cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

tag
Lboo
Valued Member

Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

Hi All:

 

I was sued for a medical bill and a judgment was entered in 2010 and my wages were garnished.  The debt was satisfied in 2011 and the CA had a release satisfaction of judgment entered.  However, the debt is showing on my credit report as an unpaid judgment.  My question is can I use the HIPAA laws to have the debt removed or should I just dispute it and send the credit bureaus the release to update my credit report as paid?  Thanks for any responses. 

Starting/Current Scores: MyFICO EX 547/608, EQ 557/585, TU 555/606
Goals: Raise my scores to 620 to get a mortgage then car loan early 2016
Other Notes: Started with 23 Collections and 3 Judgments
9 dropping off 2015 - 8 paid waiting for Goodwill deletions
2 Judgments Paid – One deleted/waiting for second one to delete in July 2015/Paying third judgment August 2015 and deletion
2 cell phone collection disputes (Verizon and U.S. Cellular) and 4 collections to pay by August 2015 for DEBT FREEDOM!!!
Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES 4
RobertEG
Legendary Contributor

Re: Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

HIPAA has express provisions that permit the retention of sufficient information that does no otherwise violate privacy provisions of the act that is related to collection of a medical debt.  HIPAA does not explicitly have provisions dealing with deletion of information reported to CRAs based on having paid a medical debt.

 

There are procedures that are based on interpretations of HIPAA that purportedly require deletion of medical information from consumer reports after the permissible retention based on collection of the debt have expired by payment of the debt.  They are untested interpretations of law that are not specifically advocated on this site.

 

Can you use HIPAA for deletions?

Perhaps, but you will have to get the procedures for any sjuch interpretations elsewhere.

 

AS for filing a dispute based only on  showing of payment of the debt, each CRA has the same policy that information should not be deleted based on payment of the debt, the reporteing by the debt collector relates to the fact that they had, at a prior point, collection authority.  Payment of the debt does not negate that fact, and thus there is no inaccuracy in reporting upon which to base a dispute soley due to payment of a debt.

The CRAs have a joint crredit reporting manual that includes the express provision that reporting not be deleted based on payment of a debt, so some basis other than simply payment would be necessary to show error.

Message 2 of 5
Lboo
Valued Member

Re: Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

Thanks for clearing that up.  I would like to have the credit bureau update the account as paid and I recalled from information I received in the past that you can send the release to the credit bureaus and they will note in your report that it has been satisfied and paid.  I kind of figured it would not be able to be removed.   

Starting/Current Scores: MyFICO EX 547/608, EQ 557/585, TU 555/606
Goals: Raise my scores to 620 to get a mortgage then car loan early 2016
Other Notes: Started with 23 Collections and 3 Judgments
9 dropping off 2015 - 8 paid waiting for Goodwill deletions
2 Judgments Paid – One deleted/waiting for second one to delete in July 2015/Paying third judgment August 2015 and deletion
2 cell phone collection disputes (Verizon and U.S. Cellular) and 4 collections to pay by August 2015 for DEBT FREEDOM!!!
Message 3 of 5
LIGHTNIN
Senior Contributor

Re: Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

I believe what you are looking for is called a "motion to vacate" a judgment.

Then if the judge approves your motion, you can have it removed from your CR.

 

 

FICO's May 2015 EQ764 ~~Live below your means and always keep an emergency fund -Love Everybody ~ Big Kenny ~ Big and Rich ~~~~~Credit Scoring 101 - Common Abbreviations - Freq Req Threads - Free Credit Reports - What Steps Do I Take?DV? PFD?
Message 4 of 5
Lboo
Valued Member

Re: Medical Judgment Can I Use HIPAA Laws?

Thanks!! I will check into seeing if I have grounds to get the judgment vacated. However, I paid it off already by being garnished and it happened four years ago so I don't remember all the details and I kind of doubt it could be but that would be awesome though if I can.  

Starting/Current Scores: MyFICO EX 547/608, EQ 557/585, TU 555/606
Goals: Raise my scores to 620 to get a mortgage then car loan early 2016
Other Notes: Started with 23 Collections and 3 Judgments
9 dropping off 2015 - 8 paid waiting for Goodwill deletions
2 Judgments Paid – One deleted/waiting for second one to delete in July 2015/Paying third judgment August 2015 and deletion
2 cell phone collection disputes (Verizon and U.S. Cellular) and 4 collections to pay by August 2015 for DEBT FREEDOM!!!
Message 5 of 5
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.