Hmmm.

If you had used the 2 of them up already, I 'd think that they'd both show up on your account, with the scores and dates you pulled them.

If this isn't a pressing issue, a mod or an administrator will probably be along in a while with a better solution for you.  But I think it might be "Customer Service" time.

Maybe a glitch, but I'm sure it'll get straightened out for you.

Keep us posted.