cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

Valued Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa


SinjCeridan wrote:
Not sure of the criteria used by Comenity but they do make exceptions to the V/MC rule. I've had the Wayfair and Boscov's cards for a while and recently added the SpGd Visa. Just paid first statement on the Visa and ordered from Boscov's Monday night with no problems.

Sorry about the bad luck.

I’ve made 3 statements before shutdown.

I have a ton of inquiries and new accounts. 

OP states only a couple in the last few months. THAT is what I find odd. OP should’ve been fine

Chase 62k-Bank of America17k-FNBO 44.1k-Banco de Popular 25k-Discover 14.2k-Synchrony 84k-Banco do Brazil 5k-Amex Plat-Capital One 53.1k-NFCU 88k-John Deere 17.5k-EECU 10k-Commerce 17k-Blispay 7.5k-USAA 10k-Citi 20k-Fleetcor 7k-Sunbelt-RentalOne-Locke Supply-Limits 506950
Message 21 of 29
Highlighted
Community Leader
Senior Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa


woodyman100 wrote:

SinjCeridan wrote:
Not sure of the criteria used by Comenity but they do make exceptions to the V/MC rule. I've had the Wayfair and Boscov's cards for a while and recently added the SpGd Visa. Just paid first statement on the Visa and ordered from Boscov's Monday night with no problems.

Sorry about the bad luck.

I’ve made 3 statements before shutdown.

I have a ton of inquiries and new accounts. 

OP states only a couple in the last few months. THAT is what I find odd. OP should’ve been fine


Without knowing what Comenity's AA review caused the shutdown for the OP, it's hard to say.  They typically SP both EQ and EX (and third party providers) shortly after a new account is approved.

 

Regardless, it's still a very messed up process at the end of the day.  I can see it from an UW or risk perspective if they're performing a secondary review because most initial inquiries may or may not yield approvals plus let's face it there's folks who like to game the system, but for those who go bonkers on application sprees and yield several new accounts on their CRs after 1-2 months, then that logic can apply.  Yet, on the opposite spectrum, for individuals who are not credit seekers with a fairly mature profile, low inquiries spread throughout 12-24 months, and get shutdown is definitely a head-scratcher.

Message 22 of 29
Established Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

This is why I don't mess with Comenity or Synchrony. They suck

Message 23 of 29
Community Leader
Senior Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa


ImaPirate wrote:

This is why I don't mess with Comenity or Synchrony. They suck


To you, sure.  For others, not so much.  One man's trash another man's treasure I suppose.  I've had 0 issues with either of them in the last 15-20 or so years I've had their accounts. 

Message 24 of 29
Established Member

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

They helped me get my first Amex last Oct and now one in January. Comenity jumped my score alot.
Starting: EX 476,EQ 501,TU 488 (03/10/17)
Current: EX 729,EQ 727,TU 732(05/25/18)
Goal FICOs: EX 750, EQ 750, TU 750
Message 25 of 29
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

Lol, until im Synchrony free i need to remain n Sync with H.RonySmiley Wink



Gardening since 6/13/18
Goal: No hps or cli requests at least til 1/1/19, 7/13/20 preferable
Message 26 of 29
Valued Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

DW and I both have a PayPal cr dit Account,

Comenity hasn’t touched those

Chase 62k-Bank of America17k-FNBO 44.1k-Banco de Popular 25k-Discover 14.2k-Synchrony 84k-Banco do Brazil 5k-Amex Plat-Capital One 53.1k-NFCU 88k-John Deere 17.5k-EECU 10k-Commerce 17k-Blispay 7.5k-USAA 10k-Citi 20k-Fleetcor 7k-Sunbelt-RentalOne-Locke Supply-Limits 506950
Message 27 of 29
Regular Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

My only bad experience, or more accurately, WEIRD experience was with my Wal-Mart card a few years ago - when I was just beginning my effort to rebuild after a nasty divorce. I was so excited to see myself approved online for $1500, at the time my highest yet unsecured credit limit. A month later I got a letter from them informing me they were reducing my CL to $850 and the reason they gave (including the exclamation point even!) was:

"Your credit limit has fallen to 614!"

First reax was to cry, 2nd one was to LMAO, if for no other reason than that stoopid exclamation mark(!). It was like, "You fooled us and let us down within just a few short weeks, you poophead!". Still LMFAO at that one.
Message 28 of 29
Valued Contributor

Re: Shut down by comenity for adding ONE visa

Synchrony R.I.P

Message 29 of 29