Based on your info, first one would fit you well as you currently have an LV card holder and there's not enough room for what you wanna carry. Tumi is well known for their leather products, so you can trust their quality. I buy many of their wallets during X-Mas as gifts, giving Bloomingdales their business.
I've bought them for my DH and DS. They love them! Now that they have a id theft protection, I think they are even better. By the way..., they like the Alpha wallets.
