cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Should I consolidate?

tag
OniStringer
Regular Contributor

Should I consolidate?

Alright so to preface this post. I just finished my rebuild, scores are back in the 700s. I was recently approved for an AMEX Gold and also the Chase Sapphire Preffered. I am pretty locked in on just using those 2 cards for all of my purchases and getting situated with travel points and such before I step up. 

 

I added about 10 inquires in the last few months in the midst of deciding where to go with my final remaining debts which ill list below.

 

OneMain Loan -$3573 - $195/mo

Upgrade Loan - $1475 - $145/mo

Cap 1 Savor CC - $1705 - Min $70/mo (Making higher payments to this right now, around $500 or more depending on spend each month)

 

Is it worth getting a personal loan to just pay these off and consolidate? I would still pay them off in the same amount of time. Or should I just add another inquiry, consolidate the debts, and then just let my credit sit for 2 years while I pay off that one final amount of debt. I dont see myself applying for anymore credit for at least 2-3 years.

 


Message 1 of 10
9 REPLIES 9
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?


@OniStringer wrote:

Alright so to preface this post. I just finished my rebuild, scores are back in the 700s. I was recently approved for an AMEX Gold and also the Chase Sapphire Preffered. I am pretty locked in on just using those 2 cards for all of my purchases and getting situated with travel points and such before I step up. 

 

I added about 10 inquires in the last few months in the midst of deciding where to go with my final remaining debts which ill list below.

 

OneMain Loan -$3573 - $195/mo

Upgrade Loan - $1475 - $145/mo

Cap 1 Savor CC - $1705 - Min $70/mo (Making higher payments to this right now, around $500 or more depending on spend each month)

 

Is it worth getting a personal loan to just pay these off and consolidate? I would still pay them off in the same amount of time. Or should I just add another inquiry, consolidate the debts, and then just let my credit sit for 2 years while I pay off that one final amount of debt. I dont see myself applying for anymore credit for at least 2-3 years.

 


No it's not worth it. Just follow your plan of paying stuff down, and using the 2 cards you're using.


Total revolving limits 586020 (520820 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 685 TU 691 EX 683




Message 2 of 10
Jnbmom
Credit Mentor

Re: Should I consolidate?

I agree with @SouthJamaica . You already have 2 loans not sure you used them for . I assume the rates might be on the high end ?

 

I would probably put that 500 on one of those loans and get one paid and then do the same with the other .

EXP 780 EQ 796 TU 810
Message 3 of 10
OniStringer
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?


@Jnbmom wrote:

I agree with @SouthJamaica . You already have 2 loans not sure you used them for . I assume the rates might be on the high end ?

 

I would probably put that 500 on one of those loans and get one paid and then do the same with the other .


Basically this time last year, on the verge of losing a job, and kinda just racked up debt to get by and try my best to preserve my credit as far as not being late or deliquent after being so close to my rebuild. Fast forward, somehow got by without adding anything bad outside of a few bad interest loans and high utilization, which as you can see im almost there thankfully lol 


Message 4 of 10
OniStringer
Regular Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?


@SouthJamaica wrote:

@OniStringer wrote:

Alright so to preface this post. I just finished my rebuild, scores are back in the 700s. I was recently approved for an AMEX Gold and also the Chase Sapphire Preffered. I am pretty locked in on just using those 2 cards for all of my purchases and getting situated with travel points and such before I step up. 

 

I added about 10 inquires in the last few months in the midst of deciding where to go with my final remaining debts which ill list below.

 

OneMain Loan -$3573 - $195/mo

Upgrade Loan - $1475 - $145/mo

Cap 1 Savor CC - $1705 - Min $70/mo (Making higher payments to this right now, around $500 or more depending on spend each month)

 

Is it worth getting a personal loan to just pay these off and consolidate? I would still pay them off in the same amount of time. Or should I just add another inquiry, consolidate the debts, and then just let my credit sit for 2 years while I pay off that one final amount of debt. I dont see myself applying for anymore credit for at least 2-3 years.

 


No it's not worth it. Just follow your plan of paying stuff down, and using the 2 cards you're using.


Similiary to what @Jnbmom said, also the only reason I am even choosing to pay the CC off quicker, is simply to get my utilization down asap. The other 2 payments are set amounts and monthly payments. Figured id stop accruing interest on that final CC before moving on to the two loans. Figured that was best to do? 


Message 5 of 10
Jnbmom
Credit Mentor

Re: Should I consolidate?

I am always finance over FICO . What are the rates of those loans.? 

EXP 780 EQ 796 TU 810
Message 6 of 10
FicoMike0
Valued Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?

Yes, pay the high rate card off first. Then manage the utilization on the three cards. Do azeo. Opps, do azeo on the two credit cards, the gold is a charge card. Personally I can't see fee cards until the other debt is paid, but that's just me. Make sure you get the subs on those cards.

Message 7 of 10
NoMoreE46
Community Leader
Senior Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?

The interest rate for the Savor One has got to be higher than the other two loans which are probably within 200 bp of each other but it doesn't really affect things. 

 

Given that the $500, $145 and $195 payments are static each month,  the plan of attack would be to pay all three off by about  Aug 2025.

 

  • Zero out the Savor One  $1,700  balance by paying $500 in Dec, Jan.  Feb and Mar.   
  • In Apr 2025, the Upgrade balance should be ~ $1,000.   At $645 per month  (500+ 145), this loan should be paid in the next two months.
  • In June,  OneMain balance should be ~ $1400.   At $840 per month (500+145+195),  this last loan should be paid by Aug 2025.

 

 


@OniStringer wrote:

Alright so to preface this post. I just finished my rebuild, scores are back in the 700s. I was recently approved for an AMEX Gold and also the Chase Sapphire Preffered. I am pretty locked in on just using those 2 cards for all of my purchases and getting situated with travel points and such before I step up. 

 

I added about 10 inquires in the last few months in the midst of deciding where to go with my final remaining debts which ill list below.

 

OneMain Loan -$3573 - $195/mo

Upgrade Loan - $1475 - $145/mo

Cap 1 Savor CC - $1705 - Min $70/mo (Making higher payments to this right now, around $500 or more depending on spend each month)

 

Is it worth getting a personal loan to just pay these off and consolidate? I would still pay them off in the same amount of time. Or should I just add another inquiry, consolidate the debts, and then just let my credit sit for 2 years while I pay off that one final amount of debt. I dont see myself applying for anymore credit for at least 2-3 years.

 


 

 

 

Message 8 of 10
ptatohed
Valued Contributor

Re: Should I consolidate?

I don't think enough information is provided.  OP, what are the APRs on your existing loans/balances?  Can you still borrow on the two existing loans?  If you did do some sort of consolidation, what could you get the APR(s) down to?  

5% CB rotating: ;
Everyday 3% CB: ;
Everyday 5%: ;
Companion Card: ;
Everyday 2.2% CB: ;
Retired to sock drawer after AOD (kept alive w/ 1 purchase every 6 mo): ;
On my radar: ;
Still Waiting for an Invite: ;
No hope:
Message 9 of 10
Robs931
New Member

Re: Should I consolidate?

Years ago I remember paying down my CapitalOne credit card and them offering 0 interest balance transfers and checks. I'm not sure if they still do that or not? I'm thinking about take a Onemain financial loan also. I heard it doesn't have an origination fee but it's a pain to make principal payments because you need to call them?

Message 10 of 10
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.