Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Kill Crap 1??

Valued Contributor

Re: Kill Crap 1??

LynetteM wrote:

niquieg wrote:

Your opinions are need, thank you. Should I get rid of capital one or what other options do i have?

My annual fee of $39.95 for capital one is due on the 27th. I've had this card from 2005 and it's with a $500 limit.


I also have a Orchard Bank opened 2005 $1600.00 util 0

First Premier 2005 $475 util 0

Bank of America 2007 $2000 util 1500 are obviously able to work yourself away from the builder cards. I would close Cap One so as not to have to pay the annual fee. Then, before your annual fee comes up on First Premier, I would app for another bank card. Then I would also close the First Premier.


If you do that, you will have Orchard, BofA, and one other card. You may want to look at a credit union card.


There is a place for the annual-fee-low-limit card, but you are no longer in that place. I'm not in favor of paying an annual fee just to keep history going. The history on your Cap One card will still report, even though closed, for up to the next 10 years.

Its a good idea. But I'd still recommend closing out the FP. Its a PIA in every which way. You have to pay to pay them. And importantly,FP have a monthly fee a well and hence itd all likely turn out to be moe than the Cap One AF by the time OP decides to close out FP and app for a Bank card which he may or may not get. 

Message 21 of 24
Regular Contributor

Re: Kill Crap 1??

txjohn is correct on both levels of this thread.


The advice to the OP regarding the next steps is solid.


The comments about the "spirit" of the post are also right on.  I fully trust the moderators to step in when actually necessary.  When Contributors have stepped in, in the past, to address an issue, it has regularly been done in a very low-key and supportive way--not in a corrective or preachy manner.  txjohn and others like him have navigated this very well in the past--and currently.  They fully understand that sometimes direct replies to a certain issue can cause more disharmony than the original error in judgment (or experience) of theOP--when observed from a more panoramic view.  They guide the conversation quickly to a constructive and helpful manner, addressing the actual reason for the post, and then move on.


While I have seen many OPs respond positively to the gentle guidance from moderators and thoughtful others, I have seen more than this forum's fair share of excessively long threads featuring back and forth "lively disputes" from supposedly well-meaning individuals.  I appreaciate the comments and intentions of the txjohns and haulings and choose to let their expertise and spirit guide the shaping and development of this great and contstructive forum.

Starting Score: TU 766 EQ 788
Current Score: TU 788 EQ 811
Goal Score: TU 800 EQ 800

Take the FICO Fitness Challenge
Message 22 of 24
Senior Contributor

Re: Kill Crap 1??

DI wrote:

niquieg wrote:
JoJo i've kept it that long because i'm young and it was my second card, so i've used it to practice good credit habits, and maintaining good practices. Before I got BoA my card between 3 cards I only had $1375 in available credit

niqueig-  I am happy for your success.  Please do not think I am bashing you.    The thing that bothers me is Capital One has given credit to those who wouldn't otherwise qualify for cards due to adverse credit problems.  And once the card served it's purpose and the cardholder credit has improved, they are still stuck with the same terms of the card.


Being stuck with the same limit and terms of the account doesn't make the creditor bad.  It just a sign to graduate oneself from the card and put it to rest.  If it involves fees one is not wanting to pay, there's no need to keep the card open.  




That's very true.  The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.  And a recession is where your neighbor loses his job, depression where you lose yours! 


I believe your definition of a "sub-prime" card was stated as any card that charges an AF, which no AF card is "welcome in your wallet."


The OP believes it may be time to "unwelcome" the AF card from his/her wallet, now seeing that subprime cards are no longer in their best interest.


This is the beauty of the system....a card for all types.  And as circumstances change, so do preferences and expectations.


PRIME EXAMPLE:  I had only $17k in CL's at the beginning of 2009.  One year later I have over $200k.  In beginning of 2009, my highest CL was BoA at $10k and that was a great CL.  But now, I don't like less than $20k.  In 2009 my best APR was 13.99%.  Now it is 5.24%.


Therefore, in 2009 what I found acceptable, even GREAT, is now not worthy...LOL.  I want high CL's, low APR, no AF (except in certain special cases I choose).  I am now pairing down my accounts to those with $10k or higher and getting rid of or combining those with less, except maybe Discover.


Perspective is personal and worth is subjective.  What once was acceptable may not be later.  And the free market provides for all tastes!


LOL  Smiley Wink



Credit Scoring 101 - Tuscani   *  Guide to Common Abbreviations
Frequently Requested Threads * FICO High Achievers  *  FICO Score Estimator

09/03/2009 TU: 777, EQ: 776 ($8 balance on an account dropped me out of 780's)
03/28/2009 TU: 814, EQ: 810, EX: 781 (02/12/2009)
05/18/2005 TU: 563, EQ: 580, EX: 549
Message 23 of 24
Frequent Contributor

Re: Kill Crap 1??

Actually, I see no need to bash anyone for a myriad of reasons but that is just me.


Once I had a friend tell me for two hours how miserable, low down, no class their ex was and that they were the dumbest person in the world and I told him I was not aware of all the things he had mentioned but when I look at who his 'ex" had married, I teneded to agree with his assessment of her mental capabilities.


I've always lived by the motto that the true measure of a persons character can be seen when we look at what they say about other people, instead of listening to what other people say about them, but that's just me.


Hope everyone reaches their financial goals in 2010.

Message 24 of 24