cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

Hi everyone!

First time poster here! Been recently working on my credit actively.
I want to apply for an Amex charge card in the next few months but I'm unsure which one to go for and what will get approved. Fico EX is 640. TU is 651. Credit utilization is 17%. AAoA is 3.5 years. Income is 48K. Have one charge off collection derogatory (paid less than original amount) Smiley Sad when I called Experian they said it'll fall off in 2020. At the time I paid it I didn't know about the pay for delete and all that. Completely stupid I know. Payment history is 100%.
What do you think my odds are? I would also like to apply for the sky miles gold the same day, is that advisable?

Other credit cards 1) Cap 1 Platinum $4k, Cap Quick silver $500, Discover It $1400, Credit 1 (my oldest card 6 years) $1350, first premier also an old account $500.

I'm trying to lower my credit utilization to 11%. Last year I opened up Cap 1 quicksilver in august and discover it in December. Please excuse my lack of info and lingo.. I'm still new at this.

TIA
Message 1 of 11
10 REPLIES 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

The PRG is the way to go in terms of the charge cards you mentioned? I will have mine for a year and if there are no retention offers for me when the AF hits I will cash out the MR's I have and use my BCE solely. The Gold and Green seem absolutely pointless to me. I also have to say wait a bit and get those scores up.

Message 2 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

I was approved for amex PRG about 8 months ago.  FICO in thfe 650's, but the only inq or new account was my mortgage 2 years ago.  I think you should app

Message 3 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

Thankyou so much I really want to also. I've read on this board how it's not uncommon to get approval with EX score in 640-650 range.
Message 4 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

As others have said, hold off on apping until you get your scores up. As for which of the three, it depends on your needs but the PRG makes the sense for most. If you travel a lot and fly, the Platinum may be better, but if you don't travel frequently, the PRG. 

Message 5 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

Amex is really hard to read..

 

Got denied for my first Amex app for the BCE and reason for denial was my EX score being low at 650.

 

Re-Appd after couple a months and got approved for 1K and listed my EX Fico as 668.

 

Received an offer for the Amex Platinum couple of weeks ago. My current EX Score was around 659 last week and was instantly approved. Well it probably had to do with the prequal offer.

 

Now I can't even get Amex to bulge on CLI request..

 

So I agree with the others here on keep working on your scores before apping.

Message 6 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

Personally, I have their Green Charge Card and I love it. Been very helpful and helps establish a relationship with them. I'm not too particular about rewards because I already have cards that offer great rewards but if you're just looking to start a relationship with American Express, go for the Green card. Many people I'm sure will disagree with me, but I think the green card is great. Best of luck to you
Message 7 of 11
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?


@Anonymous wrote:

Amex is really hard to read..

 

Got denied for my first Amex app for the BCE and reason for denial was my EX score being low at 650.

 

Re-Appd after couple a months and got approved for 1K and listed my EX Fico as 668.

 

Received an offer for the Amex Platinum couple of weeks ago. My current EX Score was around 659 last week and was instantly approved. Well it probably had to do with the prequal offer.

 

Now I can't even get Amex to bulge on CLI request..

 

So I agree with the others here on keep working on your scores before apping.


$1K Amex revolvers are known to stay at that limit for a long time. That's why it's better to wait until your profile is solid before applying for one of them, so you don't get stuck at a low limit for 6 month - 3 years. 

Message 8 of 11
UncleB
Credit Mentor

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?


@Anonymous wrote:
Personally, I have their Green Charge Card and I love it. Been very helpful and helps establish a relationship with them. I'm not too particular about rewards because I already have cards that offer great rewards but if you're just looking to start a relationship with American Express, go for the Green card. Many people I'm sure will disagree with me, but I think the green card is great. Best of luck to you

The Green card is OK if someone just needs/wants a charge card, but the reason most people prefer the PRG is because of the sign-up bonus, and there's no AF the first year.  If you see that you're not using the extra benefits, you can PC to a Green before the first AF is due and keep the bonus MR points.  Smiley Wink

 

Also, the PRG has a $100 airline fee credit, so if someone flies at all (or is otherwise able to take advantage of the fee credit) that makes the PRG annual fee effectively $95 ($195 - $100) which is the same as the Green card... and it earns MR points at a higher rate than the Green card, too.

 

I actually got the Green card myself back in 2015 (I wasn't well-read on the differences at the time) and I ended up closing it so I could app for the PRG and get the bonus.  At the time, IIRC my scores were around 680; they approved my Green and my BCP for $1k at the highest APR.  They made me wait 18 months before they would give me a CLI on the BCP, and even then it was an auto-CLI (they have yet to approve a CLI request initiated by me). 

 

They look at more than just score, which is why some are approved at 645 and others are declined at 680.  There's no way to know without just trying, however I will say that unless there's an urgent need I would probably wait until I knew my chances for approval were at their highest (especially since there's no special 'bonus' at the moment that I'm aware of).

 

Just my 2¢.  Smiley Wink

Message 9 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Green, Gold or PRG?

I got approved for the PRG in December but I have an 800+ credit score so that won't help you OP but I will say it's the best charge card from Amex (unless you live in airplane; go Plat then). If you do decide to app for both cards, do the Charge first then revolver on the same day!
Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.