Reply
Frequent Contributor
toi34
Posts: 488
Registered: ‎01-31-2009
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

Perhaps it's not a huge big deal, but it definately is the principle.

May 2013 Starting Scores: 540's-570's [no credit cards, no inq's, 1 Student Loan 90 day late, CA's and CO's...most PFD'd!]
September 2014 Scores: 660-705 ...Getting there!
Current Cards: SDFCU Secured ($300); Logix Secured ($500); Tobyhanna FCU ($5000); Sony Visa ($3000); Apple PC'd to Rewards MC ($1200); Barclay Rewards MC ($1300); B&N ($500); Discover ($1100); 'Credit Steps' ($2300), QS One ($750);Care Credit ($9000); US Bank Platinum ($5000); Fifth Third SU2C ($3000); Kay's ($3000); Jared's ($3000); Fingerhut ($1550); **All my favorite retail cards ($24,250)..Luv'Em..they get heavy use!
Established Member
CMS70
Posts: 12
Registered: ‎01-05-2012
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

I agree, Toi.

 

1) You just don't change the way you are reporting and not inform you customers.

 

2) It may not effect your score but you don't know what influance it would have if you were getting it review by a person.  

 

I have been unsuccessful in getting the reporting changed back.  If anyone has any suggestions on how I can get my situation correct, please Inbox me.  

 

Thanks!

 

 

Established Contributor
cashnocredit
Posts: 1,025
Registered: ‎07-18-2009
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

[ Edited ]

I'm of the opinion that FICO scores actually overestimate the risk when a card is secured*.  People think of secured CCs as a red flag that a person has bad credit but the reality may be different. Further, there is other evidence I've seen personally that this is the case. Let's take an example:

 

Imagine two people. both with a 10k CC, one secured one unsecured, with a 4k balance and both with a few CAs, say 5 y/o of say $500 each that have been paid..

 

What is the risk of default within 2 years, which is what credit scores estimate.

 

I maintain that the risk of default of the  person with the 10k secured card is lower than the person with the unsecured card. Would that really surprise anyone? I think not.

 

People look at a secured card as a bad credit flag but the flag is the CAs, not the secured card.

 

*My specific reason for this belief is that I was in a similar position 4 years ago with a couple secured cards. I was able to get a mortgage with that file. Needless to say I have since had the cards unsecured and the mortgage was has been paid off. Another interesting thing is that my VantageScore 2.0 at the time was 900 (roughly similar to a 780 FICO). The only way it could have been that high is if the fact my cards were secured weighed favorably against the CAs. Especially with a fairly thin, short file with smaller older but paid baddies. BTW, after my cards unsecured and all the baddies dropped off my Vantage score dropped to the high 800s. More evidence that secured cards are not a negative factor in credit risk.

 

We don't know the scoring algorithms of VantageScore 2.0 but the 3.0 version has been specifically stated to factor in secured cards and I suspect that such a similar situation would also be weighed favorably.

 

We do know FICO scores don't factor secured status but in the future they may do so as well. But the widespread assumption that a secured card status is a "Bad Thing" is, IMO, highly dubious.  CAs and liens, especially unpaid ones are the bad things.

I have reestablished credit over the last couple years
so my moniker is, well, rather out of date.

WM Discover $1800, WF Plat 12k, Chase Freedom Siggy15k, Amex Plat (60k H/B), Citi AA EWMC 25k
Established Contributor
Ravensfan2001
Posts: 556
Registered: ‎11-10-2012
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

I opened my secured account with them in 2012. For me, it's always been reported as "secured" with all 3 CRAs.


Starting Scores: (4/16/12 lender pull) TU 596 | EX 550 | EQ 576
Mortgage Scores:(7/24/13 lender pull) TU 663 | EX 635 | EQ 649
Current Score (9/22/14): TU 670 | EX 605 | EQ 659
Goals: 680 across the board by 3/2015. Last app 7/16/14 (auto loan)
*** Homeowner 9/27/13***
New Contributor
Refugee47
Posts: 74
Registered: ‎09-22-2014
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

Do you know if they report secured share loans as secured ?

Valued Contributor
taxi818
Posts: 1,654
Registered: ‎07-04-2014
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"


Refugee47 wrote:

Do you know if they report secured share loans as secured ?


I'm gettin loan secured. I could care less as long as fico recognizes the installment loan. We all know principle. But if they decide to change. No big deal. I would not need manual review since my score hit roof. Anyway. Secured IMO is for rebuilding or building. Once I out grew the secured card I never looked back. No need to micro manage the small stuff. 


last app 10-10-14. Garden until 6-2015
Contributor
soloman
Posts: 78
Registered: ‎09-29-2014
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

I called today and the representative insists the secured card does not report as secured. Someone who has this card please confirm before I apply.  Thanks!

Start Score 09/02/14: EQ563 TU543 EX563
Crrnt Score 10/08/14: EQ607 TU571 EX584
Short Goal: 620 ALL THREE by Thanksgiving '14
Long Goal: 700 ALL THREE by Thanksgiving '15
Valued Contributor
taxi818
Posts: 1,654
Registered: ‎07-04-2014
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

Does it matter to your fico score. No!!!! Non issue.

last app 10-10-14. Garden until 6-2015
Frequent Contributor
toi34
Posts: 488
Registered: ‎01-31-2009
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"

YES it does! ...They started reporting secured about 5 months ago.
May 2013 Starting Scores: 540's-570's [no credit cards, no inq's, 1 Student Loan 90 day late, CA's and CO's...most PFD'd!]
September 2014 Scores: 660-705 ...Getting there!
Current Cards: SDFCU Secured ($300); Logix Secured ($500); Tobyhanna FCU ($5000); Sony Visa ($3000); Apple PC'd to Rewards MC ($1200); Barclay Rewards MC ($1300); B&N ($500); Discover ($1100); 'Credit Steps' ($2300), QS One ($750);Care Credit ($9000); US Bank Platinum ($5000); Fifth Third SU2C ($3000); Kay's ($3000); Jared's ($3000); Fingerhut ($1550); **All my favorite retail cards ($24,250)..Luv'Em..they get heavy use!
Established Contributor
Jlu
Posts: 785
Registered: ‎06-12-2012
0

Re: SDFCU is now reporting as "SECURED"


toi34 wrote:
YES it does! ...They started reporting secured about 5 months ago.

It matters not what they report ..secured vs unsecured... it's the same damn thing for scoring purposes. It's like a card that gets closed at consumer's request vs closed at credit grantor's request - it doesn't really matter unless a loan officer is manually reviewing your report and even then it carries little weight.

JP Morgan Select $10k | CSP $10k | Citi TY Premier $15k | BofA 3-2-1 $15k | Chase Freedom $10k | Discover IT $10k | Barclaycard $10k | AMEX SPG $5k | AMEX PRG NPSL | NASA Platinum-Advantage $10k | CapOne Quicksilver $3k | Walmart Card $5k | Amazon Card $10k | Chase Auto 1.49% | Joined myFICO 6/12 with a 540 FICO & today I'm over 750!

myFICO is the consumer division of FICO. Since its introduction 20 years ago, the FICO® Score has become a global standard for measuring credit risk in the banking, mortgage, credit card, auto and retail industries. 90 of the top 100 largest U.S. financial institutions use the FICO Score to make consumer credit decisions.

>> About myFICO
FICO Score - The Score that matters
Click to Verify - This site chose VeriSign SSL for secure e-commerce and confidential communications.
Fair Isaac Corporation is a BBB Accredited Financial Service in San Rafael, CA
FOLLOW US Social Media Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+
}