cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

Established Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

Randolf Brooks Federal Credit Union:
It's a little different in that you don't have to come up with the money up front. You pay the monthly amount and at the end of the loan you get the money back. There is no hard pull. You can pay however much after you open the loan and it extends the due date. Cost to join credit union is $1. Minimum loan amount is $500. Open to most everyone if you agree to emails from the American consumer council but the membership is Texas based. I work there and it is great in that you don't have to come up with the amount to begin with and in that it helps you to save.
Message 51 of 153
Valued Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

So it's a credit builder loan, not a share secured loan, right? Like you don't get access to the $500 until the loan is fully paid and closed? I tried to at least join the CU but they don't take furriners without green cards. Sucks to be a 28th year legal resident without one.
Korea:
Samsung Card SSG7 Limit: $15,000 + Instant Loan Limit: $20,000
Hyundai Card M.2 Kia Q Limit: $10,000 + Instant Loan Limit: $10,000 [closed]
Credit Rank: Was 2, dropped to 5 (scale of 1-10) simply for taking out a loan from a savings bank at 8% instead of a "tier 1 bank" at 12%
-----
US:
Discover it Secured Limit: $200
-----
Needing two different countries' financial systems is like needing two severely flawed women.
Korean credit system is dumber than FICO. US fund transfer speeds really need to catch up to Korea's 2 seconds. Seriously.
Message 52 of 153
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant


@mitsuhashi wrote:
So it's a credit builder loan, not a share secured loan, right? Like you don't get access to the $500 until the loan is fully paid and closed? I tried to at least join the CU but they don't take furriners without green cards. Sucks to be a 28th year legal resident without one.

Have you tried Ideal yet? 

 

People are experiencing some difficulty joining due to georgraphic restrictions, but please look at post #49 where I urge people to give Ideal a call and try joining with the assistance of a customer service rep.  There should be no problem.

 

It would be VERY nice to have a genuine alternative to Navy (which many people cannot join) and the Alliant unsecured loan (which has its own downsides).  We need people to test out Ideal.

Message 53 of 153
Valued Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

 

Nope, but I have membership applications pending with 3 credit unions, 1 of which I've angrily reapplied to because they asked stupid questions I couldn't answer when I took their call at 1AM.

 

Korea:
Samsung Card SSG7 Limit: $15,000 + Instant Loan Limit: $20,000
Hyundai Card M.2 Kia Q Limit: $10,000 + Instant Loan Limit: $10,000 [closed]
Credit Rank: Was 2, dropped to 5 (scale of 1-10) simply for taking out a loan from a savings bank at 8% instead of a "tier 1 bank" at 12%
-----
US:
Discover it Secured Limit: $200
-----
Needing two different countries' financial systems is like needing two severely flawed women.
Korean credit system is dumber than FICO. US fund transfer speeds really need to catch up to Korea's 2 seconds. Seriously.
Message 54 of 153
Established Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

I had an expense come up and won't be able to give Ideal a try until about 2 weeks.

 

That RBFCU loan looks like a Credit Builder loan, but they have both Credit Builder and SSL options. I wonder if their SSL works the way we're looking for too.

Bizz408's Credit Cleansing 2018
Starting Score: 568-570 12/2017
As of 6/2018: TU: FICO8: 686 (CK: 648) | EQ: EQ04: 653 (CK: 644) | EX: FICO8: 654 (Vantage 3.0: 629)
2018 Goal: 700

Current TLs: First Progress Secured $300 3/13 ; Macy's $600 7/13 ; Fingerhut $800 12/17 ; Kohl's $700 12/17 ; CapOne QS1 $750 12/17
CB Indigo $300 12/17 (Plan to close 11/18) ; Discover It $2400 3/18 ; Paypal 2% CB MC $300 3/18 ; Amazon Prime Store $600 3/18
Target $300 3/18 ; CapOne Platinum $300 3/18 ; AAoA: 16 months ; HPs: TU: 6 EQ: 3 EX: 13 (mainly CU/SSL INQs)
Message 55 of 153
Valued Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant


@CreditGuyInDixie wrote:

@mitsuhashi wrote:
So it's a credit builder loan, not a share secured loan, right? Like you don't get access to the $500 until the loan is fully paid and closed? I tried to at least join the CU but they don't take furriners without green cards. Sucks to be a 28th year legal resident without one.

Have you tried Ideal yet? 

 

People are experiencing some difficulty joining due to georgraphic restrictions, but please look at post #49 where I urge people to give Ideal a call and try joining with the assistance of a customer service rep.  There should be no problem.

 

It would be VERY nice to have a genuine alternative to Navy (which many people cannot join) and the Alliant unsecured loan (which has its own downsides).  We need people to test out Ideal.


Do you know if Ideal does a credit check to open an account or get SSL? 



Starting FICO: 590ish
FICOs: EX 681 TU 670 EQ 682 (Pre App Spree 1/11/18)
FICOs: EX 664 TU 670 EQ 693 (2/16/18)
FICOs: EX 667 TU 682 EQ 712 (5/8/18)
FICOs: EX 660 TU 766 EQ 777 (5/27/18 Charge off removed from TU and EQ)
Goal: 700's all across

Gardening since February 2018
Message 56 of 153
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant


@qmbear wrote:


Do you know if Ideal does a credit check to open an account or get SSL? 


Here is what post #2 in this thread says about Ideal.

 

Ideal Credit Union

Score: 85% chance this will work (no one has proven it yet by opening an SSL at this CU and seeing what happens, but the customer service reps have confirmed all the key features)

Advantages:
*  Offers a true SS loan

*  Early paydown while keeping it open

*  Soft pull only

*  Basically anyone can join (involves a one-time $5 donation to a non-profit).

Disadvantage

* A 60-month loan requires a huge initial loan size ($5000).  The much smaller $500 loan is possible but has a 12-month term.

Message 57 of 153
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

Thus there is a credit check with one of the three bureaus, but not a hard check.  There is likely a pull of the applicant's ChexSystems report or possibly EWS report.

Message 58 of 153
Valued Member

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant


@CreditGuyInDixie wrote:

Thus there is a credit check with one of the three bureaus, but not a hard check.  There is likely a pull of the applicant's ChexSystems report or possibly EWS report.


I'll give opening an account a try tomorrow. 



Starting FICO: 590ish
FICOs: EX 681 TU 670 EQ 682 (Pre App Spree 1/11/18)
FICOs: EX 664 TU 670 EQ 693 (2/16/18)
FICOs: EX 667 TU 682 EQ 712 (5/8/18)
FICOs: EX 660 TU 766 EQ 777 (5/27/18 Charge off removed from TU and EQ)
Goal: 700's all across

Gardening since February 2018
Message 59 of 153
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: The Quest for an SSL alternative to Alliant

Awesome!  Thanks bud. 

 

Try using the online process first and use the donation to the nonprofit as you method of establishing membership eligibility.  If you get hung up by the fact that their system doesn't like your zip code, that's a problem that others have experienced, a problem that the customer service rep should be able to help you with.  Do give the CSR a call if that happens (during normal banking hours).  The donation to the nonprofit is clearly supposed to be an approved method that doesn't depend on where you live.

 

Regardless take careful notes on your experience (step by step) and let us know how it goes.

Message 60 of 153