cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

BOA denial reasons...recon FAIL

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

BOA denial reasons...recon FAIL

My EX finally cleared of BK records and I decided to app for BOA platinum plus. Instant denial.

Got their letter today, score was 741. Denial reasons were:
Too many new accounts opened recently
Limited deposit and/or investment balances with us and/or our affiliates

So....do I recon? Interesting that no relationship is a reason...wonder if I opened a checking/savings account if that would help.
Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

How many new accounts in the last six months? The other reason doesn't matter. Probably need to wait at least 90 days with no new accounts to bring them on board.
Message 2 of 9
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

OP, they've tightened some of the UW a bit so it's likely a YEMV on the outcome, especially if you have several new accounts/inquiries very recently.

It can't hurt to try... worse case scenario they say no.
Message 3 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

6 total new accounts in 6 mo-
2 cards in Nov (Sam’s MC & PenFed Promise)
2 in Dec (RBFCU & NFCU)
1 in Jan (PenFed PLOC)
Message 4 of 9
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

In their eyes, and based on your profile, they may consider that too many in such a short period. I suppose you'll know where you stand depending on the outcome of the reconsideration.
Message 5 of 9
creditguy
Valued Contributor

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

BofA is a bank that does factor in your banking relationship to an extent. My personal experience was they wouldn't touch me but when I opened a checking account and moved some money there they changed their tune and gave me a card, my profile hadn't changed much since my previous app so I assumed the banking relationship had helped. BofA can be weird sometimes and they can be conservative so if anything I'd say the too many new accounts reason is probably the one that's weighing against you the most. I'd probably let them age before reapplying and if you want them that bad opening a checking account won't hurt. Best of Luck. 

Message 6 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon?

Only the initial reason really makes sense.  Was BOA or any of its affiliates IIB?

Message 7 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon FAIL

My recon was almost comical....here is how it went....

Asked credit analyst to look at my app and reconsider.

She pulled app and started rattling off all my skeletons. Filed BK, mortgage default, credit card defaults...on and on (all in a very nice tone). Finally She gets to the good parts of my report and mentions an open Cap One loan.

Pause...um, my Cap One loan was closed in June 2017. I asked what agency my report was from because all of those baddies were no where to be found on my EX! She verified it was EX. I asked when the report was from because my copy shows none of that. Then she said...are you calling about your app from April 2017?

Uh no...I knew it was a lost cause at that point...how could she even pretend to ignore all of the terrible things she just read?

Just for fun had her open the real app. In the nicest way possible she proceeded to (pretend I’m sure) to reconsider the app. At decision time she said, you’ve opened a lot of accounts since your BK, we would need to see time between those. I couldn’t even fight it. But I can’t help but wonder if the result might have been different had she not opened the wrong App.

Lesson learned 😂
Message 8 of 9
BM3
Regular Contributor

Re: BOA denial reasons...recon FAIL

I have 1 old baddy (2 years since report), 710-769 scores. I put 3.5k into BOA checking monthly. Got student loans but they aren't reporting.

 

What SL can i look at, its funny they wouldnt give me anything but the secured card, now they offer Visa Travel Rewards, and Cash Rewards and regular Boa cc.

Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.