Established Contributor
DaveSignal
Posts: 896
Registered: ‎07-29-2011
FICO is inconsistent?

I  am having trouble figuring out what I need to do to improve my score, since my FICO changes inconsistently.  I am hoping that someone could look at this score-watch data and give an explanation:

 

DATE: 4/22/2012SCORE:643

SW ALERT: signed up for myFICO Score Watch

 

DATE: 4/24/2012SCORE: 668

SW ALERT: 

Your FICO score may have gone up because the following 2 factors are not hurting your FICO score as much as before:

  • You’ve recently missed a payment or the date of your most recent missed payment is unknown.
  • You have multiple accounts showing missed payments or derogatory descriptions.

DATE: 5/06/2012SCORE: 675

SW ALERT: New Installment Account

 

DATE: 5/08/2012SCORE: 675

SW ALERT: New Inquiry

 

DATE: 5/13/2012SCORE: 675

SW ALERT: New Inquiry

 

DATE: 5/15/2012SCORE: 675

SW ALERT: Small Balance increase on store-card account

 

DATE: 5/19/2012SCORE: 666

SW ALERT: Two charge-off accounts (1+2 of 4) put in dispute after I sent in letters requesting verification of DOFD.

 

DATE: 5/23/2012SCORE: 671

SW ALERT: No specific reason given

 

DATE: 5/24/2012SCORE: 655

At about this time all of my accounts had finished updating to $0 balance except for 1 store card report a $62 balance.  This combination put me at less than 1% utilization.

SW ALERT: Another charge-off (3 of 4) put in dispute after I requested on-line that the payment history should not continue to be updated after the date the CO was paid.

 

DATE: 5/26/2012SCORE: 655

SW ALERT: Charge-off 4 put in dispute for same request that CO should not be reporting payment history after paid and closed.

 

DATE: 5/31/2012SCORE: 655

SW ALERT: Charge-offs 1 and 2 come back verified expect that CO 1 is now reporting 'account status: open' instead of a paid and closed account.  called-in to request change to account status and account immediately put back in dispute.

 

DATE: 6/1/2012SCORE: 655

SW ALERT: Charge off 3 comes back verified and Charge off 1 back in dispute.

 

 

Does this stuff make any sense at all?  My score dropped 20 points when I lowered my util to <1% because a charge-off account was in dispute?

disputed accounts come back with no change but FICO remains lowered?

new accounts and inquiries have no effect on my FICO?

What is going on?

 


  FICO Scores: EQ:702 TU:696 EX:702

Gripping a Gloriously Gold Spade!



Gardening: NFCU nRewards $14k - USAA Rewards $4.5k - SDFCU Flexpoints EMV Chip+PIN $5k - BoA Travel Rewards EMV $4.5k