Reply
Valued Contributor
bs6054
Posts: 1,673
Registered: ‎11-11-2012
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival


Revelate wrote:

bs6054 wrote:

Revelate wrote:

Citi can and possibly will still report it to the bureaus.

 

If you close it and it is reported, you do sort of look like a flake to future underwriters.  As such I'd never ever do this personally and would just suck it up for a year.  Plus on the assumption you applied for it based on some reward structure that fits your financial habits, I find it hard to believe that $5K CL is not sufficient to cover monthly expenses in that category.

 


Yes, but he obviously has a lot of big credit cards, so I don't know if a future underwriter will care (or maybe even notice) about such a small card.  Could be lots of not particularly flaky reasons (app'd for the wrong card by mistake, realized the error and cancelled).


I assume that underwriters will notice everything.  Personally I'd notice a tradeline that was artificially short, and look at it's details, and I suspect most underwriters are far more likely to notice something which is different from the vast majority of applications they look at.  Actually given the entire recon nature that is credit card approvals apparently, I think it's reasonable to state that underwriting will likely take the most negative reason and assume that.

 

It's certainly fair game to question, and I recommend minimizing those as too many questionable items almost certainly is going to be problematic.  Why have even a potential additional one when it's avoidable?

 


Yes, that's true.  I guess it depends on your credit situation, if your scores are 820 I think this is of no importance, at 650, yes!  But I still think a good answer is something like "When I applied, I misunderstood the benefits the card offered, and when I looked more closely, I realized it had no value to me and I didn't want to keep a useless card open" which doesn't attach much blame apart from poor reading comprehension!

 

Thinking about this particular situation more, the OP was originally denied, so he probably does need to be concerned some about the credit report.  He has explained that some of the best cards don't report, hence his decision, in line with everyone but mine, to keep it.

Valued Contributor
ryanbush
Posts: 1,292
Registered: ‎08-19-2012
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival


swpopham wrote:

I guess ill finish the spend requirement tomorrow and sock drawer it.  put myficos quarterly monitering on it.

 

you know what I just thought about, our CSP and navy card and jared are all that is reporting on my credit. pd and select card dont report, ink dosent report, and the ink dosent report.... damn...


This is why you got the 5k line, it is a little conservative but pretty much in line with your other cards...  unless it has a ridicilous AF just throw in the drawer and forget about it, you never know when it might come in handy 

Chase Sapphire Perferred | Chase Freedom | AMEX Platinum | AMEX Delta Platinum | AMEX SPG | Capital One Venture | Capital One Quicksliver | Discover IT | ABFCU Visa | Citi AA WEMC
Valued Contributor
j_casteel
Posts: 1,915
Registered: ‎06-21-2012
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival

lol, ask your friend to buy you a Big Mac and they say no. Then you you beg them and they decide to bring you back a McDouble instead. You throw it away.

 

Seems like a waste.

| Walmart $5k | Amazon $5k | NFCU $20k | NLOC $15k | Lowes $17k | BoA $15k | Freedom $3k | IT $4.5k | CSP $5k | Marriott $5k | AMEX TE $9k | Alaska $5k |
Starting Scores: EQ:571 EX:??? TU:597
Current Scores: EQ:694 EX:714 TU:711
Goal Scores: 700
across the board
Regular Contributor
McArthur
Posts: 249
Registered: ‎12-24-2012
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival

Within a year I bet you can get your limit doubled . . . or better.

Frequent Contributor
manyquestions
Posts: 299
Registered: ‎10-20-2008
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival

I'd keep it open. As others have said, you've already taken the hit for the inquiry, you'll have a new account reporting whether it is open or closed, and your AAoA will go down whether the card reports open or closed.   Why come away from that with a closed account? I'd leave it open and ask for a CLI after 6 months and then again at 12 months.

Established Contributor
UFGuy2006
Posts: 741
Registered: ‎08-02-2008
0

Re: closing a card in less then a week after arrival


chnceit wrote:

You took the hit plus there is no AF for a year. I say keep it and ask for a CLI after 6 months. 


Agree here. They seem to be a little more flex with CLI on this card from my experience.

FICO: EX: 743 (10/14); TU: 758 (9/14); EQ 721 (9/14)

In My Wallet: Amex X 5 | Barclays X 3 | BOA X 1 | CapOne X 3 | Chase X 3 | Citi X 7 | DCU X 1 | Discover X 1 | Fidelity X 1 | Fifth Third X 1 | Macys X 1 | PenFed X 1 | PSECU X 1 | Sams Club MC X 1 | Target RedCard X 1 | USAA X 2 | US Bank X 1 | Walmart X 1 | Wells Fargo X 1 = 36 Cards

Holding off apps until the end of the year! Wish me luck!

myFICO is the consumer division of FICO. Since its introduction 20 years ago, the FICO® Score has become a global standard for measuring credit risk in the banking, mortgage, credit card, auto and retail industries. 90 of the top 100 largest U.S. financial institutions use the FICO Score to make consumer credit decisions.

>> About myFICO
FICO Score - The Score that matters
Click to Verify - This site chose VeriSign SSL for secure e-commerce and confidential communications.
Fair Isaac Corporation is a BBB Accredited Financial Service in San Rafael, CA
FOLLOW US Social Media Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+
}