i feel a bit cheap...

[MrShush]

My AMEX Blue came a few weeks ago and had the member since date as 96 whereas my Green did not ('10). Feeling like this was a conflict in my wallet, I had a replacement card overnighted via the website, and viola, Green has member since 96. Talk about superficial

[Red1Blue]

I understand your feelings. I feel the same about some of the cards when I carry them.

[MrShush]

It's nice to know I'm not the only one.

[Anonymous]

How did you specify that it was the date you wanted corrected when you requested it online? The only options for reasons that I see on the the card replacement menu are Damaged, Lost, Stolen, or Did Not Receive. Thanks.

[MrShush]

I simply selected replace damaged card and chose 1 - 2 day UPS delivery.

[hyprble]

It would bother me too - I think more on the OCD than "cheap" side