cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

tag
need2improve
New Contributor

Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

hello all,

 

I've been thinking recently of selling my house, and purchasing a new one while the home prices are still low.  My fako scores had been improving, and I was feeling really good about paying off some debts I had been working really hard on.  Pulled my FICO scores today and was in for a real shocker....TU 560 and Equifax 556! I was really surprised because my fako scores are in the 650s, and I thought my FICO score would be around 620 (this is the number i've been aiming for).  I have a new suv that is paid off....should I take a loan against it and just pay off the rest of my debts and credit cards, and then just pay the loan back fast?  Would this help or hurt my score?  Would this help or hurt my attaining a mortgage? Or should I not bother with the loan and continue the course of paying off my debts little by little?  Thanks in advance!


Starting Score: 486 TU 3/2/10
Current Score: TU 603 EQ 582
Goal Score: 640

Message 1 of 8
7 REPLIES 7
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?


@need2improve wrote:

hello all,

 

I've been thinking recently of selling my house, and purchasing a new one while the home prices are still low.  My fako scores had been improving, and I was feeling really good about paying off some debts I had been working really hard on.  Pulled my FICO scores today and was in for a real shocker....TU 560 and Equifax 556! I was really surprised because my fako scores are in the 650s, and I thought my FICO score would be around 620 (this is the number i've been aiming for).  I have a new suv that is paid off....should I take a loan against it and just pay off the rest of my debts and credit cards, and then just pay the loan back fast?  Would this help or hurt my score?  Would this help or hurt my attaining a mortgage? Or should I not bother with the loan and continue the course of paying off my debts little by little?  Thanks in advance!


What are your current interest rates on your credit cards, and what interest rate ( approx ) would you qualify for with your potential Auto Loan ?

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 2 of 8
need2improve
New Contributor

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

The interest will be high of course, it won't be any higher than what i am already paying...I'm not really gaining anything in terms of the interest. but rather will gain as the old debts will finally be paid off (which are charge offs and collections, and 1 judgement which is almost paid off), and i will have just one bill to pay and keep up with monthly.


Starting Score: 486 TU 3/2/10
Current Score: TU 603 EQ 582
Goal Score: 640

Message 3 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

Are those collections still accruing interest? I understand the desire for simplicity, but that convenience may end up costing you some serious cash...

Message 4 of 8
need2improve
New Contributor

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

yes, they are unfortunately :-(  I have 2 accounts that are still accruing interest actually.  One of which is the one that is almost paid off.


Starting Score: 486 TU 3/2/10
Current Score: TU 603 EQ 582
Goal Score: 640

Message 5 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

Well, in that case it _might_ actually makes sense. If you'd like some more detailed advice, post the detailed data - each account, the balance, and the rates, and we can help you figure out the best plan.

Message 6 of 8
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

 

Also give some thought to the term of the Auto loan that you would take....3 years ?  4 years ?   What time frame would you be looking at ?

 

Could you pay down the debt in the same period of time without consolidating it ?

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 7 of 8
nws2002
Established Member

Re: Should I take a car loan (cash out) to pay off debt?

I'm not sure I would replace what I'm assuming are unsecured debts with a secured one.

 

Right now you have a vehicle, default on the loan however and that could disappear.  I don't think anyone really obtains a loan and with the intention of default, but life happens sometimes.

Message 8 of 8
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.