I have had the EXACT same problem. It is NOTHING with my settings. I had a free service with another credit alert and got my equifax alert from them, NOT fico. I called to voice my concern and they give me a run around everytime. Tonight I finally told them I want to cancel it and the representative said I couldnt. I had to keep it for 3 months.
Anytime I have called them I find them so unhelpful.
They truely have the worst customer service represtatives around.
So, now I am stuck with a score watch that is not sending me alerts although my settings are NOT the problem!