Reply
Blogger
HiLine
Posts: 2,831
Registered: ‎10-19-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards


lg8302ch wrote:
I am completely confused. BofA reporting the same account as OPEN and CLOSED (with comment " card lost/stolen) - Does this mean it gets counted twice for the AAofA ? it shows up as sep TL. Sorry but I am new to US reporting issues.

Can you post a screenshot of the sections that say "open" and "closed" in a new thread? This thread is for the survey .. :smileyhappy:

 

New Contributor
danielodonoll
Posts: 401
Registered: ‎03-16-2013

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

I closed Target and first premier

Citi Bank X2/ 29k-USAA Amex/Mastercard 24k-PP Mastercard 20k_
WMDiscover 20k-PenFed X2/15k
Current Fico/EQ-765
Garden Time Day- 10
Remaining Days-170
Regular Contributor
jla84
Posts: 249
Registered: ‎07-21-2011

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

1. When did the account get closed? 5/2004

2. How long did account reporting last after that? If your account is still being reported, please tell us the amount of time elapsed from account closing date, in years and months if possible. EQ has already taken it off their report when I checked last month - 8 years and 10 months. The account is still reporting on EX. Haven't checked TU recently so I can't comment on that.

3. What card is it? Who's the creditor? M&I Bank

4. Did the consumer or the creditor close the card? Consumer

5. Any other information and stories about the card? 

 

Also that card had perfect history. I believe there are different rules for accounts with baddies (taken off after 7 years from close?).

 


Starting Score (07/2011): EQ 706 TU 709
Current Score (6/2013): EQ 740 TU 732 EX 740
Goal Score: 750+ on all 3


Take the FICO Fitness Challenge
Blogger
HiLine
Posts: 2,831
Registered: ‎10-19-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

Can others share their experience as well? I don't think there are that few people that have closed credit cards ...

 

Blogger
HiLine
Posts: 2,831
Registered: ‎10-19-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

Frequent Contributor
Roarmeister
Posts: 311
Registered: ‎04-21-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

[ Edited ]

Roarmeister wrote:

HiLine wrote:

Roarmeister wrote:

 

Equifax removes an item from its database after 6 years after the last report so old deleted items do not enter into its AAofA.  Transunion has a different retention period and a really wacky way of doing business.  I also have a lot of accounts that I thought were closed but Transunion says they are reporting for example a car lease that closed in 2000 but was reported in 2009 and was still in their records in 2010.  A car loan that closed in 1994 that reported in 2009 was still in their records.  How does a car loan get reported on 15 years AFTER it was closed????  That makes no freaking sense!  Even more strange - Transunion has a record of hard inquires going back to 2002!

 

Hey maybe they just keep their records permanently but don't enter into their scoring system?  I don't know but Transunion is one funky weird company.


I believe that TU isn't responsible for reporting accounts; if the original creditor is still reporting closed accounts, the accounts will still stay on your report when you pull it.




Point 1:  And yet those same reported accounts aren't logged by Equifax but they ARE by Transunion. 

 

Point 2:  What would set off a lender company to report on a car loan that has been closed for 15 years except an back inquiry by the CRA itself?  There would be no point in the original creditor releasing that information unless it was in turn requested by somebody!

 

Point 3:  Transunion keeping inquires beyond 3 years is not an acceptible practise if the other CRAs automatically drop the inquires at that point.

 

I don't know if Transunions' practices are different south of the border but I find their business practices weird up here.



Mystery solved with a phone call.  Transunion pulled all records for my pre mortgage review in 2009 and in so doing created new activity dates for these old records.  They will drop off in about three years.

AMEX_PlatinumBMOWorldMCCapOnePlatinumMBNA_Platinum+ScotiaMomentum
___$18.5k______$20k_______$20k_______$25k______$25k____
Starting Score: 676 Feb 2008; Current Score: 775 EQ, 814 TU, July 2014; Goal Score: 785 by end of year
Oldest Account reported by EQ: 12.0 years; EQ AAoA: 5.2 years; EQ Credit Utilization: 2.9%
Blogger
HiLine
Posts: 2,831
Registered: ‎10-19-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

[ Edited ]

Roarmeister wrote:

Roarmeister wrote:

HiLine wrote:

Roarmeister wrote:

 

Equifax removes an item from its database after 6 years after the last report so old deleted items do not enter into its AAofA.  Transunion has a different retention period and a really wacky way of doing business.  I also have a lot of accounts that I thought were closed but Transunion says they are reporting for example a car lease that closed in 2000 but was reported in 2009 and was still in their records in 2010.  A car loan that closed in 1994 that reported in 2009 was still in their records.  How does a car loan get reported on 15 years AFTER it was closed????  That makes no freaking sense!  Even more strange - Transunion has a record of hard inquires going back to 2002!

 

Hey maybe they just keep their records permanently but don't enter into their scoring system?  I don't know but Transunion is one funky weird company.


I believe that TU isn't responsible for reporting accounts; if the original creditor is still reporting closed accounts, the accounts will still stay on your report when you pull it.




Point 1:  And yet those same reported accounts aren't logged by Equifax but they ARE by Transunion. 

 

Point 2:  What would set off a lender company to report on a car loan that has been closed for 15 years except an back inquiry by the CRA itself?  There would be no point in the original creditor releasing that information unless it was in turn requested by somebody!

 

Point 3:  Transunion keeping inquires beyond 3 years is not an acceptible practise if the other CRAs automatically drop the inquires at that point.

 

I don't know if Transunions' practices are different south of the border but I find their business practices weird up here.



Mystery solved with a phone call.  Transunion pulled all records for my pre mortgage review in 2009 and in so doing created new activity dates for these old records.  They will drop off in about three years.


That's hilarious, and possibly a loophole to boost your AAoA by getting closed accounts revived!

Established Contributor
YahComb
Posts: 592
Registered: ‎03-10-2012

Re: Survey: reporting of closed credit cards

my paypal mastercard still "updates" every month on TU. The notes show it as closed(in good standing), doesn't factor into credit lines and utizilation, but if you aren't paying attention it looks like an active tradeline. it was closed spring of 2013.

EQ-730(06/30/14) TU-758(06/19/14)
Newest to Oldest
Barc Sallie Mae 6K | Citi TY Pref 4.5K | US Bank Cash+ 10K | Chase Freedom 7.5K | Disc It 9K | Amazon Store 2.5K | BOA Cash Rewards 10.5K |

Closed Cards: 4 Oldest: 2.92yr AAOA: 24.8 mo

myFICO is the consumer division of FICO. Since its introduction 20 years ago, the FICO® Score has become a global standard for measuring credit risk in the banking, mortgage, credit card, auto and retail industries. 90 of the top 100 largest U.S. financial institutions use the FICO Score to make consumer credit decisions.

>> About myFICO
FICO Score - The Score that matters
Click to Verify - This site chose VeriSign SSL for secure e-commerce and confidential communications.
Fair Isaac Corporation is a BBB Accredited Financial Service in San Rafael, CA
FOLLOW US Social Media Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+