cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

understanding FICO/bureau categorization of auto loans

tag
expatCanuck
Super Contributor

understanding FICO/bureau categorization of auto loans

Hi folks.
15-20 years ago, I applied for a Honda car loan.

That loan was characterized by the bureas as a sub-prime/sub-optimal/whateverTheCorrectTermIs loan that dragged down my FICO score (a bit) for a while.

 

We are now buying a (new to us) Mazda.   I'm considering a decent enough financing offer available through Mazda's Certified Pre-Owned arm (my Auto FICO8 is 826 / FICO2 is 790).

 

Might anyone know how that Mazda CPO loan would be categorized by the bureaus (i.e. - a 'normal'/'good credit' loan, or a 'sub-prime' loan)?


2023 Goal: save 3 months' net income

Starting FICO8: 666 (give or take a FICO)
[ Last INQ 12-Feb-2024 ]
EQ8472 INQ (Auto, Mort)7y4m
EX8486 INQ (2 CC, 2 mort, 2 auto)7y
TU8501 INQ (CC)6y8m
3/241/12AoYA 10m | AoOA 24y2m~3%
9 REPLIES 9
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans


@expatCanuck wrote:

Hi folks.
15-20 years ago, I applied for a Honda car loan.

That loan was characterized by the bureas as a sub-prime/sub-optimal/whateverTheCorrectTermIs loan that dragged down my FICO score for a while.

 

We are now buying a (new to us) Mazda.   I'm considering a decent enough financing offer available through Mazda's Certified Pre-Owned arm (my Auto FICO8 is 826 / FICO2 is 790).

 

Might anyone know how that Mazda CPO loan would be categorized by the bureaus (i.e. - a 'normal'/'good credit' loan, or a 'sub-prime' loan)?


You'd be purchasing through Mazda Financial Services ?  I'm pretty sure this would show up as a regular auto loan, and not be classified as Consumer Finance. 

 

Who was the lender on your prior loan, and you're sure it was classified as a Consumer Finance account ?

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 2 of 10
expatCanuck
Super Contributor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans

The lender on the prior loan was Honda Financial.
Here's the thread I started almost 5 years ago:
https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Understanding-FICO-Scoring/Consumer-Finance-Account/m-p/5538749

 

Fun fact -- my Bankcard 3 score today is the same as it was then - 775.
My (EX) FICO8 today is marginally higher, but both still between 810 & 820.

(EQ & TU scores now closer to 850 than 800.)


2023 Goal: save 3 months' net income

Starting FICO8: 666 (give or take a FICO)
[ Last INQ 12-Feb-2024 ]
EQ8472 INQ (Auto, Mort)7y4m
EX8486 INQ (2 CC, 2 mort, 2 auto)7y
TU8501 INQ (CC)6y8m
3/241/12AoYA 10m | AoOA 24y2m~3%
Message 3 of 10
Brian_Earl_Spilner
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans


@pizzadude wrote:

@expatCanuck wrote:

Hi folks.
15-20 years ago, I applied for a Honda car loan.

That loan was characterized by the bureas as a sub-prime/sub-optimal/whateverTheCorrectTermIs loan that dragged down my FICO score for a while.

 

We are now buying a (new to us) Mazda.   I'm considering a decent enough financing offer available through Mazda's Certified Pre-Owned arm (my Auto FICO8 is 826 / FICO2 is 790).

 

Might anyone know how that Mazda CPO loan would be categorized by the bureaus (i.e. - a 'normal'/'good credit' loan, or a 'sub-prime' loan)?


You'd be purchasing through Mazda Financial Services ?  I'm pretty sure this would show up as a regular auto loan, and not be classified as Consumer Finance. 

 

Who was the lender on your prior loan, and you're sure it was classified as a Consumer Finance account ?


MFS is handled by TFS. I have no idea if my Lexus loan is showing as a CFA unfortunately.

 

https://pressroom.toyota.com/mazda-north-american-operations-renews-agreement-for-toyota-motor-credi...

    
Message 4 of 10
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans

I might be in the minority here but I'm one of those who believe that the FICO penalty for CFAs is relatively minor.   At least from my own experience, it's certainly possible to have both a CFA and scores well over 800.  

 

I'll add here that I also believe that CFAs can be either revolving or installment accounts, depending on the lender.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 5 of 10
expatCanuck
Super Contributor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans

Thanks, @Brian_Earl_Spilner.

 

Post #5 in this thread suggests that TFS reports as an auto loan
https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Auto-Loans/Toyota-Financial-Approval/td-p/6478896

 

And, @pizzadude, agreed.  I'm not terribly concerned about a clamitous FICO fall -- just want to know what to expect.


Not expecting my score to stray from dark green.  Certainly not for long, anyway.  Livin' the dream within my means ... .


2023 Goal: save 3 months' net income

Starting FICO8: 666 (give or take a FICO)
[ Last INQ 12-Feb-2024 ]
EQ8472 INQ (Auto, Mort)7y4m
EX8486 INQ (2 CC, 2 mort, 2 auto)7y
TU8501 INQ (CC)6y8m
3/241/12AoYA 10m | AoOA 24y2m~3%
Message 6 of 10
Brian_Earl_Spilner
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans


@expatCanuck wrote:

Thanks, @Brian_Earl_Spilner.

 

Post #5 in this thread suggests that TFS reports as an auto loan
https://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Auto-Loans/Toyota-Financial-Approval/td-p/6478896

 

And, @pizzadude, agreed.  I'm not terribly concerned about a clamitous FICO fall -- just want to know what to expect.


Not expecting my score to stray from dark green.  Certainly not for long, anyway.  Livin' the dream within my means ... .


CFA is a hidden tag. The only way you would know it's there is if you receive a denial, for example, and it listed the CFA as a reason for denial. At that point, you'd have to look at your reports and track score changes with report changes.

 

I've seen it mentioned that Toyota was reported as a CFA. But another user was unable to find anyone other than me saying it. Another thing to keep in mind is if a lender does report CFA, it won't report for every loan. We have plenty of datapoints where Honda reported as CFA, but we also have other datapoints that it didn't. 

    
Message 7 of 10
expatCanuck
Super Contributor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans

It may be a hidden tag, but (at least in my case) sometimes the presence of a 'Consumer Finance Account' is specified as a reason for a lower score.


2023 Goal: save 3 months' net income

Starting FICO8: 666 (give or take a FICO)
[ Last INQ 12-Feb-2024 ]
EQ8472 INQ (Auto, Mort)7y4m
EX8486 INQ (2 CC, 2 mort, 2 auto)7y
TU8501 INQ (CC)6y8m
3/241/12AoYA 10m | AoOA 24y2m~3%
Message 8 of 10
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans

In this case you're both right -- the FICO scoring reason for CFAs can show as one of your negative scoring factors.

 

The hidden tag @Brian_Earl_Spilner is referring to is how creditors assign accounts to be CFAs, we don't have any way to see this.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 9 of 10
Brian_Earl_Spilner
Credit Mentor

Re: understanding FICO categorization of auto loans


@expatCanuck wrote:

It may be a hidden tag, but (at least in my case) sometimes the presence of a 'Consumer Finance Account' is specified as a reason for a lower score.


Like I said, that's the only way to know if you have one. Now you'd have to go through your report to figure out what is tagged as a CFA. 

    
Message 10 of 10
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.