Hello everyone, it's been ages since I've been on this forum. I miss it, truth be told. So, quick recap of me : I defaulted on a bunch of cards back in 2009, and was in credit jail through 2016. Since 2017 I've been rebuilding credit and for the most part things have been going well. Post 2017, I've been gradually paying off old charged off accounts. I have a *big* one (40K) with a credit union that I'd like to pay off in full. However I remember reading years ago that if you pay off an account that's dropped off due to the 7-year rule, that you run the risk of being in a *new* 7-year "jail" of sorts because you run the risk of them reporting that the old account has been settled. So, I called the credit union and asked them if they could put it in writing that if I pay off, that they wouldn't report it.. I asked them if we could keep it a private matter between us. They put me on hold, talk to legal, and they came back and said words to the effect of "We will not put it in writing that we won't report it on your credit report. However, we won't put it on your credit report." So to me, this is fishy AF - I mean, if they are serious about not putting it on my credit report, why wouldn't they put it in writing? I'm so torn between doing the right thing but potentially ruining my credit life for another 7 years, or just abandoning that bank. Any ideas? Do I need an attorney?
he is correct. i had a 18k repo wiped off my record last year on all 3 bureaus. no lender or lawyer has ever contacted me about it. only time i ever actually disputed something. i only paid off one bank which was amex and have all whats in my signature from it but my debt is all from 2015-2016. most has dropped off. maybe one day i will pay off the rest if I can even remember what it was. only have one derog left from all the years. hasn't stopped me from getting cards. i am on a roll. last march it was 487 credit score. today it is 660. i never once considered bankruptcy.
800 CL
1000 CL
1000 CL
300 CL
2000 CL
2500 CL
250CL
2000CL
600CL
1000CL
1000CL
500CL
800CL
225CL
2000CL
300CL
500CL
1500CL
4000CL
no preset limit
no preset limit 
5000CL
1000CL
1000CL
2000CL 
1000CL 
200CL 
2000CL
You can safely take care of the debt as far as credit reporting goes. Legally they can't reinsert it no matter what. The 7 year period has elapsed. Nothing can change that fact.
Now, by acknowledging the debt/making a promise to pay/making a full/partial payment, you may restart the *SOL* for legal purposes, depending on state laws, but that aspect has nothing to do with the credit reporting.
Thank you for the replies. I'm aware of the SOL potentially restarting, but that's not what I'm concerned about. I'm talking about something actually showing up on my credit report. It's been years since I've been into this stuff, so my memory is fuzzy on the details but I recall someone mentioning that if you pay off an old account, that the lender may insert some note on your credit report stating "settled" in reference to your old charged off account, with the date of the settlement. So even though the bad debt itself technically can't be re-inserted, the fact that you've settled recently may show up. That's what I'm concerned about. If I understood it correctly at the time, it would seem that this issue would not affect my credit score, but it would definitely be noticed by a human manually reading through my credit report. I hope this is clearer...?
@onepointatatime wrote:Thank you for the replies. I'm aware of the SOL potentially restarting, but that's not what I'm concerned about. I'm talking about something actually showing up on my credit report. It's been years since I've been into this stuff, so my memory is fuzzy on the details but I recall someone mentioning that if you pay off an old account, that the lender may insert some note on your credit report stating "settled" in reference to your old charged off account, with the date of the settlement. So even though the bad debt itself technically can't be re-inserted, the fact that you've settled recently may show up. That's what I'm concerned about. If I understood it correctly at the time, it would seem that this issue would not affect my credit score, but it would definitely be noticed by a human manually reading through my credit report. I hope this is clearer...?
It can't be reinserted, therefore there'd be nowhere for a "settled" comment to be reported on the account. The only way a human would notice is when undergoing manual review if they pull up internal records (completely separate from your credit reports) if you were to apply for a card with your CU again. But if applying with other lenders, then it'll be as if that negative account never existed (they won't see it on your credit report - settling won't make it reappear in any way, shape, or form).