cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

I want an AMEX Green. But why????

Regular Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

Well I'm just not sure! Like does anyone know a figure as far as spending that would have to be made to make any of the AMEX charge cards worth it? Like say if you spend this much get gold or for this much get PRG? Anyone know? It seems like most of my spending is gas making the PRG seem like a much better choice for 2X but then again I have Discover and Chase which gives me 5% on gas for half the year so I have to take that into account too!
AMEX BCE- $12,600 I Discover IT- $10,000 I Chase Freedom- $7,000 I Citi Double Cash- $3,300 I Best Buy- $2,800 I Bayport CU Visa- $1,000
Message 41 of 95
Super Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????


eagles08 wrote:
Well I'm just not sure! Like does anyone know a figure as far as spending that would have to be made to make any of the AMEX charge cards worth it? Like say if you spend this much get gold or for this much get PRG? Anyone know? It seems like most of my spending is gas making the PRG seem like a much better choice for 2X but then again I have Discover and Chase which gives me 5% on gas for half the year so I have to take that into account too!

You first have to decide what YOU would value 1 MR point as.  People value them differently depending on how they plan to redeem (and how they value that redemption!)

But simply assuming 1c per point (which is sort of the minimum), it would take $17,500 of 1x spend to break even, and half of that x2 spending to do so (and 1/3rd x3).

But that excludes things like: if you spent the $17,500 on the existing BCE, you would get at least the same $175 and similarly for some of the 5x spend.

 

THat's why you also have to decide what the status of having the card is worth to you, that could easily be worth $175 to you.

Message 42 of 95
Frequent Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

IMO, since the PRG has a high $175 annual fee, it would only be worth it if you spent $30,000 or more annually to get the 15,000 bonus points. Otherwise, definitely not worth it.

EQ 1: 792 (11/17) 2: 824 (11/17) EX 801 (12/17) TU 815 (11/17)
Chase Freedom VS - 5k - 13.99% - 2/13 ~ Chase Hyatt VS - 5k - 16.24% - 6/13 ~ Amex Hilton Surpass - 4.5k -14.99% - 8/13 ~ Chase IHG WMC - 5k - 16.24% - 1/14 ~ Chase Ink$ VS - 12k - 14.24% - 5/14 ~ NFCU $ VS - 25k - 10.65% - 12/14 ~ Amex ED - 30k - 13.99% - 1/16 ~ Citi AT&T WMC - 23k - 16.24% - 4/16 ~ Chase Sapphire Reserve VI - 10.6k - 16.99% - 8/16 ~ Chase FU V - 10.6k - 14.99% - 12/16 ~ Merrill+ VS - 10.1k - 13.99% - 2/17 ~ USAA Limitless VS - 20k - 17.9% - 8/17
Gone: CSP, AA x3, Ink+, TYP
Message 43 of 95
Regular Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

Yeah, I guess I need to just slow down and think practical rather than cool and prestigious! Maybe in the future the PRG will be a good card for me! I'm still considering the gold though! Hahahahaha wow ok seriously I need to slow down.
AMEX BCE- $12,600 I Discover IT- $10,000 I Chase Freedom- $7,000 I Citi Double Cash- $3,300 I Best Buy- $2,800 I Bayport CU Visa- $1,000
Message 44 of 95
Super Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????


eagles08 wrote:
Yeah, I guess I need to just slow down and think practical rather than cool and prestigious! Maybe in the future the PRG will be a good card for me! I'm still considering the gold though! Hahahahaha wow ok seriously I need to slow down.

Go for the platinum and get it out of your system!

Message 45 of 95
Regular Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

Hahahaha ohhh no! No way not the platinum for me!
AMEX BCE- $12,600 I Discover IT- $10,000 I Chase Freedom- $7,000 I Citi Double Cash- $3,300 I Best Buy- $2,800 I Bayport CU Visa- $1,000
Message 46 of 95
Regular Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

OMG ok so I walk in from work and I see on the counter is a mail offer clearly from AMEX and clearly for a Gold!!!!! Well..... It's for my mother Smiley Sad oh well! She got offered the 50,000 points after spending $1,000 in 3 months! Had that been mine I'd app right away! Oh well, maybe eventually!
AMEX BCE- $12,600 I Discover IT- $10,000 I Chase Freedom- $7,000 I Citi Double Cash- $3,300 I Best Buy- $2,800 I Bayport CU Visa- $1,000
Message 47 of 95
Established Member

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

I have the AMEX Green and my intentions were  #1 to use it soley for my utilities which add up to about roughly $2,000 a month. I wanted to set up auto pay/recuring payments and cut down on the amount of bills I had to remember to pay each month.  Well, turns out the main two utilities I wanted it for (Electric and Insurance) does not accept the AMEX card..ugh!Smiley Frustrated  But I still was able to set up all my other utilities to charge to the AMEX each month. My second reason was to establish history/get my foot in the door with AMEX in order to be approved for a Revolver in 6-12 months.  Hopefully that will happen before the Annual Fee hits.  If not, I will probably go ahead and close the Green card because I do not see me ever spending more the $2,000 a month on this baby since it has to be pay in full! LOL!!!

Message 48 of 95
New Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

I think it is perfectly acceptable for someone to pay $175 for a card just for the status if that is something that makes them happy. It is honestly one of the cheaper things you could do. People spend $50 on a tshirt just to buy a brand name for the same status effects. Prices only go up from there. They will buy houses, cars, etc sometimes just for a certain brand or image. Just make sure you aren't going outside of what you can afford and don't get caught up thinking that it makes you more important.

If women didn't exist, all the money in the world would have no meaning. -- Aristotle
Starting Score: 777
Current Score:  761
Goal Score:      800
Message 49 of 95
Frequent Contributor

Re: I want an AMEX Green. But why????

Amex love struck people.....I wonder if theses banks ever think this way about us?

CARDS.jpg

Message 50 of 95