Equifax and My Fico Reports not the same?

[let]

  I recieved this from EQ in an email (dispute)

The Results Of Our Reinvestigation

>>> We have reviewed your concerns and our conclusions are:

The following disputed account or inquiry is currently not reporting on your Equifax credit file: XXXX College

I wasn't sure what that meant, I was hoping it meant deleted.  I called EQ to ask for the meaning and she said it meant EQ  was never reporting that collection.  I explained to her that it was on my EQ  CR, that's why I disputed it.  She asked where I received my report, I advised her MY Fico. She went onto say MyFico was a third party, blah, blah..so I said to her, what you're saying to me is MyFico and EQ do not report the same?  She kept saying My Fico is a third party...I understand MY Fico is a third party..not Equifax..any thoughts?

Below is what was on my EQ CR from My Fico, I deleted the name of the college:Collection on debt to:

xxxxS College The collection agency

"605YC52663"

was hired to collect a debt of $190 originally owed to

"XXXXX College "

on account number

"XXXXXXX"

.             

Collection agency [?] Original balance [?] Current balance [?] Date assigned [?] Original lender [?] Account number [?] Account holder [?]

605YC52663

$190

$190

Mar 30, 2011

xxxxx College

XXXXXXX

Individual

[DaveSignal]

Well you can't really know for sure if the CSR is correct unless you pull your EQ report directly from Equifax.  Have you used your free anuual report yet?

[let]

I have, I'll have to double check it when I get home.  I want to say I do remember that specific collection on there. 

[let]

Update..received an e mail from Equifax about two items I disputed.  Again the result was "these items are not being reported on your credit file" or something to that effect. I guess I'll have bite the bullet and actually buy my credit report from Equifax...

[StartingOver10]

Have you already pulled your free report from Equifax? You get a free report every year from www.annualcreditreport.com  That is the only place the report is actually free. EQ, TU and EX are mandated to allow consumers to pull a free report one time per year from that site only. Don't go to the EQ marketing site as they will charge you for it.

[let]

Yes, I did, back in January. 

[spike69]

I had a similar issue- I sent them a faxed copy and that got me more action from there

[let]

So I should send them a copy of the credit report showing the collections right?

[spike69]

That is what I did.

[Sonic98]

I too recently noticed different things on my report from MyFico, creditchecktotal, and pulling the reports directly from the CRAs. Sometimes I'll check sites like CreditKarma and Quizzle as well, but I would guess whatever the CRAs have is most acurate. My only problem is I'm not sure Experian is actually giving me an updated reporting or just putting a new date on an old report number