No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
I think you should pay off the bigger ones first, not the smaller ones. I'd use most of that $3000 and completely pay off Kay Jewelers. That immediately frees up $195 a month in cash flow that can go toward paying down the others.
The payoff order should be highest interest rates to lowest rates so if Kays is your highest pay it off first. You dont have an unmanagable amount of debt here, I would advise you to cut up and toss the cards until you get this under control. The credit game can be addicting and I know all too well the rush when that "Congratulations" appears on the screen but I have learned that impulse control has to be applied to stay out of credit card hell. I wish you well in getting this under control
At this point, it appears the goal is to avoid default, and thus credit score damage.
That would seem to mandate paying off the higest monthly payment accts first, thus getting their min monthly payments down as quick as possible, which will hopefully prevent account defaults.
Paying the highest monthly APR accounts first clearly makes the best financial sense, but would, if payments are that tight, not in my opinion be the best priority as long as chance of not making all monthly payments still exists.
If I were you I would definitely pay off Kay's and Fingerhut first, they are the largest payments and interest you have. The others will be much more manageable when you aren't paying $245 a month to just those two.