I'm very new to the forums as well, so take my advice very lightly... but if I were in your situation, I would look at the CR to see if SOL has passed, or is soon approaching.. if it has a awhile to go, IMO why settle? It does nothing to improve your credit when paid. You may do a DV to see about verifying it- but you said your husband knows of this debt. You may also do a PFD for a different settlement amount- which they may be open too... but then again that depends on the SOL. So IMO it just comes down to the SOL on what you should do next...but it seems you pretty much knew that already