cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Can you dispute a drop off date?

tag
dapps06
Frequent Contributor

Can you dispute a drop off date?

I'm down to one negative account on my reports, a settled Wells Fargo auto loan. Currently it's due to drop off in July of 2017, but that doesn't seem right to me. I first became late in October of 2009. I never caught up and ended up selling the car on a settlement agreement in July of 2010. Shouldn't the drop off be seven years from when I first became late, 10/2009, instead of the date I sold the car, 7/2010?

Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
gdale6
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?


@dapps06 wrote:

I'm down to one negative account on my reports, a settled Wells Fargo auto loan. Currently it's due to drop off in July of 2017, but that doesn't seem right to me. I first became late in October of 2009. I never caught up and ended up selling the car on a settlement agreement in July of 2010. Shouldn't the drop off be seven years from when I first became late, 10/2009, instead of the date I sold the car, 7/2010?


You would not be disputing the drop off date but the DoFD of the account and if you have proof that the DoFD is reporting in error then you would address it with a direct dispute to the reporting creditor. Sounds like they are trying to use the DOLA as the date it should report from and that is not correct.

Message 2 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?

Does the account reporting show the late preceeding the settlement sale? It the account reporting as charged off?

Message 3 of 9
dapps06
Frequent Contributor

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?


@Anonymous wrote:

Does the account reporting show the late preceeding the settlement sale? It the account reporting as charged off?


It's reporting as a legally settled account, with 30 day lates starting in 10/2009 all the way up through 6/2010, with an "OK" reporting one month later for 7/2010.

 

Here's how it's reporting for all three...

 

TU:

Remarks: >SETTLED-LESS THAN FULL BLNC<; CLOSED


EQ and EX:

Account paid for less than full balance

Message 4 of 9
dapps06
Frequent Contributor

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?


@gdale6 wrote:

@dapps06 wrote:

I'm down to one negative account on my reports, a settled Wells Fargo auto loan. Currently it's due to drop off in July of 2017, but that doesn't seem right to me. I first became late in October of 2009. I never caught up and ended up selling the car on a settlement agreement in July of 2010. Shouldn't the drop off be seven years from when I first became late, 10/2009, instead of the date I sold the car, 7/2010?


You would not be disputing the drop off date but the DoFD of the account and if you have proof that the DoFD is reporting in error then you would address it with a direct dispute to the reporting creditor. Sounds like they are trying to use the DOLA as the date it should report from and that is not correct.


Ugh, that means I'd have to call WF, I hate them haha.

 

I called recently to offer to pay the remaining balance on the car after I sold it in exchange for them removing this account early. They didn't even consider it.

Message 5 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?

This ones in kind of a gray area... If its not reporting a charge off and was not a collection, its technically NOT a derogatory account (other than the late payments) and should not have a DoFD. I'm just not sure how the 'settled' comment is treated on an account that was never charged off. The 30 day lates will fall off individually as they hit the 7 year mark.

Message 6 of 9
dapps06
Frequent Contributor

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?

I read somewhere once that a settled account is viewed the same as a charge off, not sure if that's true or not. It's definitely listed as a negative item on my reports though. I think what I'll probably end up doing if WF won't update their information is just disputing the account next September.

Message 7 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?

Yeah its going to show up as a negative account just on the basis of the late pays alone - both my current Cap One accounts show up in the "negative account" section because I've got some lates on them. I know a settled account 'looks bad' when reviewed, I'm just not sure how its treated with regards to a DoFD. Maybe RobertEG knows.

Message 8 of 9
dapps06
Frequent Contributor

Re: Can you dispute a drop off date?

Just called EX to file a dispute, just want to see how it goes. The rep said it's showing as being brought current in July of 2010 and then settled one month later in August. I told her when I sold the car in July that's what settled the account. She put in a dispute for me stating the account was never brought current from 10/2009, it was simply settled in July for less than the full amount. I figure EX is usually the best at getting things done so I'll start with them.

 

Almost had a HUGE victory during this call. On my EX report is shows the drop off date as May of 2017, the others say July. At the start of the call when I mentioned this she said "well May is just a few days away, I'll just delete the account, one moment please". I sat there in total shock thinking, "am I about to get this account removed two years early". My conscience kicked in tnough and I told her that it's due to fall off in May of 2017, not next month. I jokingly said "but you can still try to remove it if you want to", and she actually tried. The system wouldn't let her though because of the time frame, probably has to be within 2-3 months of the drop off date. EX is the best, the fact she even tried to remove it when she knew it wasn't falling off for two years is just awesome.

Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.