cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

tag
LS2982
Mega Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


@madredejames wrote:

 

I received an email from ScoreWatch today with an alert. I was hoping it was that my score had gone up, as I just paid down my two credit cards (total CL of $800) to below $30 each. I had been near my CL before paying these 2 accounts down. Well, that information hasn't factored into my score yet.

 

I was alarmed to see my FICO score had dropped by 13 points. Before I found this forum and myfico, I had signed up with one of those credit repair services (not a good choice, I know now.) Shortly after signing up with them, I canceled my account, but apparently they had already sent some disputes on my credit report. The disputes are the only change showing on my credit report. I am wondering if these disputes actually made my score drop, based on the way the information is being reported?

 

Here are a couple of examples. I am thinking that the score drop could have come from the change from "amount in high credit is charge off amount" to "amount in high credit is credit limit"? 

 

If so, what can I do about this? Is there anyway to remove disputes? Unfortunately, I had started the credit repair thing before I met with a mortgage broker. He looked at my report and gave me some recommendations. He said it was best not to have disputes on there and to remove them.

 

Any advice or helping me understand this is much appreciated. I am trying hard to do things right.

 

EMB/BELK  (XXXXXXXXXXXX0504)



Account opened: 7/2007
Description: Consumer disputes - reinvestigation in process
Amount in H/C column is credit limit


 

 Previously reportedNewly reported
Balance:$0$0
Past due:$0$0
Status:Bad Debt; Placed for collection;Bad Debt; Placed for collection;
Last activity:11/1/200711/1/2007
High credit:$303$500
Description:Account transferred or sold
Charge off account
Amount in high credit is original charge-off amount
Consumer disputes - reinvestigation in process
Amount in H/C column is credit limit

 

 

 

Another example:

 

MERRICK BANK  (XXXXXXXXXXXX2073)



Account opened: 4/2007
Description: Consumer disputes - reinvestigation in process
Amount in H/C column is credit limit


 

 Previously reportedNewly reported
Balance:$0$0
Past due:$0$0
Status:Bad Debt; Placed for collection;Bad Debt; Placed for collection;
Last activity:9/1/20079/1/2007
High credit:$1,891$1,500
Description:Settlement accepted on this account
Charge off account
Amount in high credit is original charge-off amount
Consumer disputes - reinvestigation in process
Amount in H/C column is credit limit

 

 


Are those 2 debts payed off or do you still owe them?? It does nothing for you to dispute them if they are accuate debts still owed.

 




EQ FICO 548 3/3/16
Message 11 of 18
madredejames
Established Member

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


Are those 2 debts payed off or do you still owe them?? It does nothing for you to dispute them if they are accuate debts still owed.

 


Starting Score: EQ 565 TU 590 EX 583 (PLUS)
Current Score: EQ 565 TU 590 EX 651 (PLUS)
Goal Score: 680

 

 

 

Reply:

 

Yes, I am aware that it does nothing to dispute real debts still owed. I mentioned early in my posts about this that it was a mistake that these disputes happened, caused by signing up with a credit repair service which seemed legit. I educated myself, a bit too late, and immediately canceled the credit repair service.

 

One of these debts was settled.

 

After my initial panic, I am not going to fret about this, but will learn from it and move forward. My husband and I have already made plans to pay off the one real remaining debt now that he is employed again and our financial situation has turned around.

 


Message 12 of 18
LS2982
Mega Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


@madredejames wrote:

 


Are those 2 debts payed off or do you still owe them?? It does nothing for you to dispute them if they are accuate debts still owed.

 


Starting Score: EQ 565 TU 590 EX 583 (PLUS)
Current Score: EQ 565 TU 590 EX 651 (PLUS)
Goal Score: 680

 

 

 

Reply:

 

Yes, I am aware that it does nothing to dispute real debts still owed. I mentioned early in my posts about this that it was a mistake that these disputes happened, caused by signing up with a credit repair service which seemed legit. I educated myself, a bit too late, and immediately canceled the credit repair service.

 

One of these debts was settled.

 

After my initial panic, I am not going to fret about this, but will learn from it and move forward. My husband and I have already made plans to pay off the one real remaining debt now that he is employed again and our financial situation has turned around.

 



Which credit repair service did you use if you dont mind me asking? Im under the assumption you tell them which accts to dispute they dont just pick one and go for it.

 




EQ FICO 548 3/3/16
Message 13 of 18
madredejames
Established Member

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

In my case signing up with a credit repair company was a mistake. I canceled with them about a week after signing up after I found this website and learned more.

 

Apparently, they sent dispute letters on my behalf, but I now wish that had not happened. I would not have disputed these debts knowing what I know now. It's not like they didn't happen or belong to someone else. It would have been better to have left well enough alone.

 

The companies seem to try to just dispute everything and hope that something beneficial happens. They don't really care about the ramifications if it backfires.

Message 14 of 18
LS2982
Mega Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


@madredejames wrote:

In my case signing up with a credit repair company was a mistake. I canceled with them about a week after signing up after I found this website and learned more.

 

Apparently, they sent dispute letters on my behalf, but I now wish that had not happened. I would not have disputed these debts knowing what I know now. It's not like they didn't happen or belong to someone else. It would have been better to have left well enough alone.

 

The companies seem to try to just dispute everything and hope that something beneficial happens. They don't really care about the ramifications if it backfires.


I guess it depends on which one you use. I'm having sucess with the one im using. I have to give them direction into what I want done, and they go from there. I wish I did have the patience to do it on my own, but I know i'll just get frustrated with it.

 




EQ FICO 548 3/3/16
Message 15 of 18
cw81
Frequent Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


@madredejames wrote:

In my case signing up with a credit repair company was a mistake. I canceled with them about a week after signing up after I found this website and learned more.

 

Apparently, they sent dispute letters on my behalf, but I now wish that had not happened. I would not have disputed these debts knowing what I know now. It's not like they didn't happen or belong to someone else. It would have been better to have left well enough alone.

 

The companies seem to try to just dispute everything and hope that something beneficial happens. They don't really care about the ramifications if it backfires.


Sorry about  your fiasco with the  CRO   Its unfortunate  you learn so much here for free  it just requires your time and  some effort  when I first  came here  I spent  like two weeks reading for like 4 hours a night  before I even signed up.  I have gained so much I would never have got from  paying  to have it done.  You learn that some of those organizations dont really have  a clue.

 

Message 16 of 18
cw81
Frequent Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

I dont think if you are paying them you should be giving them direction as to what they should be doing in my opinion.  All they are doing is writing letters  that  you could do yourself and  paying for postage you could do yourself.  Most of the letters are here on this site   if you look hard enough and all you have to do is modify them to match your situation.   The wait  for disputes to come badk is the same whether you do it or they do it.  The responses will be the same whether you do it or they do it  so i don't see it as cost effective. You do spend time reading and researching but   I am wiser and more savvy for it .  I hope it works out for you  but I would rather clean up my mess myself  and  do it right  just my  2 cents


@LS2982 wrote:

 


@madredejames wrote:

In my case signing up with a credit repair company was a mistake. I canceled with them about a week after signing up after I found this website and learned more.

 

Apparently, they sent dispute letters on my behalf, but I now wish that had not happened. I would not have disputed these debts knowing what I know now. It's not like they didn't happen or belong to someone else. It would have been better to have left well enough alone.

 

The companies seem to try to just dispute everything and hope that something beneficial happens. They don't really care about the ramifications if it backfires.


I guess it depends on which one you use. I'm having sucess with the one im using. I have to give them direction into what I want done, and they go from there. I wish I did have the patience to do it on my own, but I know i'll just get frustrated with it.

 


 

Message 17 of 18
LS2982
Mega Contributor

Re: ScoreWatch 13-point drop-disputes causing?- help!

 


@cw81 wrote:

I dont think if you are paying them you should be giving them direction as to what they should be doing in my opinion.  All they are doing is writing letters  that  you could do yourself and  paying for postage you could do yourself.  Most of the letters are here on this site   if you look hard enough and all you have to do is modify them to match your situation.   The wait  for disputes to come badk is the same whether you do it or they do it.  The responses will be the same whether you do it or they do it  so i don't see it as cost effective. You do spend time reading and researching but   I am wiser and more savvy for it .  I hope it works out for you  but I would rather clean up my mess myself  and  do it right  just my  2 cents


@LS2982 wrote:

 


@madredejames wrote:

In my case signing up with a credit repair company was a mistake. I canceled with them about a week after signing up after I found this website and learned more.

 

Apparently, they sent dispute letters on my behalf, but I now wish that had not happened. I would not have disputed these debts knowing what I know now. It's not like they didn't happen or belong to someone else. It would have been better to have left well enough alone.

 

The companies seem to try to just dispute everything and hope that something beneficial happens. They don't really care about the ramifications if it backfires.


I guess it depends on which one you use. I'm having sucess with the one im using. I have to give them direction into what I want done, and they go from there. I wish I did have the patience to do it on my own, but I know i'll just get frustrated with it.

 


 


I know alot of ppl here do it themself, I may just use them for like 2-3 months then cancel. I can garden my own CC's and make progress on my own. Just rather have them deal with the CA's cause theyre's only 2 to deal with. The others been paid and removed! Smiley Very Happy

 




EQ FICO 548 3/3/16
Message 18 of 18
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.