cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Balance decreases and so does score?

tag
diann744
Member

Balance decreases and so does score?

The balance on one of my cards went from $399 to $0 and my score dropped 32 points?!  Seriously?  Can someone help shed light on why this might possibly be?

 

I pay off EVERYTHING, EVERY month before the due date.  This month, I paid before the billing cycle hit.  Why can my score drop so far simply because I now have a zero balance?

 

I'd love some guidance here.

 

Thanks

 

D

Message 1 of 6
5 REPLIES 5
CH-7-Mission-Accomplished
Valued Contributor

Re: Balance decreases and so does score?

FICO will ding you 20 points for all credit reports reporting zero.  It is well known here and discussed in thousands of posts.

 

Let $5 report on one card and then pay it by the due date.  Problem solved.

Message 2 of 6
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Balance decreases and so does score?

Yep Ch-7 is spot on when I let my accounts report zero balances I always get dinged. It really will not matter unless you are appling for a credit product though. 

Message 3 of 6
diann744
Member

Re: Balance decreases and so does score?

Really?  Wow, I've been monitoring for years and never saw that.  Zero balances are quite the norm for me.  Thanks so much for the tip; I'll definitely do that from now on.  Ouch!  My score generally goes up and down between 2 and 8 points with no rhyme or reason but I've never seen 32 in either direction!  Freaked me out.  Is it something to do with the new FICIO 9 scoring?

 

I appreciate your help!

Message 4 of 6
CH-7-Mission-Accomplished
Valued Contributor

Re: Balance decreases and so does score?


@diann744 wrote:

Really?  Wow, I've been monitoring for years and never saw that.  Zero balances are quite the norm for me.  Thanks so much for the tip; I'll definitely do that from now on.  Ouch!  My score generally goes up and down between 2 and 8 points with no rhyme or reason but I've never seen 32 in either direction!  Freaked me out.  Is it something to do with the new FICIO 9 scoring?

 

I appreciate your help!


The problem goes away the second another one of your cards reports even a $2 balance.  You don't have to wait a whole month unless you only have one card.

 

Where people get totally **bleep**ed is when they are getting ready for a mortgage or a car loan and pay all cards down to zero thinking they are maximizing their scores only to find out they got royally screwed with a 20 or 30 point drop in FICO scores.

It's the same thing that happens when you pay off an installment loan -- car, student loan, share secured.  Scores usually drop 20 points for "doing a good thing"

FICO isn't designed to reward consumers, it is designed to make scienticially valid predictions based on millions and millions of profiles.

 

Sucks, I know, but once you know the game, you won't make the mistake again.

 

The all cards reporting a zero balance is the easiest of all things to fix.  Don't sweat it but do understand it.

Message 5 of 6
diann744
Member

Re: Balance decreases and so does score?

I'm not looking for new credit or applying for anything but I've brought my rating up from an abysmal low of 540 (10 years ago) to 834.  I play it like a video game, for (internal) bragging rights.  Today's drop was an ego blow.  I feel like I need to stay up all night honing my mad FICO skills.  :-)

Message 6 of 6
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.