cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

Just wondering how often does the calendar categories overlap? is there a point to having both of these cards together? I understand if someone spends more than the $1500 cap on one of the cards and can use the other if they're in the same rotating category quarter, but if someone doesn't. Is this combo useless?
Message 1 of 10
9 REPLIES 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

No annual fees on either so having both doesn't cost anything.

 

Freedom Unlimited has the $150 sign up bonus which is easy to attain.  Discover It has double cashback the first year, IIRC.

Message 2 of 10
Cashbackjunky
Established Contributor

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

Interesting question. I'm wondering the same thing.

Cheers!
AmEx Blue Cash Preferred - $20k | | AmEx Cash Magnet - $20k | | Apple Card - $29k | | BofA Customized Cash - $96k | | BofA Customized Cash - $25k | | BofA Unlimited Cash - $30k | | CapOne Quicksilver - $16.25k | | CapOne Venture - $30k | | Chase Amazon - $26.7k | | Chase Freedom Unlimited - $24k | | Chase Freedom - $16k | | Chase Freedom Flex - $41k | | Citi Custom Cash - $17.9k | | Citi Rewards+ - $15.4k | | Discover It Cash Back - $18k | | Discover It Cash Back - $21.3k | |Discover It Travel - $14.5k | | Elan Max Cash Preferred- $15k | | PayPal Cashback Mastercard - $20k | | PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature - $12.5k | | PenFed Power Cash - $12.5k | | Synchrony Discount Tire Card - $25k | | Wells Fargo Autograph - $25k
837 INQ:
2
836 INQ:
3
825 INQ:
2

TCL: $571.05k CCs:23 AAoA: 6yr 1mo Util: ~1% Derog: 0

Mortgage: $215.1k Sonata Lease: $1.3k Palisade: $23.8k
Message 3 of 10
Cashbackjunky
Established Contributor

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

I found this through a Google search...

http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/Chase-Freedom-Calendar-v-s-Discover-Calendar/td-p/48434...

Cheers!
AmEx Blue Cash Preferred - $20k | | AmEx Cash Magnet - $20k | | Apple Card - $29k | | BofA Customized Cash - $96k | | BofA Customized Cash - $25k | | BofA Unlimited Cash - $30k | | CapOne Quicksilver - $16.25k | | CapOne Venture - $30k | | Chase Amazon - $26.7k | | Chase Freedom Unlimited - $24k | | Chase Freedom - $16k | | Chase Freedom Flex - $41k | | Citi Custom Cash - $17.9k | | Citi Rewards+ - $15.4k | | Discover It Cash Back - $18k | | Discover It Cash Back - $21.3k | |Discover It Travel - $14.5k | | Elan Max Cash Preferred- $15k | | PayPal Cashback Mastercard - $20k | | PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature - $12.5k | | PenFed Power Cash - $12.5k | | Synchrony Discount Tire Card - $25k | | Wells Fargo Autograph - $25k
837 INQ:
2
836 INQ:
3
825 INQ:
2

TCL: $571.05k CCs:23 AAoA: 6yr 1mo Util: ~1% Derog: 0

Mortgage: $215.1k Sonata Lease: $1.3k Palisade: $23.8k
Message 4 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?


@Anonymous wrote:
Just wondering how often does the calendar categories overlap? is there a point to having both of these cards together? I understand if someone spends more than the $1500 cap on one of the cards and can use the other if they're in the same rotating category quarter, but if someone doesn't. Is this combo useless?

I've had both cards for two years...and it seems there has been at least one quarter each year that has some match. Even if they match on something, one may offer a second category that the other does not.

 

I don't consider it a useless combo, unless you never plan to use one card or the other

Message 5 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?


@Anonymous wrote:
Just wondering how often does the calendar categories overlap? is there a point to having both of these cards together? I understand if someone spends more than the $1500 cap on one of the cards and can use the other if they're in the same rotating category quarter, but if someone doesn't. Is this combo useless?

It seems to be a quarter or two each year. Often, on first quarter gas.

 

No, this combo is not useless. In fact, I'm of the belief that for cash back seekers (as opposed to travel rewards seekers), these are the two cards that people should get first. The pair is just awesome. Having both means that, in most quarters, you will have a useful 5% category. Why not double up on your chances of a useful 5% category? 

 

These two cards and a good 2% card can get someone a really nice system for cash back. And with the Discover cash back match year, there's no real need for the 2%er for the first year.

Message 6 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

I personally think they are both nice to have even if I have to rotate usage.

 

They both seem to grow nicely as well so I added both to my lineup.

Message 7 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

I have both and they often overlap. I rather use the Freedom but I have a rehearsal dinner to pay for so I will actually use them both!
Message 8 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

Looks like restaurants and dining are overlapping for both cards this summer. 

Message 9 of 10
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: How often does the 5% freedom & Discover It overlap ?

Often
Message 10 of 10
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.