Scoring impact of different types of public records

[3darcher2]

Does anyone have any input as to how much impact different types of public records have?  Are they the same?  Like a 2 year old released tax lien is the same as a 2 year old paid judgment?  How about amount?  Is a $10,000 judgment worse than a $500 one?

If you had an otherwise clean report, what would be worse score-wise?  A $1000 charge off or a $1000 judgment.  I have read PRs are the worst, is that true?

[llecs]

I believe that all PRs are scored the same. For certain, the balance doesn't matter at all, just like with CAs.

I'd guess the initial hit would be the same. If I had to choose, I'd choose the CO, privided it wasn't a CC CO hurting util too. At least with the CO you'd have the age and potential positive impact to AAoA helping you.

[RobertEG]

Public records, for the most part being determinations based on findings of facts of consumer indebetness by a governmental/judicial agency, would, in my opinion, carry more weight that an internal bookeeping determination of a creditor.

Apart from the actual FICO weighting, manual review of PRs leads to  subjective opinions by creditors, and may be more significant than the actual point impact.