cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Spree vs Snail

tag
Creditaddict
Legendary Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail


@jesseh wrote:

I'm gonna miss out on all sign up bonusses... I don't expect to get the CSP or ihg bonus.

So the sign up bonusses are no reason to apply for me at all. (although the first spend bonus on the ihg is nice)

 

Which cards should I go for?

 

Preapprovals:
Barclay: Rewards (you may also be interested in Ring, Arrival Plus)

Amex: BCE, ED, Green, Gold

Cap1: QSone, Platinum

Citi: DC, AA plat select, TY Pref. (you may also be interested in TY Premier, Hhonors)

or something else?

 

 


Amex BCE or ED

Citi DC

 

Wait until you get offer for Venture/QS to apply for Cap1

Message 51 of 66
OmarGB9
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail


@jesseh wrote:

I'm gonna miss out on all sign up bonusses... I don't expect to get the CSP or ihg bonus.

So the sign up bonusses are no reason to apply for me at all. (although the first spend bonus on the ihg is nice)

 

Which cards should I go for?

 

Preapprovals:
Barclay: Rewards (you may also be interested in Ring, Arrival Plus)

Amex: BCE, ED, Green, Gold

Cap1: QSone, Platinum

Citi: DC, AA plat select, TY Pref. (you may also be interested in TY Premier, Hhonors)

or something else?


Are you sure those are true pre approvals? Barclays pre approval site isn't very reliable. Amex's is, but only if it says "Congratulations. You are prequalified for the following offers" or something to that effect; if it says anything about "we recommend," then it's not a true prequal. Cap1 I'd hold off until you qualify for QS (with no AF) and/or Venture.


Last App: 1/10/2023
Penfed Gold Visa Card

Currently rebuilding as of 04/11/2019.

Starting FICO 8 Scores:




Current FICO 8 scores:


Message 52 of 66
jesseh
Frequent Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail

I do, however csp required 4k in 3mo, I wont reach that
Ihg not sure

Yes, the amex are real approvals.
Cards: BCE 24k 5/'17 | CF 12k 10/'15 | IHG 12k 10/'15 | HH 6k 6/'18 | DS It 6k 3/'15 | TR 5k 11/'15
Scores: 760-770 | Inquiries: 0-1 | Utilization: 0-10% | AAoA: 3yrs | Bank: Ally | CU's: Navy & Pentagon
Message 53 of 66
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Spree vs Snail


@jesseh wrote:
I do, however csp required 4k in 3mo, I wont reach that
Ihg not sure

Yes, the amex are real approvals.

OP, why you stopping?!

Message 54 of 66
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Spree vs Snail

Credit Addict gives sound advice. Hit the Am Ex now and just decide between the BCE and ED. In your situation if you don't travel, do the BCE.

 

Barclay's,  go for the first approval, the rewards card. My DW got an Arrival  through the prequal site,  It was the first choice.

 

Citibank,  the DC has no interest for a year. Do that one. It is ALWAYS good to have a 0 interest card in your portfolio for emergencies. 

 

Skip Capital One. 

 

Now figure EVERYTHING you can pay for ( bills) with your CSP to make minimum spend. If you are in a relationship combine all the bills to that card and use both of your cash to pay them back immediately. 

Message 55 of 66
jesseh
Frequent Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail

Where should i stop in terms of inqs? Barclays will be my fourth TU inq
Cards: BCE 24k 5/'17 | CF 12k 10/'15 | IHG 12k 10/'15 | HH 6k 6/'18 | DS It 6k 3/'15 | TR 5k 11/'15
Scores: 760-770 | Inquiries: 0-1 | Utilization: 0-10% | AAoA: 3yrs | Bank: Ally | CU's: Navy & Pentagon
Message 56 of 66
NRB525
Super Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail


@jesseh wrote:
Where should i stop in terms of inqs? Barclays will be my fourth TU inq

That is a question each person has to consider for themselves, there is no answer book for number of INQ.

On the bright side, any INQ you get now will be no longer affecting your score in 12 months, so INQ are all temporary.

 

With the CSP, do you pay rent? Even if there's a small fee, using rent to contribute to bonus spend is a good idea. What is your overall spend rate per month? The 40,000 UR points that it is possible to earn with this card (plus the $4k spend to get it = 44,000 points at least) can be transferred to United Airlines where a typical round-trip domestic flight goes for about 25,000 miles. Hyatt hotels is also a transfer partner, and the points per night tend to be reasonable, so you can get a couple nights at a nice Hyatt.

 

Regarding the Barclay Rewards card, it give 2% cash back, however you already have the CSP in your wallet, and the transfer value of those points is often close to 2c per point. Dining out, including fast food, is 2x points on the CSP, but even basic spend could be similar return to the Barclay Rewards card.

 

This is the point where you decide if you are going Snail or Spree. You have some large credit lines now, due to your good credit history. The CSP has the possibility to earn good points, and transfer those to useful partners, and if you can make the spend, you get a clear payback in terms of being able to make a trip for nearly free. The likelihood that you will come back around to get a CSP bonus is probably near zero, yet you have the opportunity to concentrate spend to get that bonus now.

 

Edit to add: Your initial goal was to get high credit limits. You accomplished that with your first two cards. At your spend level, any additional cards will not make any noticeable difference in your Utilization percentage, and thus will not noticeably increase your FICO score. Taking more INQ, that has the definite possibility to lower your FICO score temporarily. At this point, the only thing that is going to really improve your FICO score is time; more months of solid payment history. You have enough cards and enough CL to accomplish this. Could you get more cards? Yes, definitely. Are they going to really give you more benefits? Doubtful, unless you can cover the bonus spend requirements. In FICO score benefits? Additional cards not helpful.

High Bal Jan 2009 $116k on $146k limits 80% Util.
Oct 2014 $46k on $127k 36% util EQ 722 TU 727 EX 727
April 2018 $18k on $344k 5% util EQ 806 TU 810 EX 812
Jan 2019 $7.6k on $360k EQ 832 TU 839 EX 831
March 2021 $33k on $312k EQ 796 TU 798 EX 801
May 2021 Paid all Installments and Mortgages, one new Mortgage EQ 761 TY 774 EX 777
April 2022 EQ=811 TU=807 EX=805 - TU VS 3.0 765
Message 57 of 66
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Spree vs Snail


@jesseh wrote:
Where should i stop in terms of inqs? Barclays will be my fourth TU inq

Stop after Barclay's with TU. 

Message 58 of 66
jesseh
Frequent Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail

Called Chase Lending dept about the Freedom app, they say Chase has a "No more than 2 cards per 30 days" policy.

Edit: 'officially' reconned, but they simply can't add an additional product. I explained I was fine with relocating credit from a card I've been approved for and explained why I think the freedom card would be useful, but no go. The first-line lending dept is actually not the 'real' recon folks, the lending dept said I was declined, after asking to recon I was told I would be transferred.

note: the recon guy could see I called lending dept earlier, he didn't consider that a good thing. So, lesson learnt: if you call Lending svs, if you're told you're declined, ask to recon right away, rather than calling back again later and seeming more desperate.

Cards: BCE 24k 5/'17 | CF 12k 10/'15 | IHG 12k 10/'15 | HH 6k 6/'18 | DS It 6k 3/'15 | TR 5k 11/'15
Scores: 760-770 | Inquiries: 0-1 | Utilization: 0-10% | AAoA: 3yrs | Bank: Ally | CU's: Navy & Pentagon
Message 59 of 66
jesseh
Frequent Contributor

Re: Spree vs Snail

I figured, with an IHG (world mc) and a CSP (visa sig) card and a Discover, let's try to find cards that would be useful in my wallet, but most other cards are not more interesting in terms of rewards and benefits (besides a spending bonus). I'm looking for cards I don't see a reason to ever want to close, to build longest account age and aaoa. (which will take a hit at some time when I close the secured cards). 

Cards: BCE 24k 5/'17 | CF 12k 10/'15 | IHG 12k 10/'15 | HH 6k 6/'18 | DS It 6k 3/'15 | TR 5k 11/'15
Scores: 760-770 | Inquiries: 0-1 | Utilization: 0-10% | AAoA: 3yrs | Bank: Ally | CU's: Navy & Pentagon
Message 60 of 66
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.