It seems they purchased both our accounts in 2005, and just lied. I knew they were shady but the more I learn the more my tummy aches. And to think Experian "verified" this, sure they did. You know after reading all that you've found I'm just going to start legal proceedings, it may be a waste or time consuming but how shadier can you get!
Oh and as far as what I told the FTC and Florida's AG. I basically put in that their corp wasn't active (it's an LLC), that they aren't licensed to collect (got that info from one of the links you provided via PM), and that they are a JDB who is falsifying records to keep old items on my CR. I also told them that I have proof of all of this if they need copies of my loan documents, etc. Also of the settlement, but the major points were they were inactive and not licensed in their state. I haven't checked if they're licensed in NY yet to collect. The thing is this company has NEVER sent me any correspondence, they just have it on my CR. I have never received a letter, not even when I called them, and they have yet to respond to my 1st DV. I just don't trust this company who is to say they won't lie on any so called proof. These type of shady people are savvy, thus why I think filing suit, and informing the FTC and FL and your state AG involved is the best route.
I need to find where I find it he's licensed in NY. I guess just call the licensing department for NY?