cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

tag
Catatonico
Valued Member

Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

So... I have recently consolidated several of my personal loans into 2 loans with lower interest rates (lowER.... not LOW) and freed up about $1k a month that I can apply to other debt.  My credit score is about 680... based on my income, credit score, and current debt load, I think I'm pretty much maxed out as far as taking on any other loans.  My credit report is clean (no baddies anywhere... just high utilization).

 

I don't have any specific goals right now, but I would like to simplify my finances and start dumping some of my rebuilder cards that I have.  I'd also like to keep the most money available on my credit cards (just in case), so I don't really want to start with the cards I'm planning on closing first (its a psychological thing).

 

Here is what I have left.  I want to do something with the credit cards now, which, I hope will increase my scores enough so that I can qualify to consolidate those loans.  I've notated the accounts that I plan on closing.  I've been making minimum payments (except on Discover) for so long that I know there's a possibility that I'll get balance chased... I'll probably just have to deal with it for now.  Do I start smallest balance to largest... higher interest to lower... do I close the accounts as soon as they are paid off, or sock drawer them as long as they don't have fees?  I just really need some help on focusing.

 

As I said earlier, I have $1k a month (I actually budget $260/week) that I can comfortably use to make extra payments.  Being able to see progress keeps me motivated.

 

Thank you!

 

CategoryCompany Balance  Minimum Payment RateMaturity Credit Limit Notes
LoanOneMain $ 2,271.62 $ 155.00  19.00%06/20/2020  Rewards Program 
LoanPioneer Credit $ 5,042.88 $ 140.0831.00%10/16/2021  New 
LoanAvant $ 12,100.00 $ 428.7629.95%10/26/2022  New 
Credit CardPayPal - MC $ 265.32 $ 25.0028.24%  $300.00 
Credit CardCredit One - MC $ 605.62 $ 25.0021.15%  $650.00Close
Credit CardDiscover Card $705.54   $ 30.00   23.24%  $800.00 
Credit CardCitibank $ 888.21  $ 25.0024.24%  $900.00 
Credit CardBest Buy Visa $ 940.87  $ 32.00  25.49%  $1,000.00 
Credit CardGeorgia's Own Visa $ 975.31  $ 25.0012.24%  $1,000.00 My Bank
Credit CardCredit One - Visa $ 1,241.47 $ 67.0025.15%  $1,300.00Close
Credit CardCapital One QS1 Visa $ 1,486.41 $ 46.0020.15%  $1,550.00 
Credit CardCapital One - MC $ 1,946.13 $ 63.0025.15%  $2,000.00Close - Merge w/ CapOne QS (was Orchard)
Store CardKohl's $ 641.62  $ 27.00 24.24%  $700.00 
Store CardDell Financial Services $ 855.12       $ 32.00 29.99%  $1,000.00Close
Store CardCare Credit $ 883.88   $ 33.0026.99%  $3,600.00 
Store CardTiresPlus $ 1,022.07 $ 39.0022.80%  $1,200.00 
Store CardTarget $ 1,250.22   $ 29.00   23.15%  $1,000.00Close
Store CardJCPenney $ 1,267.04   $ 31.0026.99%  $1,500.00 
Store CardWalmart $ 1,869.85 $ 56.0023.15%  $1,900.00Close
Store CardAmazon $ 1,871.55 $ 47.0026.24%  $2,000.00 
Store CardGameStop $ 2,274.03 $ 80.0027.24%  $2,350.00 
  Totals $ 40,404.76 $ 1,435.84   $24,750.00 
Keep on keeping on!
Message 1 of 11
10 REPLIES 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

Hi, C.

 

There's several ways to go about tackling a large CC debt payoff, mostly revolving around either hit highest int% first (most bang for buck) or hit smallest acct balances first (create payoff momentum). Both are viable. But you raised a good concern: you might get balance chased.

 

A thought I had looking at your profile: pretty much all the cards are maxed & thus candidates to be balance chased. Not knowing how long you've been at these balances, nor how long you've been paying minimum, I wondered if it might not be effective to: double pay the minimum on every card (from $712 to $1424 monthly) and then use the remaining $328 out of your extra $1040 to target a particular card (either snowball or highest int%)? Note: if you get paid weekly ("I have $260 per week") then know that every 3 months you'll have an extra week and thus, extra $260 -- make sure to use it to pay debt.

 

One other thought: Your overall CC util is roughly 21,000 owed on 24,750 = 85% so while paying down the balances some more credit "breathing room" might not be a bad thing. It'll help your scores and maybe increase the chances one of your creditors doesn't take AA. It sure can't hurt (might even make you feel better). I'm not suggesting go app, but rather consider paying down Discover and request a CLI. Not so long ago I was owing 18500 on 20750, including 7992 on 8000 to Discover. Once I got my balance with them below 5,000 I requested, and got, a 4000 CLI. Just a thought. 

 

Good luck.

 

Message 2 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

Additional thought: I don't necessarily consider my suggestion a "put it on pilot and stick to it" plan. It seems to me a reasonable and simple way to make some headway across the board. Once headway has been gained -- say all accounts are below 68.9% -- then a more surgical approach might make sense. 

 

I was taught that a worthwhile goal should be challenging and yet attainable. For me, part of attainable is simple. I sure can bog down on minutia given half the chance. But that might only be me. 

Message 3 of 11
Catatonico
Valued Member

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

Thanks, J.!

 

Funny that you should mention paying off Discover... I actually just decided to do that (I had some slush in my budget that I needed to get rid of before I spent it on crap).  Since I've been making $100 every month to them anyway (4x the minimum due... just kept running it up), I paid it off, put my Netflix, Hulu, and MS Office subscriptions on it, and SD'd it for now.  I'll try to for a CLI in a couple of months, once I make some more progress.  I love that card!

 

I think I may tackle the PayPal MC next, since its small... not sure what I'm going to do with it yet, though.  Then I'll probably tackle at least one of the Cap1's, so that I can combine those accounts.  That might take me a month or so, unless I get another bonus this year.  Its pretty haphazard and in no way does it focus on saving me money (I'm kind of ignoring interest rates right now), but it makes me feel good to kill them.

 

Any idea what I should do with that PayPal?  Its a toy limit and my newest card.  I haven't dug into the possible perks of having it yet and I have no idea how they handle CLI's.

Keep on keeping on!
Message 4 of 11
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans


@Catatonico wrote:

So... I have recently consolidated several of my personal loans into 2 loans with lower interest rates (lowER.... not LOW) and freed up about $1k a month that I can apply to other debt.  My credit score is about 680... based on my income, credit score, and current debt load, I think I'm pretty much maxed out as far as taking on any other loans.  My credit report is clean (no baddies anywhere... just high utilization).

 

I don't have any specific goals right now, but I would like to simplify my finances and start dumping some of my rebuilder cards that I have.  I'd also like to keep the most money available on my credit cards (just in case), so I don't really want to start with the cards I'm planning on closing first (its a psychological thing).

 

Here is what I have left.  I want to do something with the credit cards now, which, I hope will increase my scores enough so that I can qualify to consolidate those loans.  I've notated the accounts that I plan on closing.  I've been making minimum payments (except on Discover) for so long that I know there's a possibility that I'll get balance chased... I'll probably just have to deal with it for now.  Do I start smallest balance to largest... higher interest to lower... do I close the accounts as soon as they are paid off, or sock drawer them as long as they don't have fees?  I just really need some help on focusing.

 

As I said earlier, I have $1k a month (I actually budget $260/week) that I can comfortably use to make extra payments.  Being able to see progress keeps me motivated.

 

Thank you!

 

CategoryCompany Balance  Minimum Payment RateMaturity Credit Limit Notes
LoanOneMain $ 2,271.62 $ 155.00  19.00%06/20/2020  Rewards Program 
LoanPioneer Credit $ 5,042.88 $ 140.0831.00%10/16/2021  New 
LoanAvant $ 12,100.00 $ 428.7629.95%10/26/2022  New 
Credit CardPayPal - MC $ 265.32 $ 25.0028.24%  $300.00 
Credit CardCredit One - MC $ 605.62 $ 25.0021.15%  $650.00Close
Credit CardDiscover Card $705.54   $ 30.00   23.24%  $800.00 
Credit CardCitibank $ 888.21  $ 25.0024.24%  $900.00 
Credit CardBest Buy Visa $ 940.87  $ 32.00  25.49%  $1,000.00 
Credit CardGeorgia's Own Visa $ 975.31  $ 25.0012.24%  $1,000.00 My Bank
Credit CardCredit One - Visa $ 1,241.47 $ 67.0025.15%  $1,300.00Close
Credit CardCapital One QS1 Visa $ 1,486.41 $ 46.0020.15%  $1,550.00 
Credit CardCapital One - MC $ 1,946.13 $ 63.0025.15%  $2,000.00Close - Merge w/ CapOne QS (was Orchard)
Store CardKohl's $ 641.62  $ 27.00 24.24%  $700.00 
Store CardDell Financial Services $ 855.12       $ 32.00 29.99%  $1,000.00Close
Store CardCare Credit $ 883.88   $ 33.0026.99%  $3,600.00 
Store CardTiresPlus $ 1,022.07 $ 39.0022.80%  $1,200.00 
Store CardTarget $ 1,250.22   $ 29.00   23.15%  $1,000.00Close
Store CardJCPenney $ 1,267.04   $ 31.0026.99%  $1,500.00 
Store CardWalmart $ 1,869.85 $ 56.0023.15%  $1,900.00Close
Store CardAmazon $ 1,871.55 $ 47.0026.24%  $2,000.00 
Store CardGameStop $ 2,274.03 $ 80.0027.24%  $2,350.00 
  Totals $ 40,404.76 $ 1,435.84   $24,750.00 

I would leave the installment loans alone, just continue to make your payments.

 

With revolving accounts, I would recommend the snowball method:

1. Stop using cards.
2. Pay off smallest balance first, then next smallest, and so on.
3. On other cards pay minimum + something each month.
As each balance turns to zero, that will free up your remaining monthly cash to apply to the next smallest balance.

 

After you've paid off a subprime card with an annual fee, close the account.

 

As to the other accounts, leave them in place.

 


Total revolving limits 741200 (620700 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 703 TU 704 EX 691

Message 5 of 11
tacpoly
Established Contributor

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans


@SouthJamaica wrote:

 

I would leave the installment loans alone, just continue to make your payments.

 

With revolving accounts, I would recommend the snowball method:

1. Stop using cards.
2. Pay off smallest balance first, then next smallest, and so on.
3. On other cards pay minimum + something each month.
As each balance turns to zero, that will free up your remaining monthly cash to apply to the next smallest balance.

 

After you've paid off a subprime card with an annual fee, close the account.

 

As to the other accounts, leave them in place.


Agree with the above.  Do not use any card; spend as little money as you can.  Pay off as many cards as you can, as fast as you can.  It'll keep you motivated zeroing out balances and having fewer bills to pay every month.

 

Keep it simple:  don't worry about dropping utilization for all the cards (right now you're maxed out for all of them and don't have much room to maneuver), don't apply for new cards, don't apply for credit limit increases -- you'll likely not get them.  If you're being balance-chased, who cares?  You're not going to be using the cards anyway.  Besides, you can the CL back when you're debt is down to a more reasonable level.  

 

In 12 months, you'll have paid off all but 5 of your cc's.  At that point, you may think about spreading your payments (which would be around $1500/month) across the remaining cards, looking to lower utilization for all cards preparing to get lower interest loans.  In 16 months, you can be free of all credit card debt (providing you weren't adding to them during the payment period).  

 

Once you no longer have revolving debt, you'll have around $1700 extra to put towards your loans (hopefully now at much lower rates), which you can eliminate in another year to year and a half, depending on how aggressive you want to be.  

 

I would start socking away money into savings by the time you're done paying off the credit cards.  Close all but a few cards.  Keep spending in control.  Put all that money you were using for payments into savings.  Hopefully you'll build up enough savings that you would never fall into long-term credit card debt again.

Message 6 of 11
Kforce
Valued Contributor

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans


@SouthJamaica wrote:


I would leave the installment loans alone, just continue to make your payments.

 ( 2 of the 3 installment loans are at higher interest than his cards, I would also attack the loans)

 

With revolving accounts, I would recommend the snowball method:

1. Stop using cards. (Most important)
2. Pay off smallest balance first, then next smallest, and so on.

(Works well when one has a lot of cards and loans - Like your situation)
3. On other cards pay minimum + something each month.

(Add an extra $ 20 to each)
As each balance turns to zero, that will free up your remaining monthly cash to apply to the next smallest balance.

 (+1)

After you've paid off a subprime card with an annual fee, close the account.

 (+1)

As to the other accounts, leave them in place.

(Until all debt is gone, then some more cleaning might be in order)

 


Even without the snowball advantage of freeing up extra money to attack the debt, this is doable in about 1.75 years.

With the snowball about 1.5

 

Myfico2.png

Myfico1.png

 

Message 7 of 11
Catatonico
Valued Member

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

That's about the timeframe I was aiming for. And my weekly snowball amount that I have now (about $260) is just what I have budgeted for it. It's a minimum... I usually throw more at it when I have some extra (usually another $50-$100 a week) and my husband and I usually each get bonuses around Thanksgiving... They are normally around $3000 combined, and since I already have my Christmas money put up in savings, I was planning on using the bonus to kill some more debt.

So I'm getting there.
Keep on keeping on!
Message 8 of 11
xaximus
Valued Contributor

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

I think you have some great advise and suggestions above. I would definitely follow the snowball method myself. With some self-control, you should be able to knock out your debt in under 2 years. If you can throw more money at the debt, that'll definitely help bring that time table even shorter. If it's possible to add a part time gig, I would do that as well. Never hurts to have extra cash if you have the time for it.


Scores - All bureaus 770 +
TCL - Est. $410K
Message 9 of 11
Catatonico
Valued Member

Re: Need some help focusing my debt repayment plans

So... been about a week and I've been busy.  I got my annual bonus, so I have now paid off my PayPal MC.  The Discover card was paid off last week.  I've also paid off my CapOne QS1 Visa and upgraded my CapOne MC to another QS1 (kept the lower annual fee of $19 + added rewards).  I also got an $1800 CLI on my CareCredit card (my kid will eventually need braces, so that may come in handy).  Once my CapOne Visa reflects as paid, I'm going to try to combine the two accounts.

 

So, that will be all of my immediate goals accomplished... Now, I just continue with my debt repayment plans and enjoy watching the balances shrink.

 

Progress feels awesome!

Keep on keeping on!
Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.