cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

tag
sergi0wned
Contributor

Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

I really would like to obtain a Sallie Mae MC as soon as possible. I will be on my own this summer and it would be nice to receive 5% back on groceries, and I would also like 5% back in bookstores (since I don't really like accumulating TY points) on my textbooks.


The problem is that I've heard that Barclays is INQ and new account sensitive. I'm conflicted with this advice, because on one hand I don't want a denial, but on the other hand I'm an impatient college student! I don't care about APR since I always PIF, and CL is not too important since I won't get anywhere near maxing out my rewards.


Now for my stats:

 

I have only two INQs on TU (one of which will age off in May), and the other was last year in June for my Discover. That's the tempting part.

 

I have three new accounts, however, according to CK. My Amex and Chase cards are reporting, and when I logged in today, I noticed that my Macy's AMEX got a $2,000 auto-CLI that appears to have resulted in a new TL? I don't know how that works, and I'm not sure if I believe that I do in fact have a new account. Regardless, I'm worried that these will prevent me from approval. Do you think that 2 (and maybe 3) new accounts is too many?


Discover TU FICO is 730 as of last month.

 

 

The Sallie Mae is the last card I want to obtain on my student income - then I'm content to stay in the garden until graduation in 2016 and let my accounts grow until I have the income (and higher scores) to support nice cards like the CSP. Please let me know when I should apply for it! If now is not the time, just knowing when is the time should be enough to tide me over lol!

20 years old | 4 Cards in my wallet | TU (3/28/14) 743
January 2013 - 1st Financial Bank USA Platinum VISA ($500 --> $1,500)
June 2013- Discover IT Student ($1,500 --> $1,800 --> $2,100), Citi Forward Student ($1,500 --> $2,900)
December 2013 - Macy's American Express ($1,000 --> $3,000)
February 2014 - American Express Blue Cash Everyday ($3,000), Chase Freedom ($2,000)
April 2014 - Sallie Mae MasterCard ($3,800)
Message 1 of 47
46 REPLIES 46
ficobgtx
Regular Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

For no reason other than I just like this card and wouldn't mind having for myself - go for it!

TU - 850 (BOA TU08 FICO/Barclay TU08), 831 (CK FAKO)
EQ - 870 (CITI FICO), 848 (ATFCU FICO), 831 (CK FAKO)
EX - 841 (AMEX FICO)
Message 2 of 47
MoreRewards
Established Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

I'm not sure on Barclay being all that sensitive. When i app ' d in Oct they did pull TU.

My score was 758. 5 INQ on TU. New credit cards accounts opened in March, April, June & 2 in July.
EQ 773 * EX 786 * TU 797
Message 3 of 47
Themanwhocan
Senior Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

You are probably just fine to obtain a Sallie Mae. Here is the record of my credit cards:

 

Secured (Closed)  1/1/2012

 

US Bank Cash+     1/1/2013

Elan (closed)     1/1/2013

Discover IT       1/29/2013

US Bank Cash+ #2  4/1/2013

Amex BCE          4/20/2013

Priceline.com     5/7/2013

Sallie Mae        9/21/2013

Chase Freedom     11/20/2013

Sallie Mae        4/7/2014

 

The priceline was only a $1500 limit, and the first Sallie was only $1600. Once I let my score recover and stopped having a lot of recent applications, my second Sallie was granted at $10,000.





TU-8: 804 EX-8: 805 EQ-8: 788 EX-98: 767 EQ-04: 752    
TU-9 Bankcard: 837 EQ-9: 823 EX-9 Bankcard: 837
Total $443,800
Message 4 of 47
sergi0wned
Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

Thanks for the responses, guys. I notice that when you applied (MoreRewards, Themanwhocan) your accounts were generally a couple months old.

 

Do you think it would be advisable to wait a couple of months to let the accounts age, or should I just take the hit now?

20 years old | 4 Cards in my wallet | TU (3/28/14) 743
January 2013 - 1st Financial Bank USA Platinum VISA ($500 --> $1,500)
June 2013- Discover IT Student ($1,500 --> $1,800 --> $2,100), Citi Forward Student ($1,500 --> $2,900)
December 2013 - Macy's American Express ($1,000 --> $3,000)
February 2014 - American Express Blue Cash Everyday ($3,000), Chase Freedom ($2,000)
April 2014 - Sallie Mae MasterCard ($3,800)
Message 5 of 47
yudeology101
Senior Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

Looks good, GO GO GO!!

JPM Ritz Carlton $8k I UMP Club $8k I CSP $8k | Chase Hyatt $5k I AMEX Green NPSL I AMEX Delta $2k I Citi AA $2k | C1 QS $4.5k
BOA UNC-CH Alumni $6k I Hawaiian WEMC $3k I Arrival $6.5k I IT $1.5k | Merrill+ $2k | Lowes $12k | Apple $2k | +23more
Scores: EQ:671 (FICO 11) EX:686 (FICO N/C) TU:686 (FICO N/C) *8-5-14*
Overall UTIL: 14% *Gardening Since: 1/20/16*
------------------------------------------------------------
Need to stay out of trouble.... Go Heels!!! ... GC Watchlist ( #1 since 12-12-13)
Message 6 of 47
MoreRewards
Established Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

If you want to take the hit now you should be fine. It might effect CL but if you are not concerned about that app now. I was only approved for $2,500. Unlike themanwhocan I've never tried for a 2nd Sallie Mae. I had trouble gardening as it is without doubling my cards but that is tempting.
EQ 773 * EX 786 * TU 797
Message 7 of 47
eagle2013
Established Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger


@MoreRewards wrote:
I'm not sure on Barclay being all that sensitive. When i app ' d in Oct they did pull TU.

My score was 758. 5 INQ on TU. New credit cards accounts opened in March, April, June & 2 in July.

Ditto for me. Apped yesterday when FICO was 720ish. Had 8 inqs total on TU, 2 within the last two months. Also a new account (opened a month ago) was reporting at the time of application. Approved for the WMC. With only two inqs on TU I would go for it! 

Message 8 of 47
Creditaddict
Legendary Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger


@Themanwhocan wrote:

You are probably just fine to obtain a Sallie Mae. Here is the record of my credit cards:

 

Secured (Closed)  1/1/2012

 

US Bank Cash+     1/1/2013

Elan (closed)     1/1/2013

Discover IT       1/29/2013

US Bank Cash+ #2  4/1/2013

Amex BCE          4/20/2013

Priceline.com     5/7/2013

Sallie Mae        9/21/2013

Chase Freedom     11/20/2013

Sallie Mae        4/7/2014

 

The priceline was only a $1500 limit, and the first Sallie was only $1600. Once I let my score recover and stopped having a lot of recent applications, my second Sallie was granted at $10,000.


WOW, Barclay issued a 3rd card!!?

 

OP APPLY!

Message 9 of 47
sergi0wned
Contributor

Re: Sallie Mae - talk me down or help me pull the trigger

OH MY GOD!!!!!!

 

Just got INSTANTLY APPROVED for $3,800!!! I can't believe it! Highest approval yet. It's the platinum version, but I can't really complain.

 

Off to the garden I go! Thanks for the encouragement guys!

20 years old | 4 Cards in my wallet | TU (3/28/14) 743
January 2013 - 1st Financial Bank USA Platinum VISA ($500 --> $1,500)
June 2013- Discover IT Student ($1,500 --> $1,800 --> $2,100), Citi Forward Student ($1,500 --> $2,900)
December 2013 - Macy's American Express ($1,000 --> $3,000)
February 2014 - American Express Blue Cash Everyday ($3,000), Chase Freedom ($2,000)
April 2014 - Sallie Mae MasterCard ($3,800)
Message 10 of 47
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.