Update!
Payment had processed so it was showing my credit limit available to $1700 again. I decided I would now ask for the CLI and got the dreaded under review but should hear back in 24 hours.
I figured I would app for the 2nd card now as well. I got an immediate you don't meet lending criteria on that one so it has me wondering if maybe they might have me as still too new.
I messaged them because I was unable to call but they just told me to wait for the letter in 7 to 10 days. Last time this occurred they just straight up told me I was too new and I would have to show at least 3 months of good payment history.
I got a feeling I might have to app for the 2nd card later but maybe with the manual review on the CLI they will see my history and that's it's indeed 3 statements/90 days and hook me up!
I also noticed no hard pulls after doing either of these apps either by the way, which makes me think it auto-generated too new status on me.