Op for a comparison.. my 19yr old had 0 credit, score was 730 with absolutely no profile whatsoever yet. Capital One approved him w/ 19k income while in school for a 1k SL on the Capital One Journey card. They had no issue giving him an unsecured card w/ a thin/nonexistent profile. With your scores around the same however already with some history.. I'd think you have a better opportunity already with Capital One. As previously mentioned, the kicker to that is they triple pull you for sport so be prepared for that.
Welcome, @Anonymous. 
Do you have any loans on your report?
I always like seeing it when a member's first card is a Chase card with a decent limit. That doesn't happen often.
It'd be useful to get your FICO scores at some point. But you have a report with one credit card with a year of history. It's pretty easy to predict that you should have a lot of cards to choose from. The only ones I'd avoid right now are the ones with high starting limits that you might not get approved for at this point in your history. The Venture would be among them.
Before you apply, make sure that your Chase card utilization is down. It should be below 28.9% of its limit. Some will tell you that 8.9% is better (which it is, scoring-wise), but I don't think that'll matter much in your case.
When you're about ready to apply, make sure your statement balance is in check for reporting purposes. If you don't want to wait, you can bring your utilization down within the span of about a week — probably less.
On a Monday, make a payment to bring your card down to your desired balance. Once it posts (probably the next day), ask Chase to report to the bureaus. Then watch your monitoring services so you know your new balance has hit your reports. This will likely happen by Friday or Saturday.
DO NOT bring your balance to zero during this time. There'll be a FICO penalty for all cards with balances of zero, and Chase will report zero whenever you pay to zero. That doesn't mean you have to pay interest. Feel free to pay your statement balance in full AFTER a new charge has posted. If you goof up and end up at zero, ask Chase to report once you have a small positive balance.
For future reference, Chase is among the few banks that'll report your balance upon request. Discover is another. Capital One certainly won't.
As far as Capital One cards go, I'd suggest the Quicksilver or SavorOne. The only way I see the VentureOne beating either of those cards is if you make extensive use of the hotels.com reward. Otherwise, the other two cards have higher rewards value. And rewards redemptions aren't limited to travel.