@aav wrote:
Good question. I'm in the same position. I've had the card for two years. It was the first card I got on the rebuild. So I'm a little sentimental about it.. Even though it's the lowest credit line I have.
The double cash card sounds good. I don't care for its appearance
lol but the benefits sound good. I've also thought abt the Hilton honors... But think I would prefer the Amex version.
I feel you about being sentimental about putting it on the chopping block , the Hilton amex seems to be no diff than the citi Hilton (no fee versions) , of course if you get the amex bonus that's when it makes the diff . But you won't get bonus when you pc :/ it's also one of my lowest credit lines too 
@Anonymous wrote:I called citi yesterday to ask about product changing my diamond Preffered and the csr said I can change to "any" card I like ..... Preferably I want to keep it no-AF so I was looking at double cash or thank you Preffered !? Are thank you points better than cash back ?! Another option was the no fee HHonors , but I have the Hilton amex no fee as well :/ I don't know what to do , I want to show citi some love cause they where the first ones to approve me for a good credit card 2 yrs ago but with all these other cards , freedom , discover , bofa cash , the diamond has been SD until yesterday I purchased something at Dairy Queen with it just because I forgot my Hilton amex at home that gives me 5% on restaurants
At the very least, you can get 1:1 cash back from TYP from mortgage/student loan redemption. The best value is when you redeem for travel, but I believe you need to be carrying a Thank You Premier or Thank You Prestige to really take advantage of those redemptions. Unless you plan on getting one of those cards as well, I think the DC is your best bet.
And I agree that the DC looks much better in person. I just wish the card itself was a bit more sturdy. But perhaps I've just been spoiled from using my CSP so much 