Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Negotiate PFD Over Phone or In Writing??


Negotiate PFD Over Phone or In Writing??

I recently received a settlement offer from Wells Fargo for my Dillard's card. I would like to take the offer, because it is 40% off of my balance, but I would like to negotiate a PFD when I settle. Should I negotiate the PFD over the phone or via mail?? If I negotiate over the phone, should I require them to send the PFD agreement in writing??

Message 1 of 4
Established Contributor

Re: Negotiate PFD Over Phone or In Writing??

Documentation is unquestionably always preferred. I’m pesstimisitc that WF will comply with your request. But I wish you all the best and I’m pulling for you! 😊
Started 6/6/2018 EX - 588 ; EQ - 667 ; TU 575

Updated 12/2018

Message 2 of 4
Established Contributor

Re: Negotiate PFD Over Phone or In Writing??

I would shoot for doing both, you can always hope for the sympathetic human on the other end of the line, if not a well thought out letter can go a long way.Good luck.

~~ Former Royal Navy Submariner - Proud to have served ~~
Message 3 of 4
Legendary Contributor

Re: Negotiate PFD Over Phone or In Writing??

As with any contract negotiation, it is more prudent to reduce the agreement to writing.

However, for business reasons, furnishers are often reluctant to reduce to writing an agreement to delete in exchange for payment of the debt.


The CRAs want to maintain the completeness, and thus value, of their product, and dont want relevant credit history information subjectively deleted by furnishers.  They thus have a policy, as stated in both their credit reporting manual and their credit reporting agreements, that furnishers not delete based on payment of the debt.


An oral agreement made as a condition for payment comprises a binding contract, but of course can be more difficult to prove should you need to go to court to enforce the oral contract.

If you live in a state that permits one party recording of phone converstations, you could record the agreement.


In most cases, I would recommend asking for a written agreement, but if they balk, I would still proceed rather than kill the deal.

Message 4 of 4
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.