is it one of only 2 cards that you have? if so, and you close this account, you decrease your available credit by almost 30%. If you have a 200 dollar balance on your 1200 card, you are using 16% of your overall available credit. Not bad but, if you have a 200 balance with 1700 in available credit, you are using 11% of your available credit which is viewed more favorably by the FICO Gods. Between 1-9%. If you really must close it, you are doing right by closing the newest one, but I personally would sock drawer it unless there is an annual fee.
Sept 07 EQ 419
April 2012 EQ- 669 EXP- 680 TU-700= Proud New Homeowner!