cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

NFCU refi decline. But wait...

Auto Loans for ANY Credit Situation. Immediate Response.
Advertiser disclosure
Highlighted
Frequent Contributor

NFCU refi decline. But wait...

With very little credit history, and while I was watching my coins, Navy Fed gave me a car loan for my daughter's car for 72 months at around 9%. I took it to get my foot in the door with Navy. Now, my scores are well-established and I've had the loan for over a year and am ready to do an internal refinance with Navy for a shorter term and better rate. The application was declined. So, I waited on the letter and it said that my EQ score is 680 (auto enhanced 5, looks like). Uhhhh... what the? My reports are clean and I'm AZEO. I don't get it.

 

So, I sent a SM basically asking what gives? There's no way that anyone manually looked at my application and turned me down. I just don't get it. They responded that I can contact them, tell them which bureau to use and they will override the decline and manually review to see what they can do. I'll be doing that in the morning and ask them which version of each they pull to choose the best one. 680 on EQ Auto 5 looks to be the lowest but even with that, I don't think that they should have declined me.

 

Stay tuned. I should be able to get some data points out of this.

Starting Score (May 2017): 584 TU
Current Scores: 699 TU, 770 EQ, 775 EX

Goal Score: 820+




Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES 4
Highlighted
Regular Contributor

Re: NFCU refi decline. But wait...

How did it go?

Message 2 of 5
Highlighted
Frequent Contributor

Re: NFCU refi decline. But wait...

So I called in and the girl said that it should've been approved but it was declined because it made my payments go up, which I was aware of. So, we resubmitted the app for recon and she made notations that I'm aware that the payments go up. After all, I'm going from a 72 month to a 36 month and looking for lower interest rate.

 

The loan came back as a conditional approval at 6.59% (currently at 9.84%). The condition is that I respond saying that I'm aware that the payments would be higher than what I'm currently paying (about $100 per month higher).

 

With all the hesitancy and them stressing that it's going up, I decided to pull back and think this through. I didn't get the lowest rate (which the girl told me I prequalified for) which is 5.49 or 4.59. I can't remember offhand. Also, this would restart a new loan on my credit. So, yeah, I'm not taking that. I think I'm just going to pay the principle way down and then continue paying additional towards the principle with each payment. I could probably pay it off within a year but I'll have to see about that too. I'll need another installment loan to keep my scores up. Meantime, I'm still checking into my best options.  

 

If anyone has any advice, my ears are wide open. I still have a few days to change my mind and accept before they officially send me another decline to close out the application.

Starting Score (May 2017): 584 TU
Current Scores: 699 TU, 770 EQ, 775 EX

Goal Score: 820+




Message 3 of 5
Established Contributor

Re: NFCU refi decline. But wait...

Why not try the capital one? It’s a soft pull so can’t hurt to check. If you actually apply it will be a triple hard pull though. You might be pleasantly surprised.
Current Cards (in order they were approved with current limits):
Cap1 QS (plat.) $2750
Kohls $3K
Cap1 Savor $15K
PenFed Power Cash Rewards $2K
NFCU CashRewards $6K
NFCU MoreRewards $12.5K
Cap1 Venture $30K
PenFed Gold $2K
Ollo Rewards $3.2K
Sync Amazon $10K
NASA FCU Platinum Cash Rewards $3K
Disco It #2 $14.8K
DCU Visa $10K
NFCU Flagship Rewards $23K
Sync Care Credit $15K
PenFed Power Cash Rewards #2 $39K
WF Propel $4K
Comenity AKC $10.5K
Apple (GS) $6.5K
TD Cash Credit Card $6K
Rakuten Siggy Visa $6.5K
BBVA ClearPoints Visa $10K
Disco It #3 $8K

BK 7 discharged July 2016




Message 4 of 5
Highlighted
Frequent Contributor

Re: NFCU refi decline. But wait...

Good idea. Can’t hurt.
Starting Score (May 2017): 584 TU
Current Scores: 699 TU, 770 EQ, 775 EX

Goal Score: 820+




Message 5 of 5
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.