Confused. Am I missing something?

[shanac]

I had a new CA report on all three CR on 3/15/13.  Experian FAKO immediately dropped 42 points. FAKO yes, but still devastating. I got the CA to agree to delete. Well today I received an alert from EX that my score had increased 42 points. Cool, the CA deleted tradeline from EX and I regained what I'd lost. Score! Foolishly (???) I was expecting to get an alert from SW today that my TU and EQ scores had also increased. I wasn't expecting 42 points but I was definitely expecting something. At the end of my work day when I hadn't received any alerts, I decide to call TU and EQ to find out if there was still a CA on my CR from Debt Recovery Solutions. TU said yes and EQ said no. So I decide it's ok to go ahead and buy an updated My FICO EQ CR since EQ confirmed it was removed. My score is still at 697. Is that not odd? 

On 3/4/13 EQ was 687.

On 4/4/13 EQ jumped to 697 due to another 2 1/2 year old CA being deleted.

I never received an EQ score reduction when the new CA hit my CR on 3/15. Is that why I didn't receive an increase?

As of 4/5/13, my FICO TU is 667 (yikes!!). I hope this increases when the CA is deleted.

Lesson: Teach yourself not to depend on SW. That way hopes do not rise, nor does disappointment occur. 

[shanac]

Bump

[guiness56]

There could be many reasons why your score didn't go up or down.

What else is on your reports?

[DiabolicallyRandom]

When I was in that score range I was getting 2 and 5 point bumps for things, even lost a point once. When my last terrible awful was removed I got a 48 point bump.

[shanac]

I have one other CA from 2009 that I haven't tackled yet.

[deadbishop]

Shanac... This may be a dumb question but are you 100 percent sure that CA reported to EQ in the first place? I know you said on 3/15 that the new CA reported to all 3 but are you going by what they told you or did you see it on EQ yourself? Maybe it only hit on EX and TU. your EX score dropped then came back and TU slow as hell but you called them so you know it's on there but EQ just said no you don't have that new CA on here. Just maybe it never did get put on EQ. That would explain no SW update for the ding or removal.

[shanac]

Deadbishop, I never thought of that! I never pulled report and I just assumed a CA would report to all three. Thanks for that perspective. Thanks to everyone for your comments. I still have another CA to work on!

[deadbishop]

Shanac it might be a great idea if you have a few extra bucks to get a daily puller. Usaa and eidt has one. You can pull all 3 reports everyday. This is good to have to see exactly what's on all 3. They run 12 to 20 bucks a month.

[shanac]

Deadbishop can I sign up for those even if I'm not a member? What's eidt?

[deadbishop]

Usaa you have to be a member and to join you have to be in military or have a family member in military.

Eidt is eliminate Id theft.