topic Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where? in Credit Cards

How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:02:12 GMT

I have had my Cap1 going on a year now. I have been getting additional requests from Cap1 for other cards. I applied and was approved to the Discover It in Jan but I had never received a mailing to apply. I just tried and was approved. I then PC to the Quicksilver this month and am waiting for my new card.

But I am receiving several other offers. Mostly cards I have no interest in. I was just wondering once you start getting better cards or higher CL's do you get solicitations a lot? I just got an AmerEx Blue app offer. Not going to apply as I wont be shopping for another CC for another year at least.

Just curious about the offers and if you receive them is that a good indication you would qualify for them?

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

WillTeasle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:12:40 GMT

As your credit improves, you will most likely see more offers. I think I see a card offer nearly every other day. Some of those offers have come from companies with which I don't currently have a relationship, and they SP my report more than some of my current lenders.

Unfortunately, I don't really know what they would offer in terms of CL or rate as most head to the shredder immediately.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Creditaddict — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:17:33 GMT

@BluePoodle wrote:
I have had my Cap1 going on a year now. I have been getting additional requests from Cap1 for other cards. I applied and was approved to the Discover It in Jan but I had never received a mailing to apply. I just tried and was approved. I then PC to the Quicksilver this month and am waiting for my new card.

But I am receiving several other offers. Mostly cards I have no interest in. I was just wondering once you start getting better cards or higher CL's do you get solicitations a lot? I just got an AmerEx Blue app offer. Not going to apply as I wont be shopping for another CC for another year at least.

Just curious about the offers and if you receive them is that a good indication you would qualify for them?

Id take the Blue offer... you will lock in your membership year with them forever as 2014!

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Uppingmyscore — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:21:23 GMT

Happy to say I do not get any offers.... been opt out for years. I only apply for credit cards I want and need.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:24:11 GMT

@creditaddict
I would but I need to apply for a car loan (actually two) at the end of April or early May and I don't want to jeopardize my interest rate offer with a lower score. Or the fact that I am requesting too much credit in a short period of time.

I applied for the Discover (I think it was a SP) but the auto loans are a higher priority.

Do you think it would hurt?

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:25:46 GMT

@Uppingmyscore wrote:

Happy to say I do not get any offers.... been opt out for years. I only apply for credit cards I want and need.

Once I get my 3rd CC, I plan to do the same!

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Creditaddict — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:26:04 GMT

@BluePoodle wrote:
@Creditaddict
I would but I need to apply for a car loan (actually two) at the end of April or early May and I don't want to jeopardize my interest rate offer with a lower score. Or the fact that I am requesting too much credit in a short period of time.

I applied for the Discover (I think it was a SP) but the auto loans are a higher priority.
Do you think it would hurt?

The Discover was for sure a HP.

2 cars?

I would not think the Amex app would effect your auto loans but since it's basically this month you can do the autos first.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 17:35:36 GMT

@Creditaddict wrote:
@BluePoodle wrote:
@Creditaddict
I would but I need to apply for a car loan (actually two) at the end of April or early May and I don't want to jeopardize my interest rate offer with a lower score. Or the fact that I am requesting too much credit in a short period of time.

I applied for the Discover (I think it was a SP) but the auto loans are a higher priority.
Do you think it would hurt?
The Discover was for sure a HP.
2 cars?
I would not think the Amex app would effect your auto loans but since it's basically this month you can do the autos first.

The other reason I thought I would wait is to achieive CLI with Discover and QS first. I really want higher limits and I understand that new cards would probably match that. Right now I am only $2000 with Discover and $3750 with QS. I understand it is pretty easy to get a CLI with discover and less so, with QS but I would think one year would allow me to get each of those up a bit before applying for a new card. Does this sound correct to get a better CL with Amex or any other card I might apply for? I really don't want an bunch of $2000 - $3000 CL cards.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Anonymous — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 19:42:11 GMT

@Creditaddict wrote:
@BluePoodle wrote:
I have had my Cap1 going on a year now. I have been getting additional requests from Cap1 for other cards. I applied and was approved to the Discover It in Jan but I had never received a mailing to apply. I just tried and was approved. I then PC to the Quicksilver this month and am waiting for my new card.

But I am receiving several other offers. Mostly cards I have no interest in. I was just wondering once you start getting better cards or higher CL's do you get solicitations a lot? I just got an AmerEx Blue app offer. Not going to apply as I wont be shopping for another CC for another year at least.

Just curious about the offers and if you receive them is that a good indication you would qualify for them?
Id take the Blue offer... you will lock in your membership year with them forever as 2014!

But if OP can get the Blue, he/she can probably get a more useful card, such as the Everday. Better than the Blue in every way.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 19:54:11 GMT

@Anonymous wrote:
@Creditaddict wrote:
@BluePoodle wrote:
I have had my Cap1 going on a year now. I have been getting additional requests from Cap1 for other cards. I applied and was approved to the Discover It in Jan but I had never received a mailing to apply. I just tried and was approved. I then PC to the Quicksilver this month and am waiting for my new card.

But I am receiving several other offers. Mostly cards I have no interest in. I was just wondering once you start getting better cards or higher CL's do you get solicitations a lot? I just got an AmerEx Blue app offer. Not going to apply as I wont be shopping for another CC for another year at least.

Just curious about the offers and if you receive them is that a good indication you would qualify for them?
Id take the Blue offer... you will lock in your membership year with them forever as 2014!
But if OP can get the Blue, he/she can probably get a more useful card, such as the Everday. Better than the Blue in every way.

It was the "Blue Cash Everyday Card" that I received the letter for. 0% APR for 15 months, 12.99 afterwords, No AF. It says "Flexibilty to cary a balance" which I have no idea what that means as a feature??? And $150 in statement credit after $500 in purchases for the first 3 months.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Anonymous — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 20:16:36 GMT

@BluePoodle wrote:
But if OP can get the Blue, he/she can probably get a more useful card, such as the Everday. Better than the Blue in every way.
It was the "Blue Cash Everyday Card" that I received the letter for. 0% APR for 15 months, 12.99 afterwords, No AF. It says "Flexibilty to cary a balance" which I have no idea what that means as a feature??? And $150 in statement credit after $500 in purchases for the first 3 months.

OK, that is a different card from the Amex Blue.

Flexibility to carry a balance just means it isn't a charge card, you don't have to pay the full amount every month. For most credit card companies, that would be what you expect, but with Amex's background in charge cards (which DO need to paid fully each month unless you have "pay over time" feature granted) they feel the need to say that.

As a personal crusade, I don't recommend the BCE to anyone though! If you want a card to get cash back on light spending on gas and groceries, get the Sallie Mae, if you spend around 5-6000 on groceries a year, get the Blue Cash Preferred (and Sallie Mae for the gas and Amazon). If you spend a lot more, get the Blue Cash. If you just want an Amex to get a Member Since Date, get the new Everyday card.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Open123 — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 20:27:34 GMT

@Anonymous wrote:
As a personal crusade, I don't recommend the BCE to anyone though! If you want a card to get cash back on light spending on gas and groceries, get the Sallie Mae, if you spend around 5-6000 on groceries a year, get the Blue Cash Preferred (and Sallie Mae for the gas and Amazon). If you spend a lot more, get the Blue Cash. If you just want an Amex to get a Member Since Date, get the new Everyday card.

Right, there's absolutely NO reason to opt for the BCE, other than having an Amex TL. For lesser grocery spending, the Sallie Mae is better; and, for higher spending, the BCP is better.

And, now with the ED, there isn't even a reason to use up a valuable revolver slot on the BCE for the Amex TL.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 20:35:18 GMT

@Open123 wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:
As a personal crusade, I don't recommend the BCE to anyone though! If you want a card to get cash back on light spending on gas and groceries, get the Sallie Mae, if you spend around 5-6000 on groceries a year, get the Blue Cash Preferred (and Sallie Mae for the gas and Amazon). If you spend a lot more, get the Blue Cash. If you just want an Amex to get a Member Since Date, get the new Everyday card.
+1

Right, there's absolutely NO reason to opt for the BCE, other than having an Amex TL. For lesser grocery spending, the Sallie Mae is better; and, for higher spending, the BCP is better.

And, now with the ED, there isn't even a reason to use up a valuable revolver slot on the BCE for the Amex TL.

So now based on these two responses, I am totally confused. Not sure what what I should be wanting in a CC. Not sure what the Amex TL is and I don't know much about SM. I am going to have to do more reading it seems.... But Thanks for your suggestions.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Anonymous — Sun, 30 Mar 2014 22:15:47 GMT

OK, I will try to expand a little! But the basic point is that not every card from an issuer is worthwhile (and just because you get a preapproval doesn't mean you should take it, especially if there are good alternatives.)

The Blue Cash Everyday: 3% off groceries up to $6K per year, 2% off gas and select department stores (no cap) 1% off everything else. No AF.

Sallie Mae: 5% off gas and groceries, up to $250 per month each (so $3K a year on groceries), plus 5% off "bookstores" including all Amazon purchases, up to $750 a month, no AF.

Blue Cash Preferred: 6% off groceries up to $6K a year, 3% off gas and select department stores, 1% off everything else.

TheManWhoCan has posted charts detailing rewards vs spending on gas and groceries, and the BCE NEVER is the best choice. So even though the grocery cap is higher than Sallie Mae, it is outweighed by the lower earnings on the first $250 per month (5% rather than 3%). As you get closer to $6K a year, the BCP becomes better, even with the AF (although still get the SM in addition, for gas and Amazon). For large gas and groceries purchases, use the Blue Cash, (if only gas is big, use a 5% gas card from Penfed or Fort Knox)

Sallie Mae is a really good card, better for all than BCE, and better for most than Chase Amazon (which only gets 3% on Amazon purchases).

The other two cards mentioned:

Blue Cash. THis is an older card that is still available for heavy spenders. After $6,500 per year, it gives 5% uncapped on groceries, gas and drug stores.

Amex Everyday. A new card that gives 2MR points on supermarkets up to $6K a year, 1MR on everything else, but if you make 20 or more purchases a month, you get a 20% bonues, so 2.4MR on supermarkets and 1.2% on everything else.

Edit: I missed Amex TL. This is just "Trade Line", i.e. an Amex card. Amex limits the number of credit cards you can have (four in most cases) so as time goes on, you don't want to "waste" them with underperforming cards.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Mon, 31 Mar 2014 01:25:19 GMT

@Anonymous wrote:
OK, I will try to expand a little! But the basic point is that not every card from an issuer is worthwhile (and just because you get a preapproval doesn't mean you should take it, especially if there are good alternatives.)

The Blue Cash Everyday: 3% off groceries up to $6K per year, 2% off gas and select department stores (no cap) 1% off everything else. No AF.

Sallie Mae: 5% off gas and groceries, up to $250 per month each (so $3K a year on groceries), plus 5% off "bookstores" including all Amazon purchases, up to $750 a month, no AF.

Blue Cash Preferred: 6% off groceries up to $6K a year, 3% off gas and select department stores, 1% off everything else.

TheManWhoCan has posted charts detailing rewards vs spending on gas and groceries, and the BCE NEVER is the best choice. So even though the grocery cap is higher than Sallie Mae, it is outweighed by the lower earnings on the first $250 per month (5% rather than 3%). As you get closer to $6K a year, the BCP becomes better, even with the AF (although still get the SM in addition, for gas and Amazon). For large gas and groceries purchases, use the Blue Cash, (if only gas is big, use a 5% gas card from Penfed or Fort Knox)

Sallie Mae is a really good card, better for all than BCE, and better for most than Chase Amazon (which only gets 3% on Amazon purchases).

The other two cards mentioned:

Blue Cash. THis is an older card that is still available for heavy spenders. After $6,500 per year, it gives 5% uncapped on groceries, gas and drug stores.
Amex Everyday. A new card that gives 2MR points on supermarkets up to $6K a year, 1MR on everything else, but if you make 20 or more purchases a month, you get a 20% bonues, so 2.4MR on supermarkets and 1.2% on everything else.

Edit: I missed Amex TL. This is just "Trade Line", i.e. an Amex card. Amex limits the number of credit cards you can have (four in most cases) so as time goes on, you don't want to "waste" them with underperforming cards.

Thank you for the explaination. That helps a lot!

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

BluePoodle — Tue, 15 Apr 2014 04:27:15 GMT

@Anonymous wrote:
OK, I will try to expand a little! But the basic point is that not every card from an issuer is worthwhile (and just because you get a preapproval doesn't mean you should take it, especially if there are good alternatives.)

The Blue Cash Everyday: 3% off groceries up to $6K per year, 2% off gas and select department stores (no cap) 1% off everything else. No AF.

Sallie Mae: 5% off gas and groceries, up to $250 per month each (so $3K a year on groceries), plus 5% off "bookstores" including all Amazon purchases, up to $750 a month, no AF.

Blue Cash Preferred: 6% off groceries up to $6K a year, 3% off gas and select department stores, 1% off everything else.

TheManWhoCan has posted charts detailing rewards vs spending on gas and groceries, and the BCE NEVER is the best choice. So even though the grocery cap is higher than Sallie Mae, it is outweighed by the lower earnings on the first $250 per month (5% rather than 3%). As you get closer to $6K a year, the BCP becomes better, even with the AF (although still get the SM in addition, for gas and Amazon). For large gas and groceries purchases, use the Blue Cash, (if only gas is big, use a 5% gas card from Penfed or Fort Knox)

Sallie Mae is a really good card, better for all than BCE, and better for most than Chase Amazon (which only gets 3% on Amazon purchases).

The other two cards mentioned:

Blue Cash. THis is an older card that is still available for heavy spenders. After $6,500 per year, it gives 5% uncapped on groceries, gas and drug stores.
Amex Everyday. A new card that gives 2MR points on supermarkets up to $6K a year, 1MR on everything else, but if you make 20 or more purchases a month, you get a 20% bonues, so 2.4MR on supermarkets and 1.2% on everything else.

Edit: I missed Amex TL. This is just "Trade Line", i.e. an Amex card. Amex limits the number of credit cards you can have (four in most cases) so as time goes on, you don't want to "waste" them with underperforming cards.

So I have been reading up on these cards you mentioned Longtimelurker. I am really wanting an AmEx card but honestly, I dont' shop for my groceries at stand alone grocery stores. I hate grocery shopping so I usually hit Walmart and Target stores where I can get everything else I need too. So it is looking like Sallie Mae may be my best bet. I realize there is the $250 cap for gas and groceries but I do have a daughter in college so having the Bookstore at $750 might also make it valuable for me since she uses Amazon for most of her books. Then I guess once I hit my $250 cap I can use my QS at 1.5% or Discover for revolving catagories.

Thank you for your suggestions, and if anyone else has a suggestion for me to look at, please feel free to share.

Thanks again this has been most helpful!

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

Revelate — Tue, 15 Apr 2014 04:48:04 GMT

I didn't get any offers outside of CreditOne and other deep subprime lenders like Springleaf until I had established history for 2 years, and then only from lenders which I had a relationship with.

The ones I do get are mostly are meh, Chase Slate, le sigh. No balances, no use.

That said, I have a suspicion that the higher quality lenders do some simple analysis on a credit report: Discover once sent me an offer many moons ago when I only had a BOFA tradeline that I was using for car rentals (long before I consider myself to have "established" my credit report) but this go around with both Chase and Amex tradelines on it, I haven't heard a peep. Odds are that looking at my report I'm just not as likely to accept an offer as someone with varied tradelines certainly isn't the old model consumer who simply wrapped their arms around their local bank for virtually everything.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

lg8302ch — Tue, 15 Apr 2014 05:34:57 GMT

I never get any offers from decent cards/lenders. The only thing I get is the tons of pop up from shopping cart tricks but I am not interested in any of the store cards. Cards I am interested in I go with cold apps and it has worked so far

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

takeshi74 — Tue, 15 Apr 2014 12:46:02 GMT

@BluePoodle wrote:
Not sure what what I should be wanting in a CC.

Start with your major spend categories and see if any rewards match your spend. Are there any particular benefits that would be of use to you?

@Anonymous wrote:
and just because you get a preapproval doesn't mean you should take it, especially if there are good alternatives

In other words, preapprovals and offers are just marketing. While getting offers (especially those with lower APR's. etc) can be a good sign they really don't mean anything with regard to whether one will be approved or not. Don't just respond to marketing. Find cards that sre suited to you.

@Anonymous wrote:
But if OP can get the Blue, he/she can probably get a more useful card, such as the Everday. Better than the Blue in every way.

Better is always highly subjective. Everyday, for example, is pointless for me as I don't have any use for MR. As always, YMMV.

Re: How many CC app requests do you get and from where?

MoreRewards — Tue, 15 Apr 2014 15:30:41 GMT

Seems like I get offers constantly. From almost every place out there BOA, Commerce, Cap 1, Amex, Credit One, First Premier, US Bank...Chase & Citi to a lesser extent. I probably get the most from Amex but they SP my report like crazy so maybe that's why.