Well i cant say what would happen, but from my personal experience. I had a overdrawn bank account with wachovia bank. It was reporting since 2005. This past August i called them up and ask for a settlement. They agreed to half the amount. The original amount was 1600, they agree to 800. Once the account was updated on my credit report, it stated settled in full for less than amount. The balance showed as zero, but to my surprise, my credit scores went up a few points. I'm not saying this would happen to you but i look at it like this, its best to have the account settled rather still showing a high balance.