12-12-2012 04:30 AM
Just a note for those that compare FAKOs to FICOs and say that CK is usually close. Walmart TU08 came out today. DW's FICO was 754, her TU on CK was 644. That's just a difference of 110 points.
12-12-2012 08:29 AM
For me it is similar on the Vantage part. It says 680 and WM FICO says 676. It was 709 before I added 4 new TLs and had util report over 50% on a card and WM FICO was 706. I don't take it as an actual score and any similarities are pure coincidence. Just use it for the report of Util, new inquiries, TLs, etc. and that's it.
12-12-2012 11:12 AM
The utility of the ck score really depends on whether its major differences from FICO apply to you. For example, CK counts average age of open accounts, whereas fico counts average age of all posted accounts (including closed). If you have no closed accounts, both will track similarly. If, like me, you have over 20 closed accounts, the difference is significant. Same with inquiries. I had my only TU inquiry fall off yesterday. Today, ck was unchanged, but ck vantage went up 5 points. I'm reasonably sure my fico would bump at least a little going from 1 to 0. My guess is that inquiry penalties depreciate faster on CK than on fico, so I likely saw the benefit of aging inquiry on ck some time ago. My guess is someone with a relatively new profile, a ton of inquiries, no negatives and no closed accounts would see a strong correlation. The rest, not so much.
That being said, CK keeps getting more and more detailed, to the point where it is almost equivalent to a credit report. Also, the vantage is used by a few lenders. I continue to find ck more valuable for tracking my overall credit profile than scorewatch, credit sesame or credit.com
12-12-2012 01:42 PM
My CK is at 748 and TU08 is at 759. On CK the CK score goes up, the Vantage score goes up and the Insurability score goes down. Makes no rhyme or reason.
12-12-2012 06:31 PM
My CK literally JUST jumped over 600, even with TU98 being 638 at least 90 days ago, with 3 more major derogatories listed.
|Chase Freedom $9500|
DCU Visa $10000
Capital One QS $2000
AMEX BCE $3000
|Lowe's CC $8500|
WalMart CC $3100
BOA Platinum $600
AMEX Gold NPSL
12-13-2012 02:20 PM
Just for sh!ts and giggles I logged on to credit karma to see if something new posted nearly heart nearly ripped through my chest when I saw 698 staring back at me when I knew I had 755 a month prior. Panicked strickened I paid the dang 19.95 for a transunion report to my relief 760 staring back at me backed by MYFICO- my trusted buddy!! so basically, use ck for entertain,ent purposes or to keep track of accounts but don't worry if the numbers look scary. Although, sometimes the score given on ck can be higher than what myfico says. TRUST ONLY MYFICO!
12-14-2012 08:52 AM
Another comparison to add to the mix. My CK score: 638 MyFico TU: 670. I always tell people to take it with a grain of salt, because the scores are not worth the pixels they occupy on their monitor
12-14-2012 09:19 AM
However, I use creditchecktotal.com and they are not too far off of my FICO scores: