cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Should I close my secured cards?

tag
heavyjay
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


@joltdude wrote:

Let's see...

Close OpenSky 

Close First Premier.... (I consider FP the cheap corner street walker of subprime credit cards....)

Close Milestone (subprime)

Close First National (if theres any fee) (subprime card)

Close Merrick (if there is a fee)  (Consider Merrick a *better* rebuilder than others but still in the subprime zone, hence why its further down the list)

 

Check for prequalify once your baddie falls off... or dont wait...

How long have you had your Personal COne card? (not AU) (f im reading it right, your AU on 2 1500$ CL cards and have your own 3000$ CL card, if not.. id check for a preapproval) 

 

Could see if theres an offer in your account... or check prequal for another card...

 

Reason i didnt say close SDFCU is albeit for a secured card, it has your deposit. it has a relatively low APR if you ever NEED it ...

I dont see any cards comparable yet in your lineup for that level of low APR...

 

Just rip off the bandaid now... and when your final baddie comes off youll be in a place to work on cards you have that are better or apply for prime cards...

 

 And hope you plan on pruning the store cards as well..

 

 

 


OpenSky - closed

First Premier- closed

Milestone- closed

First National - closed

 

Should I kick Eddie Bauer and his low limit to the curb?

 


FICO 08:Jan 18, 2017: EX 800 EQ 725 TU 799
FICO 08:Feb 10, 2017: EX 788 EQ 772 TU 791 (post New Year's app spree)
In the garden as of 1/4/2017. Will remain for all of 2017.
Message 11 of 21
joltdude
Senior Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?

Do you use the Eddie Bauer at all? 

Its a Comenty card (if i read correctly) Might be able to get CLI's if its used at all...

Id hold onto the EB for now.... 

 

If not... perhaps SD it and revisit it after you get some other cards....

 

Keeping the Merrick card for now is not a bad thing since your still in rebuilder mode... 

 

 

 

 

 

Message 12 of 21
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Should I close my secured cards?

I recently closed FP and it was a nightmare! I hope your experience was better than mine. I had a balance on it and when it reported closed my score went up a little, which was nice. Once your cards report closed to the CAs, can you let us know if your AAOA and scores were affected in any way? I'm considering doing the same with my Cap1 secured and a few Comenity cards I got via the SCT. Good luck and thanks! 

 

Message 13 of 21
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Should I close my secured cards?

I agree, if you don't need the cash in SDFCU account, leave it open. The interest rate is hard to beat if you need to carry a balance, and I think the account earns interest but I'm not sure.

Message 14 of 21
grillandwinemaster
Valued Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


@heavyjay wrote:

@joltdude wrote:

Let's see...

Close OpenSky 

Close First Premier.... (I consider FP the cheap corner street walker of subprime credit cards....)

Close Milestone (subprime)

Close First National (if theres any fee) (subprime card)

Close Merrick (if there is a fee)  (Consider Merrick a *better* rebuilder than others but still in the subprime zone, hence why its further down the list)

 

Check for prequalify once your baddie falls off... or dont wait...

How long have you had your Personal COne card? (not AU) (f im reading it right, your AU on 2 1500$ CL cards and have your own 3000$ CL card, if not.. id check for a preapproval) 

 

Could see if theres an offer in your account... or check prequal for another card...

 

Reason i didnt say close SDFCU is albeit for a secured card, it has your deposit. it has a relatively low APR if you ever NEED it ...

I dont see any cards comparable yet in your lineup for that level of low APR...

 

Just rip off the bandaid now... and when your final baddie comes off youll be in a place to work on cards you have that are better or apply for prime cards...

 

 And hope you plan on pruning the store cards as well..

 

 

 


OpenSky - closed

First Premier- closed

Milestone- closed

First National - closed

 

Should I kick Eddie Bauer and his low limit to the curb?

 


Yes, kick Eddie Bauer's a$$ to the curb! You don't need him. You have moved on. 


Current Scores 3/2016 Equifax 676 Transunion 697 Experian 648 Goal Scores: 720's accross the board. Gardening Goal: 3/2017
Message 15 of 21
heavyjay
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?

I use the Eddie Bauer occasionally just to get it to report. I tried for a CLI a couple weeks ago and was denied. The letter said it was based on my credit score from Aug 12. I looked on my reports, they never did an AR in August. There was one on EQ from Nov 18 so I have no clue where they got August from. I'll SD it and try again in 3 or 4 months. 


FICO 08:Jan 18, 2017: EX 800 EQ 725 TU 799
FICO 08:Feb 10, 2017: EX 788 EQ 772 TU 791 (post New Year's app spree)
In the garden as of 1/4/2017. Will remain for all of 2017.
Message 16 of 21
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


@heavyjay wrote:

I opened 2 secured cards in March 2015 to help with my rebuilding.

 

OpenSky 750 CL

SDFCU  1250 CL

 

Fico 08 scores are now between 684-706.

I have one derog left, reporting on EQ only and due to come off in March.

 

I'm an AU on 2 Cap1 cards with $1500 CL's that always report a zero balance and were opened in 2004.

I have an Eddie Bauer card that always reports zero that I opened in 2005.

 

My current bank cards are:

Cap1 QS1 - $3000 CL

1st Premier - $1000 CL

Merrick - $1500 CL

1st National CC - $600 CL

Milestone - $300 CL

 

Store cards:

Walmart - $2000 CL

Amazon - $2300 CL

Lowes - $2000 CL

Firestone - $1000 CL

Eddie Bauer - $850 CL

 

AU cards: these cards get very limited use and always PIF before statement cuts

Cap1 - $1500 CL

Cap1 - $1500 CL

Sync BP - $2000 CL

Sync Steinmart - $3500 CL

 

Closing the secureds won't hurt my AAoA or utilization and I can think of better ways to use that $2000 other than letting it sit there earning no interest.

 

What do y'all think?

 

PS: I was thinking about closing the 2 turds also.


My 2 cents would be:

 

1. Close Open Sky, Merrick, Milestone, 1st Premier

 

2. Try to convert SDFCU to unsecured


Total revolving limits 741200 (620700 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 703 TU 704 EX 687

Message 17 of 21
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


@heavyjay wrote:

@joltdude wrote:

Let's see...

Close OpenSky 

Close First Premier.... (I consider FP the cheap corner street walker of subprime credit cards....)

Close Milestone (subprime)

Close First National (if theres any fee) (subprime card)

Close Merrick (if there is a fee)  (Consider Merrick a *better* rebuilder than others but still in the subprime zone, hence why its further down the list)

 

Check for prequalify once your baddie falls off... or dont wait...

How long have you had your Personal COne card? (not AU) (f im reading it right, your AU on 2 1500$ CL cards and have your own 3000$ CL card, if not.. id check for a preapproval) 

 

Could see if theres an offer in your account... or check prequal for another card...

 

Reason i didnt say close SDFCU is albeit for a secured card, it has your deposit. it has a relatively low APR if you ever NEED it ...

I dont see any cards comparable yet in your lineup for that level of low APR...

 

Just rip off the bandaid now... and when your final baddie comes off youll be in a place to work on cards you have that are better or apply for prime cards...

 

 And hope you plan on pruning the store cards as well..

 

 

 


OpenSky - closed

First Premier- closed

Milestone- closed

First National - closed

 

Excellent

 

Should I kick Eddie Bauer and his low limit to the curb?

 

Because is it's so old, I'd keep it around awhile

 


 


Total revolving limits 741200 (620700 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 703 TU 704 EX 687

Message 18 of 21
heavyjay
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


@Anonymous wrote:

I agree, if you don't need the cash in SDFCU account, leave it open. The interest rate is hard to beat if you need to carry a balance, and I think the account earns interest but I'm not sure.


$3.14 since March 2015. Not much, but better than the free loan I gave Open Sky.


FICO 08:Jan 18, 2017: EX 800 EQ 725 TU 799
FICO 08:Feb 10, 2017: EX 788 EQ 772 TU 791 (post New Year's app spree)
In the garden as of 1/4/2017. Will remain for all of 2017.
Message 19 of 21
heavyjay
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I close my secured cards?


My 2 cents would be:

 

1. Close Open Sky, Merrick, Milestone, 1st Premier

 

2. Try to convert SDFCU to unsecured


SDFCU doesn't graduate but as soon as my 1% util reports I'll qualify for the unsecured.


FICO 08:Jan 18, 2017: EX 800 EQ 725 TU 799
FICO 08:Feb 10, 2017: EX 788 EQ 772 TU 791 (post New Year's app spree)
In the garden as of 1/4/2017. Will remain for all of 2017.
Message 20 of 21
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.