Well definitely call up and ask. Maybe others can chime in about which CCCs will open up old accounts. Your other good option may be to reapply with some of the cards that will open a new account BUT give you the old date.
It can't hurt to ask. You might get lucky and find a lender that will do it, but I haven't had any luck with Citi, Discover, or Radio Shack. I'm not even asking BoA. since that one was a CO back in the MBNA days.
If you get any positive response, be sure and let us know.
Scores on4/8/10: TU 731 EQ 731 Unapologetic Amex fan