cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

New Member

Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

I sent a letter asking for a goodwill adjustment to my student loan creditor - they really screwed me big because they apparently hold 3 accounts that they report separately so even though it was one late payment they reported it to 3 separate accounts on my credit.  I sent them a letter asking for a goodwill adjustment and they responded:

"We received your request for a courtesy/good-will credit retraction. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), we are required to report complete and accurate information to the nationwide consumer reporting agencies; therefore, we are unable to honor your request."

I know that creditors can make goodwill adjustments so I would like to respond to them and tell them that they are incorrect.  What is the best way of going about that?  Is there any official documentation anywhere that I can reference?

Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES
Valued Contributor

Re: Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

I successfully goodwill'd ALL of my late history from ALL of my past due accounts but I wouldn't say there's an easy way to do it.

 

My most difficult account (which actually had 90 day lates over a year) took over a year of writing letters, phone calls, emailing random email addresses I tried out, etc.  One day I received a call from the VP of the bank who said he will correct all of the lates to paid-as-agreed and 45 days or less later my CRs reported the account as perfect payment history.

 

I think I've spent 100s of hours making calls, writing letters (USPS) and emails and probably $100 in stamps to get all my accounts looking beautiful.  Just because someone says no today doesn't mean they'll say no tomorrow.  

FICO8FICO8Visit my posts:
03/1712/17My 11 Rules to Credit Rebuilding
550EX
570TU
559EQ
710EX
701TU
734EQ
FICO alert: why did my credit score drop???
Message 2 of 5
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

Keep sending, that's a standard denial.  Just so you know, it's not true.  The FCRA mandates that all information that is reported must be accurate, nothing mandates that anything "HAS" to be reported at all.  Keep plugging away!

Starting Score: 504
July 2013 score:
EQ FICO 819, TU08 778, EX "806 lender pull 07/26/2013
Goal Score: All Scores 760+, Newest goal 800+
Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge

Current scores after adding $81K in CLs and 2 new cars since July 2013
EQ:809 TU 777 EX 790 Now it's just garden time!

June 2017 update: All scores over 820, just pure gardening now.
Message 3 of 5
Community Leader
Epic Contributor

Re: Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

The actual prohibition from deletion is based on CRA policy, not on any specific prohibition in the FCRA.

 

The FCRA does not mandate reporting.  It mandates that if a party does report, it is a violation if any reporting is knowingly inaccurate.

 

The CRAs are in business to sell credit reports, and the value of those reports depends upon their completeness.

To that end, the CRAs have a real vested business interest in preserving the completeness of credit histories that they sell.

They have a stated policy in both their common credit reporting manual, the "Credit Reporting Resource Guide," and their credit reporting agreements, that furnishers are not to delete accurate reporting based on the consumer having paid the debt.

 

They will often erroneously cite the FCRA as preventing deletion, when in fact it is based on their credit reporting agreements with the CRAs.

However, they need provide no reason to deny any subjective deletion, so any cited basis for denial will not, if contested, lead to any requirement to delete.

Contesting their basis is likely to cause them to dig in their heels rather than grant good will deletion.

Message 4 of 5
New Visitor

Re: Asked for Goodwill Adjustment but Creditor said they can't due to FRCA

Does anyone have a good response to the assertion by the bank that they can only make an adjustment if it was due to an actual error by the bank? I had a late payment with DRB due to an autopay failure, which they assert is my fault, but it is far more complicated than that and they were partially at fault as well. However they say they are not allowed to make the adjustment unless it was a clear cut error on their part. I've looked at the Fair Credit Reporting Act and do not see anything to support their position, but I'm not sure that telling them that will help my case..

Message 5 of 5