16/09 688, 2/27 674,3/3 682,4/16 685, 6/28 679
1/2/09 EX 668 2/13/09 669
AS of NOV08 I am Credit card debit free. I AM A MYFICO.COM ADDICTED :smileyhappy: ~
Valued Contributor
Uborrow-Upay
Posts: 2,710
Registered: ‎10-16-2008

Re: Discover card- earned income

Yes, it's true.  And a lot of folks who walked away from their upside-down mortgages after a refi  to cash out equity  will find that out, too, if they haven't already.

 

If there are any accountants or tax people frequenting these boards, please chime in! 

Frequent Contributor
niecey89
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎05-01-2007

Re: Discover card- earned income

[ Edited ]
She just called me because she said it states that it is a cancelled debt and it is a 1099C form. But of course she leaves this information out of the conversation during the 4 times she has called me this morning. OH THE DRAMA.
Message Edited by niecey89 on 02-05-2009 09:02 AM
FICO Scores 7/15/2008: EQ 600, TU 546, EX 490
9/17/08 - TU 571,12/17/08 649,3/16/09 638, 6/14 642
ScoreWatch 12/17/08 EQ 646, 1/2/ 09 664, 2/2/09 684,2/12/09 673, 2/16/09 688, 2/27 674,3/3 682,4/16 685, 6/28 679
1/2/09 EX 668 2/13/09 669
AS of NOV08 I am Credit card debit free. I AM A MYFICO.COM ADDICTED :smileyhappy: ~
Mega Contributor
Creditaddict
Posts: 18,877
Registered: ‎10-23-2007

Re: Discover card- earned income

yes when a company writes off bad debt, you have to claim it on your taxes as ordinary income tax, Luckily only 1 account claimed me when I filed bankruptcy for about $2300.  Depending what tax bracket your in and the amount I guess it could be a big deal, mine didn't effect me.
Fico Scores: EQ 639 Navy, TU 665 GE, EX 677 Prosper (07-09-14)
You will have to put up Electric Fence to keep me in the garden!
Highest Limit: Fidelity Amex $25k (AU)
Lowest Limit: Buckle $250
Over 30 Cards in between :smileytongue:
Frequent Contributor
niecey89
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎05-01-2007

Re: Discover card- earned income


Creditaddict wrote:
yes when a company writes off bad debt, you have to claim it on your taxes as ordinary income tax, Luckily only 1 account claimed me when I filed bankruptcy for about $2300.  Depending what tax bracket your in and the amount I guess it could be a big deal, mine didn't effect me.

oh i see, i had bad debt but i never had that happen to me. Now I understand, all i know is that with her claiming the income it will bring her into the 6 figure tax bracket when she files her taxes. at least that is what she said. i am so glad i clean up my credit. 

FICO Scores 7/15/2008: EQ 600, TU 546, EX 490
9/17/08 - TU 571,12/17/08 649,3/16/09 638, 6/14 642
ScoreWatch 12/17/08 EQ 646, 1/2/ 09 664, 2/2/09 684,2/12/09 673, 2/16/09 688, 2/27 674,3/3 682,4/16 685, 6/28 679
1/2/09 EX 668 2/13/09 669
AS of NOV08 I am Credit card debit free. I AM A MYFICO.COM ADDICTED :smileyhappy: ~
Frequent Contributor
niecey89
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎05-01-2007

Re: Discover card- earned income

Thanks Credit Addict, I called and told her. She seems to be better about it. oh well, until her next freak out moment.
FICO Scores 7/15/2008: EQ 600, TU 546, EX 490
9/17/08 - TU 571,12/17/08 649,3/16/09 638, 6/14 642
ScoreWatch 12/17/08 EQ 646, 1/2/ 09 664, 2/2/09 684,2/12/09 673, 2/16/09 688, 2/27 674,3/3 682,4/16 685, 6/28 679
1/2/09 EX 668 2/13/09 669
AS of NOV08 I am Credit card debit free. I AM A MYFICO.COM ADDICTED :smileyhappy: ~
Contributor
CreditCardWhore
Posts: 76
Registered: ‎01-20-2009

Re: Discover card- earned income


niecey89 wrote:

Creditaddict wrote:
yes when a company writes off bad debt, you have to claim it on your taxes as ordinary income tax, Luckily only 1 account claimed me when I filed bankruptcy for about $2300.  Depending what tax bracket your in and the amount I guess it could be a big deal, mine didn't effect me.

oh i see, i had bad debt but i never had that happen to me. Now I understand, all i know is that with her claiming the income it will bring her into the 6 figure tax bracket when she files her taxes. at least that is what she said. i am so glad i clean up my credit. 


I have to chime in here on 2 things.  1 - this is absolutely taxable income to her - it is call cancellation of debt (COD) income.  The reasoning is simple, 1 minute she owed 5K the next she did not.  The counterparty is going to tax a 5K bad debt expense, hence she has to pick that up in her income to balance out the transaction.  Also they have no choice but to right her a 1099-C.  Not to do so would be a failure to file informational returns on their part and subject them to penalties.

 

2 - if this 5K COD income is putting her into 6 figure taxable income, why did she not pay the debt in the first place?!?! 

Valued Contributor
Uborrow-Upay
Posts: 2,710
Registered: ‎10-16-2008

Re: Discover card- earned income

CreditCardWhore, my thoughts exactly!  Kudos!!
Frequent Contributor
niecey89
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎05-01-2007

Re: Discover card- earned income

[ Edited ]

CreditCardWhore wrote:

niecey89 wrote:

Creditaddict wrote:
yes when a company writes off bad debt, you have to claim it on your taxes as ordinary income tax, Luckily only 1 account claimed me when I filed bankruptcy for about $2300.  Depending what tax bracket your in and the amount I guess it could be a big deal, mine didn't effect me.

oh i see, i had bad debt but i never had that happen to me. Now I understand, all i know is that with her claiming the income it will bring her into the 6 figure tax bracket when she files her taxes. at least that is what she said. i am so glad i clean up my credit. 


I have to chime in here on 2 things.  1 - this is absolutely taxable income to her - it is call cancellation of debt (COD) income.  The reasoning is simple, 1 minute she owed 5K the next she did not.  The counterparty is going to tax a 5K bad debt expense, hence she has to pick that up in her income to balance out the transaction.  Also they have no choice but to right her a 1099-C.  Not to do so would be a failure to file informational returns on their part and subject them to penalties.

 

2 - if this 5K COD income is putting her into 6 figure taxable income, why did she not pay the debt in the first place?!?! 


because she one of my friends that live way above their means and thinks that she got it like that. She has to have the best of everything for her and her son. when things go crazy she calls me for advice. What makes it so bad is that she is in law enforcement works mad overtime or moonlights 2-3 jobs to go on 2-3 trips a year (before she pays her bills). Budget to her is a joke. oh yeah i have been to eviction court with her a couple of times. she is a sad case. 

 

rob peter to pay paul but can not pay peter back

Message Edited by niecey89 on 02-05-2009 01:48 PM
FICO Scores 7/15/2008: EQ 600, TU 546, EX 490
9/17/08 - TU 571,12/17/08 649,3/16/09 638, 6/14 642
ScoreWatch 12/17/08 EQ 646, 1/2/ 09 664, 2/2/09 684,2/12/09 673, 2/16/09 688, 2/27 674,3/3 682,4/16 685, 6/28 679
1/2/09 EX 668 2/13/09 669
AS of NOV08 I am Credit card debit free. I AM A MYFICO.COM ADDICTED :smileyhappy: ~
Contributor
CreditCardWhore
Posts: 76
Registered: ‎01-20-2009

Re: Discover card- earned income

Got to say - I am between 5 and 150 times more annoyed with this situation than the guy making little money who just got a bit behind in his payments or made 1 or 2 poor choices

 


because she one of my friends that live way above their means and thinks that she got it like that. She has to have the best of everything for her and her son. when things go crazy she calls me for advice. What makes it so bad is that she is in law enforcement works mad overtime or moonlights 2-3 jobs to go on 2-3 trips a year (before she pays her bills). Budget to her is a joke. oh yeah i have been to eviction court with her a couple of times. she is a sad case. 

 

rob peter to pay paul but can not pay peter back

Message Edited by niecey89 on 02-05-2009 01:48 PM

 


myFICO is the consumer division of FICO. Since its introduction 20 years ago, the FICO® Score has become a global standard for measuring credit risk in the banking, mortgage, credit card, auto and retail industries. 90 of the top 100 largest U.S. financial institutions use the FICO Score to make consumer credit decisions.

>> About myFICO
FICO Score - The Score that matters
Fair Isaac Corporation is a BBB Accredited Financial Service in San Rafael, CA
FOLLOW US Social Media Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+